Nämä tarinat on tiivistetty tekoälyn avulla.
Redditissä ihmiset jakavat usein kokemuksiaan useissa kommenteissa tai viesteissä. Jotta tämä tieto olisi helpommin saatavilla, detrans.ai kerää kaikki hajallaan olevat osat yhdeksi helposti luettavaksi yhteenvedoksi ja aikajanaksi. Kaikki järjestelmäkyselyt on merkitty kyselysivulle.
Joskus tekoäly voi hallusinoida tai väittää asioita, jotka eivät ole totta. Yleensä tiivistetyt tarinat kuitenkin heijastavat tarkasti käyttäjien alkuperäisiä kommentteja.
Tiivistelmä
Olen detransitioitunut nainen, joka identifioitui transmieheksi vuosia. Opin trans-asioista 15-vuotiaana, transitioiduin sosiaalisesti 16-vuotiaana, aloitin testosteronin 19-vuotiaana ja kävin läpi kaksinkertaisen mastektomian 23-vuotiaana, ennen kuin lopetin testosteronin äkillisesti alle kolme kuukautta myöhemmin. Transitio oli traumaattinen polku, jota ajoivat kehonkuvaongelmat lapsuuden seksuaalisen hyväksikäytön, diagnosoimattoman autismin ja seksismin takia. Kaksi vuotta testosteronin lopettamisen jälkeen menen yhä läpi miehenä ja kamppailen transfobian kanssa, ja käytän sukupuolineutraaleja tiloja välttääkseni vihamielisyyttä. Kokemukseni vaikeaa premenstruaalista dysforista häiriötä ja minut raiskattiin detransition jälkeen.
Koko tarina
I learned about trans stuff at 15, did a partial social transition at 16, and was fully out by 18. I started testosterone at 19 and had a double mastectomy at 23. I stopped T cold turkey less than three months after the surgery, and I was on it for about six years total in one description and five in another. I passed as a cis man while on T. Now, two years off T, I still pass as a gay man or a trans woman depending on what I wear, and I look shorter because of lost muscle.
My pathway to transition was trauma. I needed safe adults in my life, I needed treatment for CSA, I needed a world less sexist, and I needed to be diagnosed with autism. I view gender dysphoria as a very specific type of body dysmorphia. These days I'm more likely to say I have body image issues as a result of CSA, and those body image issues present as discomfort with my sexed body and wanting to have the other sex's features to "be safe from/around men." Gender dysphoria is simply the diagnosis that fits with "discomfort with your sexed body," even if you have very valid reasons to feel that discomfort. It's just the wording on my medical file.
I've watched transition be the "treatment" for CSA body image issues again and again. I've watched it be an autistic mask for undiagnosed autistic individuals trying to find their place in the world. I've watched being trans and straight be the better option to being gay. I've seen transition be a way to escape sex-based violence, oppression, and stereotypes. Where I am, I was denied publicly funded gender-focused therapy, so my only treatment option was $5 every three months for T. When you get diagnosed with gender dysphoria, the treatment is hormones and surgery. Therapy to work through underlying issues isn't the treatment; it isn't even discussed as an option.
A lot of transition involves bending reality to justify why you're really trans. I look back and all the "signs" that I was trans are now gone because they're nothing more than a little girl struggling with body image issues due to CSA, struggling to fit in with her peer group because of undiagnosed autism, and just general GNC. Now that I don't identify as trans, my life isn't being over-analysed to justify why I'm really a "man." If there wasn't a constant dismissal of detransitioners and the denial of the link between CSA and gender dysphoria, I would have gone about things differently.
I stopped T cold turkey and it caused a lot of mental health breakdowns, but I just didn't feel able to talk to a doctor about it. If you have PMDD or a history of bad moods around period times, then stopping T can lead to significantly worse moods until hormones stabilize. I have really bad PMDD that makes me suicidal every month. I think it's less that it's another "gender affirming care thing that's wildly understudied" and more that it's classic sexism resulting in poor medical healthcare around the female body.
With detransition, women in my life still act like I have male privilege, like I don't experience any of the discrimination that comes alongside being female. They also seem to think the simple act of me no longer identifying as trans means I get to just be cisgender. I get to deal with transphobia and homophobia for looking visibly queer, and detransphobia because people seem to think the simple act of no longer identifying as trans means I get to just walk away from all the social consequences of medical transition. I just want to put my transition behind me, but it feels like I'm stuck living as a man because of how I look and sound.
As a detrans female, living as a trans man was safer than being detrans. Since detransition, a part of me getting SA'ed has been rooted in not identifying that I pass as female to some and that this comes with an element of social danger. At the same time I still pass too much as a man to use women-only spaces without judgement or harassment from women. One thing with detrans women is trying to balance your own safety with the comfort of the women around you, which can make trying to understand what you look like an even bigger obsession.
I still consider myself cis. I'm just not at a stage in detransition where I can just be a woman, so I tend to use the non-binary label and gender-neutral spaces to avoid hostility. I wouldn't recommend going into trans spaces; instead do something like make a YouTube channel talking about your transition and detransition. I don't like when detrans studies are trans-focused. Adding a trans pride flag and a rainbow pride flag in a detrans study is kinda yucky since the focus really shouldn't be on the trans community.
I was on T for 5 years, passed as a cis man, 2 years off T I still pass as a man. With facial hair removal you want electrolysis for permanent removal. You want to avoid going down a body dysmorphia surgery pathway. Things within a cis range you want to avoid changing. You want to get to a passing stage then learn to love yourself and avoid further surgeries. A lot of transition is just not fitting stereotypes and transitioning to conform; with detransition you want to avoid following that pathway again. Sometimes full detransition is just about accepting that you're you, there's no need for more labels that make you different from other women just because you're not a stereotype.
Transition isn't treatment for trauma, it only delays healing and worsens things. It needs to be okay to have open conversations about the other things in life that can cause gender dysphoria. There is zero talk of how gender dysphoria can be treated without transition without it being labelled as conversion therapy, so if you're liberal the idea of therapy helping is painted in a negative light. A lot of online trans spaces operate in a way that worsens your mental health and make you desperate. It's a lot like having an eating disorder and spending time in eating disorder forums.
I'd suggest waiting till 1 year off T to socially detransition, it shows commitment to detransition so people won't be as worried that it's an impulsive choice. Honestly don't use the word detransition, detrans is seen as a dirty word. With leftists it's better to simply say "hey just letting you know I currently go by name and she/her."