Kaikki tarinat

Ei koskaan transitoinut — vietti 2022 muiden dysforiaa valvoen

Mies · Luopunut156
Nämä tarinat on tiivistetty tekoälyn avulla.

Redditissä ihmiset jakavat usein kokemuksiaan useissa kommenteissa tai viesteissä. Jotta tämä tieto olisi helpommin saatavilla, detrans.ai kerää kaikki hajallaan olevat osat yhdeksi helposti luettavaksi yhteenvedoksi ja aikajanaksi. Kaikki järjestelmäkyselyt on merkitty kyselysivulle.

Joskus tekoäly voi hallusinoida tai väittää asioita, jotka eivät ole totta. Yleensä tiivistetyt tarinat kuitenkin heijastavat tarkasti käyttäjien alkuperäisiä kommentteja.

Tiivistelmä

Olen henkilö, joka ei koskaan transitioitunut, mutta vietin aikaa verkossa detrans- ja sukupuolikriittisissä tiloissa vuonna 2022, kannattaen vahvasti sukupuoliesentialistisia näkemyksiä ja ilmaisten huolta trans-identtisiksi itsensä määrittelevien nuorten medikalisoinnista ja steriloinnista. Muistan, että oma gynekomastiani murrosiässä hävisi muutamassa vuodessa, ja päädyin näkemyksiini osittain seuraamalla, kuinka sukupuolikeskustelu räjähti Tumblrissa. Esitin salaliittoteoreettisia epäilyksiä koordinoidusta vaikutusvallasta nuorten trans-identifioitumisen kasvun taustalla, samalla myöntäen, että luin ehkä liikaa salaliittoteorioita. Olen ollut suorasukainen ja kriittinen dysforiasta kertovia kirjoittajia kohtaan ja kyseenalaistanut, liioittelevatko he. En kerro koskaan identifioituneeni trans-henkilöksi tai käyneeni läpi mitään lääketieteellistä transitiota.

Koko tarina

I was born male. I went through puberty and developed gynecomastia, which resolved on its own within a few years — I told another poster that "when i went through puberty i had gynecomastia and just a few years later it was all gone" and that I expected them to be "totally back to normal in just 2-4 years." I also mentioned that in high school I thought I was ugly, but that "college went completely differently for me with women," which taught me that many people are seen as desirable by others without ever being told so. I don't describe ever identifying as trans myself, nor any medical transition of my own; my account is largely about other people's transitions and about the concept of gender. I recall being on Tumblr "during the glory days" and watching gender-identity discourse "blow up huge in real time out of nowhere," noting that "no one was talking about 'gender' being different from sex at all in the 00s." I have discussed these views with two of my best friends, who came to similar conclusions. I expressed strong concern about the medicalization of young people, particularly the sterilizing effects of testosterone on young women and surgeries on young men, saying "there have to be tens of thousands of people who have been sterilized by transmedicalization already." I voiced suspicion about coordinated influence behind the rise in youth trans-identification, pointing to the Pritzker family's involvement in transgender-related fields and drawing a parallel to Margaret Sanger and Planned Parenthood, arguing that if eugenic goals could be pursued openly through abortion, similar dynamics could be at play with hormones distributed to minors. I acknowledged I might be "reading about too many conspiracy theories lately." I hold a sex-essentialist view of gender, arguing that gender as separate from sex was "completely manufactured by gender theorists in academia" and that unmeasurable internal feelings cannot alter biological sex. I told one poster that usually 60-90% of teenagers who identify as transgender desist by age 25. I have been critical and blunt toward posters describing dysphoria or discrimination, questioning whether they are catastrophizing and telling them that "modifying your body or pretending to be the opposite sex will not make you more of yourself than you already are." I do not describe any detransition process, therapy, mental health diagnosis, family dynamics, romantic relationships beyond the college reference, or current identity beyond these expressed views.