Kaikki tarinat

Asianajajan sota sukupuoliklinikoita vastaan — siirtymättä koskaan itse

Nainen · Luopunut93
Nämä tarinat on tiivistetty tekoälyn avulla.

Redditissä ihmiset jakavat usein kokemuksiaan useissa kommenteissa tai viesteissä. Jotta tämä tieto olisi helpommin saatavilla, detrans.ai kerää kaikki hajallaan olevat osat yhdeksi helposti luettavaksi yhteenvedoksi ja aikajanaksi. Kaikki järjestelmäkyselyt on merkitty kyselysivulle.

Joskus tekoäly voi hallusinoida tai väittää asioita, jotka eivät ole totta. Yleensä tiivistetyt tarinat kuitenkin heijastavat tarkasti käyttäjien alkuperäisiä kommentteja.

Tiivistelmä

Olen 42-vuotias australialainen nainen ja juristi, syntynyt naiseksi, enkä ole detransitioitunut mutta olen aktiivinen sukupuolikriittisessä liikkeessä Australiassa. Kasvoin väkivaltaisen BNPD-äidin kanssa ja minulla oli syömishäiriö ja riskikäyttäytymistä teininä ja nuorena naisena, vihasin itseäni 30-luvun lopulle asti, jolloin lopetin juomisen, karsin myrkylliset ihmiset pois ja tein rauhan kehoni kanssa. Kampanjoin sukupuoliklinikoita vastaan, autoin painostamaan Australian liittovaltion terveysministeriä tutkintaan valtion sukupuoliklinikoista, ja neuvon dysforisia teinejä menemään yleiselle psykologille sukupuoliterapeutin sijaan ja jättämään kehonsa rauhaan. Vastustan sitä, mitä näen naisten rajojen rapautumisena trans-identiteetin omaavien miesten toimesta, ja kritisoin subjektiivista 'trans'-sanan laillista määritelmää.

Koko tarina

I am a 42-year-old woman and a legal professional in Australia with an interest in gender-related law and medicine — I am not a detransitioner myself, but I am active in the gender-critical movement here. I was born female and I am a mother. I grew up with an abusive mother who had borderline and narcissistic personality disorder (BNPD). As a teenager and younger woman I had an eating disorder and engaged in a lot of risky behaviour — drugs, 'bad men' — and I did a great many things to dissociate from who I was because I hated myself. It was only in my late 30s that I finally stopped hating myself; I also stopped drinking and cut a lot of toxic people out of my life, and I made peace with my body, which felt like a weight had lifted. I describe that as possibly a maturity thing. On Reddit I post mostly in gender-critical and detrans-adjacent discussions. I argue forcefully against what I call TRAs and 'trans-identified males', saying I will not respect anyone who 'seeks to dismantle safeguards, erode women's boundaries and colonise women's spaces'. I quote the UK High Court's Justice Julian Knowles on 'TERF' being a derogatory term used to deplatform people who hold different views, and I object to being told I cannot have boundaries. I say that as a female and a mother I assess risk from males in order to protect myself and my children, and I say I would regard a trans-identified male with even more suspicion because of AGP and because transvestism is, in my view, a top-three fetish of sexual predators. I also criticise the legal definition of 'trans' as subjective and confusing, and I have linked to academic work by Dianna Kenny on children and young people seeking gender dysphoria treatment in Australia. I give practical advice to people posting about gender dysphoria: I recommend speaking to a GP and getting a referral to a general psychologist — explicitly not a gender clinic or a gender therapist, because 'they will just affirm, put you on a medical pathway and won't help you explore and address any other issues'. I warn that hormones can seriously mess with your emotions as a side effect. I tell teenagers that it is okay to be female and not like 'girls' stuff, okay to hate your breasts because they get in the way and draw unwanted attention, and that it may take years or decades but one day they will make peace with their body and be glad they left it alone. I suggest finding an older woman in their life who doesn't care about appearance to talk to. I also raise the possibility of suing doctors: I ask whether someone was underage, whether their cognitive functioning was impaired to the point they weren't truly giving informed consent (for example through an eating disorder, being non-neurotypical, depression or anxiety), and whether all risks were explained, saying that if they rushed someone through they should be held accountable. I am part of the movement in Australia that pressured the federal health minister into launching an inquiry into state-run gender clinics. I call it 'completely unethical and malpractice' that young women are being encouraged or allowed to have surgery without addressing underlying issues, and I have called the situation 'a terrible scandal'.