Nämä tarinat on tiivistetty tekoälyn avulla.
Redditissä ihmiset jakavat usein kokemuksiaan useissa kommenteissa tai viesteissä. Jotta tämä tieto olisi helpommin saatavilla, detrans.ai kerää kaikki hajallaan olevat osat yhdeksi helposti luettavaksi yhteenvedoksi ja aikajanaksi. Kaikki järjestelmäkyselyt on merkitty kyselysivulle.
Joskus tekoäly voi hallusinoida tai väittää asioita, jotka eivät ole totta. Yleensä tiivistetyt tarinat kuitenkin heijastavat tarkasti käyttäjien alkuperäisiä kommentteja.
Tiivistelmä
Olen detransitioitunut/desistoitu mies, joka ei koskaan ottanut naisellistavia hormoneja mutta oli lähellä sitä useita kertoja, ja nykyään identifioidyn mieheksi, joka on sinut mieskehoinsa kanssa, mutta koen yhä toistuvia haluja näyttää naiselliselta. Olen 37-vuotias, asun Pariisissa ja päätin olla tekemättä transitiota sydänterveysriskien, sosiaalisen hylkäämisen pelon, työhön ja turvallisuuteen liittyvien huolten ja läpipääsyn kuorman vuoksi. Terapia, mukaan lukien psykiatri ja taideterapia, auttoi minua hyväksymään itseni, vaikka kamppailen yhä emotionaalisesti katumusta siitä, etten ole nainen. En toistaiseksi kadu sitä, että olen detransitioitunut, ja olen hyvällä tiellä itsehyväksynnässä. Minulla on ehdollinen näkemys: kunnioitan transitiota niille, joilla on vakava kehodysforia, mutta en usko sen sopivan kaikille.
Koko tarina
I was born male and I have never taken feminising hormones, though I came very close to starting them at several points. I am 37 years old as of February 2023, and I live in Paris, France.
My struggle has been with wanting to look female rather than with a decision I made and reversed. I describe myself as a "desist MtF almost did it" — I got close to transitioning but ultimately did not, for health and societal reasons. I did a lot of therapy, including seeing a psychiatrist and doing art therapy (I used AI-generated art to portray my dysphoria), and I say that therapy "worked wonders into accepting who I was." Even so, I told others in the community that I still struggle with my gender identity and my sexuality.
The urge to feminise has never fully gone away. I wrote in December 2022 that I try to suppress it but "it ALWAYS come back at some point," and that I am "more or less made peace with it" while remaining deeply attracted to feminisation as part of my sexuality — expressed through clothes and sport to achieve desired curves rather than drugs. In January 2023 I described being "back on the loop again" whenever one of several layers of wanting to be a woman catches me, and I said I was "so fucking tired of wanting to be female everyday."
I have identified multiple distinct reasons I want to be a woman: environmental (wanting to be with a man in a "traditional couple" as my family and strangers outside would see it, without fear of homophobia); familial (my mother would have preferred a daughter); sexual; and social/hobby-related (I have many female friends and get along well with them, and I like a lot of things considered feminine). I also envied beautiful trans women. In March 2023 I added another layer: I wanted to seduce heterosexual men, whom I find more attractive than gay men, and I said that attraction to men as a man is probably one of the reasons I wanted to transition, and that the guilt I feel is mostly about that attraction.
In February 2023, talking with my psychologist, she asked me a question about my transition and I was fine at first but then had "a huge surge of emotion, sadness and regret" about not being a woman, or not transitioning as a teenager or young adult. I said I had dealt with accepting not being a woman on the surface but not emotionally, and I asked others how to stop it hurting.
My stated reasons for not transitioning were: fear of health problems (I specifically cited heart risk for trans women, and shared an Everydayhealth article about it); fear of social rejection and of having a hard time finding jobs; fear for my personal safety in Paris, where in transports I could be an easy target for people who are not trans friendly; fear about passing; and being overwhelmed by the amount of work required to pass as female (voice, operations). I decided it wasn't worth it and that I should work on self-acceptance, making peace with my body and my sexuality.
I have been cautious about medical steps even short of hormones: in April 2023 I considered laser hair removal to be more feminine but decided against it, saying I want to be happy in the body nature gave me and that I was scared of "going ballistic spiraling on a feminising dawnfall" if I started that trend.
As of April 2023 I wrote: "I'm on a good track by doing just this and I do not regret being a detransitioner so far!" I also said I sometimes regret not doing it (not transitioning). I have not described any surgeries, hormones, or puberty blockers.
My attitude toward transition for other people is mixed and conditional: I have said I have huge respect for trans people and that transition is the way for some people, but "only those with major body dysphoria and crippling struggle with their body." I have also said that I personally don't think detransition is necessarily good for everyone, and that people who are happy with how they look and are perceived shouldn't feel bad. I have been active in the r/detrans community, encouraging comprehension and empathy rather than hate, and I have advised others to take their time, see a psychiatrist, and consider writing their feelings down.