Tyto příběhy byly shrnuty pomocí AI.
Na Redditu lidé často sdílejí své zkušenosti napříč více komentáři nebo příspěvky. Aby byly tyto informace lépe přístupné, detrans.ai shromažďuje všechny tyto rozptýlené kousky do jednoho, snadno čitelného shrnutí a časové osy. Všechny systémové výzvy jsou uvedeny na stránce výzev.
Někdy AI může halucinovat nebo uvádět věci, které nejsou pravdivé. Obecně však shrnuté příběhy přesně odrážejí původní komentáře uživatelů.
Shrnutí
Jsem dezistovaná, genderově kritická žena, která je dezistovaná už pár let a pracovala s terapeutem na řešení své dysforie bez tranzice. V únoru 2026 jsem ztratila dva přátele (muže přecházející k ženskému pohlaví), kteří mě kvůli mým názorům ignorovali a zablokovali, přestože jsem je opakovaně ujišťovala, že podporuji svobodu dospělých podstoupit operaci a nikdy bych nepodpořila nic, co by jim ublížilo. Udržuji komunikaci otevřenou pro případ, že by detranzicovali, a respektuji volbu lidí měnit svá těla, zároveň kritizuji sociální prostředí trans komunity jako kultovní a rozdělující. Identifikuji se jako biologická žena, věřím, že ženy mají právo být ostražité vůči lidem vypadajícím jako muži v ženských prostorech, a zastávám názor, že muži nemohou být podle definice lesbami. V tomto materiálu nepopisuji žádné lékařské intervence, operace ani diagnózy duševního zdraví.
Celý příběh
I am a desisted, gender critical woman. I have been desisted and gender critical for a couple of years now (as of early 2026). I was born female — I refer to myself as a "bio female" and speak as a woman about women's spaces.
My own transition history is not something I laid out in detail in these posts; what I have shared publicly is that I desisted a couple of years ago and that I have worked with a therapist on my dysphoria without transitioning. When someone asked about therapy, I said that a worthwhile therapist will help you work on what you want to work on, and that if you tell a good therapist you want to work on your dysphoria without transitioning, they should help you with that — which reflects my own approach of seeking to address dysphoria without medical transition. I also advised that you have to shop around until you find a therapist whose personality and methods click with you, which suggests I have been through that process myself.
In February 2026 I lost two good friends, both male-to-female, over my gender critical beliefs. Many of my friends knew about my reservations towards the trans community, and we had previously agreed to amicably disagree on many things. I thought they knew I wouldn't want any harm to them. Then, as I put it, "the cultish nature of the trans community finally got to them though, and they ghosted me with no explanation." We had been talking like normal that morning until suddenly they cut all communication and blocked me on almost everything. Only one of our mutual friends finally got them to explain what happened. I was frustrated and sad; I said I knew it was a risk when I made trans friends, but I can't help but be sad anyway, and I wished they had explained because I would've been understanding. I felt reduced to "some 'terf' who doesn't deserve the decency."
I have kept the line of communication open on my end in case they decide to detransition. I told them very thorough explanations of my beliefs and they still chose to cut me off, though I wasn't too surprised. I reiterated to them multiple times that I would never support anything that would harm them or restrict their ability as adults to undergo surgery if they wish, but that wasn't good enough. I noted they may not realize that cutting me off could push me toward supporting the harsh policies they fear — which I won't do because I value people's personal freedoms.
My views on other people's transition are tolerant but critical: I dislike the social environment surrounding the trans community, but I respect people's choices to change their bodies. To me it is no different than any other elective cosmetic procedure or surgery; I just wish it wasn't so encouraged and divisive. I speculated that one of my ex-friends might have been a mild autogynophile and that the other may have had genuine dysphoria, though I don't know for sure. I wish we could have all been friends without this getting in the way — they were some pretty awesome people.
On women's spaces, I believe women are right to be wary of male-seeming people entering our vulnerable spaces, and I advised someone in that position to just try to ignore it and, if confronted, explain that they are a bio female if comfortable doing so — you aren't hurting anything by being there. I hold a firm biological position on sex and sexuality: in March 2026 I stated flatly that "Males cannot be lesbians by definition."
I do not describe any surgeries, hormones, or medical complications in these posts, and I do not describe my current mental health beyond the frustration and sadness of losing these friendships. I have not described any activism beyond posting and commenting in gender critical spaces.