Tyto příběhy byly shrnuty pomocí AI.
Na Redditu lidé často sdílejí své zkušenosti napříč více komentáři nebo příspěvky. Aby byly tyto informace lépe přístupné, detrans.ai shromažďuje všechny tyto rozptýlené kousky do jednoho, snadno čitelného shrnutí a časové osy. Všechny systémové výzvy jsou uvedeny na stránce výzev.
Někdy AI může halucinovat nebo uvádět věci, které nejsou pravdivé. Obecně však shrnuté příběhy přesně odrážejí původní komentáře uživatelů.
Shrnutí
Jsem detranzicionovaná/dezistovaná žena, narozená jako žena, která nikdy nebrala hormony ani nepodstoupila operaci, ale prožila období touhy tranzicovat a nyní se prezentuje maskulinně, což mám každý rok raději. Je mi 51 let, jsem lékařka a členka GETA (Gender Exploratory Therapy Association) a aktivně doporučuji genderově explorativní terapii, Genspect a Therapy First ostatním v komunitě. Zastávám silně genderově kritické názory: pohlaví vnímám jako biologický fakt, nikoli identitu, jsem kritická k tomu, co nazývám trans ideologie, a k lékařskému/korporátnímu vykořisťování genderové tísně, a jsem obzvlášť skeptická k blokátorům puberty a k tranzici u nejistých mladých lidí. Domnívám se, že pornografie a online grooming přispívají k dysforii u dospívajících dívek, a na tato témata jsem napsala dva příspěvky. V tomto přepisu nepopisuji žádné sebevražedné myšlenky, sebepoškozování ani pokusy o sebevraždu.
Celý příběh
I am a woman, born female, who identifies as desisted — I never took hormones or had surgery, but I lived through a period of wanting to transition and I now present in a masculine way that I enjoy. I am 51 years old as of May 2023, and I have been presenting masculinely as a woman for about 50 years, which I say gets better every year.
My own story is not one of medical intervention. When I talk about my 'binder years,' I mean I hid my female body parts in men's clothing; I describe possibly 'hiding' my female body in men's clothing during that time. I no longer have a uterus but I do have ovaries, so I still ovulate and get monthly hormonal symptoms such as breast swelling. I have no children mentioned. I have been in at least one relationship with a man who had autogynephilic interests — I say 'I was in a relationship with one and there are plenty.'
I came to a settled, comfortable relationship with being a masculine-presenting woman over decades. I explicitly say it 'took me some decades' and that being a lesbian (or at least someone attracted to women) means you get 'more and more attractive with age, starting around 40,' when you are freed from the male gaze. I experience real pleasure in my body now — my breasts give me pleasure, and that pleasure deepened after 40. I also express grief for what others have lost: I wrote 'I'm so sorry you lost your nipple sensitivity and breasts, as they are giving me so much pleasure!' to a detransitioner.
I am a physician. I say this directly: 'I'm physician, I just can't believe the risk we are letting our young people take.' I am angry at my own profession for how it handles transition medicine — 'I'm so angry at my profession' — because I believe surgeons care only about optics six months post-surgery, not whether the individual patient is actually happy. I am also involved with GETA, the Gender Exploratory Therapy Association: 'I'm part of Geta, there is a clinical guide with all the science on their webpage.' I actively recommend GETA and Therapy First to people posting in the community, and I mention Genspect as a resource that may fund detransition stories.
I have strong, clearly stated views about what drives dysphoria and transition, especially in young women. I suspect pornography aggravates body and gender dysphoria in female adolescents, and I wrote a post titled 'ROGD, porn, grooming and unease with becoming a woman' asking whether porn consumption should be assessed during gender dysphoria evaluation. I am open about my own reaction: 'I am ashamed when I see these images of objectified women, stereotypes, and it definitely increases my unease with my own female appearance. So I do not like these stereotypical clothes and wear masculine clothes. But it did not extend to my body.' I also wrote a second post asking about adult contacts with male-identified youth considering transition, wondering whether such contacts are sexual in motivation.
I hold a firmly binary, biological view of sex and am critical of what I call 'trans ideology.' I argue that 'being female is not an identity, it's a biological fact,' that nobody 'feels' female except trans women, and that 'assigned sex' language reflects essentialist thinking. I am sharply critical of what I see as medical and corporate exploitation of gender distress — I have written that the 'born in the wrong body' idea makes gender identities 'perfectly exploitable by the fast growing market of pharmaceutical and surgical and therapeutical industry,' and that identifying 'as' something is a marketing device. I am also critical of puberty blockers, writing that they 'reduce your intellectual capacity for life, reduce your bone density for life... They may make you sterile.' I have been blunt with posters considering orchiectomy, calling it having 'already mutilated your body.'
I have written about autogynephilia (AGP) and homosexual transsexualism (HSTS) as explanatory frameworks, and I believe AGP-affected individuals may have played a key role in motivating the medicalization of gender-dysphoric youth. I have also written about the Dutch protocol's origins in older transwomen's wishes. I am critical of what I see as cis women's tendency to adopt trans women as a 'victim category' to protect rather than engaging with them as full people. I am skeptical of nonbinary identification, writing 'Nobody can be "one of the girls"' and questioning the sex distribution of nonbinary speakers.
I recommend gender exploratory therapy frequently, along with antidepressants (like sertraline) to reduce libido when that is the issue, and I advise people to try less invasive steps before surgery. I encourage people to build lives outside the 'gender bubble' — hobbies, community work, sports, caring for others. I have been direct with posters I think are being poorly served by their therapists or doctors, telling them to find new ones. I have also been involved in conversations about lawsuits and organizations like Partners for Ethical Care supporting people who want to pursue legal action.
I do not describe any personal suicidal ideation, self-harm, or suicide attempts. My mental health journey was about coming to terms with my body and my presentation over decades rather than through crisis. I have written warmly to others in acute distress, telling them 'It will get better. Even if you don't believe it now. Life is best around 50.'
I am critical of transition for most young people, especially when they are uncertain — 'if you doubt, don't do it' — and I am skeptical of trans friends who discourage exploring opposing viewpoints. At the same time, I am not uniformly opposed to transition: I have written that there are trans women who have fought for women's rights and that some people genuinely benefit from transition, and I have told some posters that living openly as a trans woman might be a better solution for them than a failed male passing attempt. My overall stance is that transition should be a last resort after genuine exploration, therapy, and building a life, and that gender nonconformity should be supported without medical intervention.