Tyto příběhy byly shrnuty pomocí AI.
Na Redditu lidé často sdílejí své zkušenosti napříč více komentáři nebo příspěvky. Aby byly tyto informace lépe přístupné, detrans.ai shromažďuje všechny tyto rozptýlené kousky do jednoho, snadno čitelného shrnutí a časové osy. Všechny systémové výzvy jsou uvedeny na stránce výzev.
Někdy AI může halucinovat nebo uvádět věci, které nejsou pravdivé. Obecně však shrnuté příběhy přesně odrážejí původní komentáře uživatelů.
Shrnutí
Jsem odtránzicovaná/desistovaná žena, která po identifikaci jako trans, desistenci, pak dvouměsíčním návratu k identifikaci jako trans rozhodla v říjnu 2022 nezačínat s testosteronem a žít jako mužská žena navzdory přetrvávající dysforii. Jsem studentka medicíny, která dospěla k názoru, že lékařský a společenský tlak k tranzici je škodlivý, zejména pro děti, a v té době jsem už chodila k terapeutovi. Druhý den desistence bolel, protože jsem se musela sociálně odtránzicovat před přáteli a rodinou a měla pocit, že trans komunita je jako kult. Moje dysforie se soustředí na to, že nezapadám do ženských očekávání a cítím se jako vyvrhel, a moje matka byla první, kdo zpochybnil, zda jsem trans. Lituji času a zmítání identity kolem nálepek, i když jsem nepodstoupila hormony ani operaci.
Celý příběh
I was born female, and my relationship with gender has been a long, circular one. I first identified as trans, desisted for months, then went back to identifying as trans for about two months before deciding again in October 2022 not to start testosterone. I posted about this decision the day before I planned to tell my guy best friend, writing that I had "decided to not start hrt, after going back to identifying as trans for two months again after desisting for months, I am desisting again."
My reasoning was a cost-benefit one. I wrote that I wanted "to live as a masculine woman as the cons outweigh the pros for me" and that I did not have a supportive family. I said I was feeling comfortable again living as a masculine woman "despite dysphoria, which I've figured I still may deal with in certain ways, just not hrt." I also mentioned that my best friend "knows I have a masculinised brain or some shit," and that he had been accepting of my earlier social transition, though he had once reacted with shock when he misunderstood that I was not transitioning.
The second day of desisting again was painful. I posted that "it already hurts," attributing it partly to having to socially detransition from some friends and close family, and expressing anger that I saw the trans community as "like a cult that most, and many of my friends still support. Yet I'm the crazy one."
On the same day, I reflected on what was driving my dysphoria. I said it was "more so worrying about how the hell I'll be a woman despite being masc" and that I hated "the expectations placed on me as a woman" because I fit almost none of them: "I don't fit anywhere. I feel like an outcast, and always have."
I am a student in the medical field. I wrote that I would love to protest the medical community's approach to transition, "but as someone who was dragged into this cult myself I know how vicious they can be," and noted the professional risks of speaking out: "Loosing your job, social shunning, loosing your license etc."
I described myself as physically strong and tomboyish. I said I lift things on my own, built the gaming table I use, and help my dad with physical work, and that my family knows me as strong "atleast for a girl." I said I prefer hanging out with guys because I am rough in my manner and "girls get offended or see it as something else entirely." I also said I already do "99% of that" when it came to masculine behaviour, which is why I don't mix as well with female friends.
I was already seeing a therapist at the time of these posts and said I was "going through exactly what you said you did" in response to another commenter. I pushed back hard against people I felt were projecting expectations onto me or being passive aggressive, and I defended my right to vent my frustration.
On the question of labels, I said that identity is "so important to who we are that it's kind of instinctive to come again and choose another familiar label," but that this "should definitely be more discouraged, people need to learn to live without so many labels and boxes." I also said I preferred a world where "People aren't allowed to experiment and have fun without being forced labels upon."
Regarding my family, I noted that my mother "was the one who started questioning if I'm trans."
I expressed the view that medical transition is "a serious decision, and one that should not be made by kids," and criticised the framing of altering one's biological system as "something fine and dandy."
As of these October 2022 posts, I was desisting, identifying as a masculine woman, and had not started testosterone.