Tyto příběhy byly shrnuty pomocí AI.
Na Redditu lidé často sdílejí své zkušenosti napříč více komentáři nebo příspěvky. Aby byly tyto informace lépe přístupné, detrans.ai shromažďuje všechny tyto rozptýlené kousky do jednoho, snadno čitelného shrnutí a časové osy. Všechny systémové výzvy jsou uvedeny na stránce výzev.
Někdy AI může halucinovat nebo uvádět věci, které nejsou pravdivé. Obecně však shrnuté příběhy přesně odrážejí původní komentáře uživatelů.
Shrnutí
Jsem detranzicionovaná žena z Itálie, která se od 14 do 18/19 let (2019 až konec 2022) identifikovala jako trans chlapec, sociálně tranzicovala, ale nikdy nebrala hormony. Detranzicovala jsem poté, co jsem si uvědomila, že tranzici používám k vyrovnávání se s jinými problémy, včetně sebedestruktivní hraniční poruchy osobnosti, a po studiu radikálního feminismu se má genderová dysforie vyřešila. Tranzice mě stála středoškolská léta, přátelství s dívkami a vztah k mé víře a vedla k záchvatovému přejídání, které mě dostalo z 60 kg na 105 kg s inzulinovou rezistencí, i když jsem od té doby zhubla na 97 kg. Stále se nedokážu cítit jako dívka — v zrcadle vidím své staré trans já, lituji piercingů a jednoho tetování a potýkám se s ženskostí, altovým hlasem a sociální izolací. Zastávám transmedikalistický názor, že tranzice by měla být vyhrazena malému počtu skutečně dysforických a psychicky stabilních lidí.
Celý příběh
I am a 22-year-old woman from Italy. I identified as a trans boy (FTM) from 2019, when I was 14, until late December 2022/2023, when I detransitioned. I only socially transitioned — I was on a hormone waitlist but detransitioned before ever taking HRT, and I'm grateful, because I was a teenager and it wasn't easy to get hormones in Italy back then. I used the name Amos. I was diagnosed with gender dysphoria and with self-destructive borderline personality disorder (BPD) a couple of years ago.
Looking back, I realize I was using transition to solve other problems. Going through my old 2019 diaries, I saw that I was essentially manipulating myself into being trans. I don't have genital dysphoria and I never had dysphoria toward my feminine characteristics; I don't want to be a man. What I have is an unbearable discomfort with what it means to live socially as a woman. I studied radical feminism for several years, which helped me understand the roots of my discomfort and even resolved my GD, but the discomfort itself persists. I hate being judged first as a woman and then as a person — my intelligence gets overlooked, my body gets sexualized (I have big breasts and an apple/rectangle body type, which I'm fine with in itself, but men sexualize them), and I feel part of a vulnerable social group. I stopped singing because I hate having a sexualized female voice (I'm an alto), I stopped leaving my house for political activism because I'll never be seen as politically active, just 'a woman.' Being called a woman feels like an insult when others do it, though it's fine when I call myself one.
The transition years cost me a lot. I missed all of high school, never formed deep friendships with other girls, and had problems with my non-denominational Christian faith. I gained weight through binge eating as self-medication: about 60 kg in 2019 at 165 cm, reaching 105 kg by December 2025, with insulin resistance (though I never had PCOS and my estrogen was actually high). Since December 2025 I've lost weight down to 97 kg and can stick to my diet because I no longer self-medicate with food. I also compulsively cut my hair (now a bowl cut), got septum and eyebrow piercings and a 'satanic' tattoo I regret and find cringe as a deeply religious person. I've been diagnosed with self-destructive BPD, which makes me avoidant; I'm theoretically bisexual but feel little attraction to anyone. I have no friends and live in a big, dangerous city in Southern Italy since September, where men are aggressive toward women. I'm terrified of being assaulted — I went through a period of leaving the house with a knife — though I've never been sexually assaulted; the only negative contact with men was my father, who beat me but never did anything sexual. I've been catcalled a couple of times as a teen. Doctors have been unhelpful and scare me.
I hold a transmedicalist view: I think transition should only be for people who are truly, diagnosed dysphoric and mentally stable, and that being trans is a rare disorder, not a common social phenomenon. I've met about two genuinely trans people whose lives improved through transition, but I also think most people who identify as trans have other mental health issues like BPD or PTSD. I would never want children. I currently have no interest in transitioning and want to feel like a normal girl, but I can't — when I look in the mirror I still see 'the guy' I thought I was, and I'm angry at having lost the girl I wanted to be.