Nämä tarinat on tiivistetty tekoälyn avulla.
Redditissä ihmiset jakavat usein kokemuksiaan useissa kommenteissa tai viesteissä. Jotta tämä tieto olisi helpommin saatavilla, detrans.ai kerää kaikki hajallaan olevat osat yhdeksi helposti luettavaksi yhteenvedoksi ja aikajanaksi. Kaikki järjestelmäkyselyt on merkitty kyselysivulle.
Joskus tekoäly voi hallusinoida tai väittää asioita, jotka eivät ole totta. Yleensä tiivistetyt tarinat kuitenkin heijastavat tarkasti käyttäjien alkuperäisiä kommentteja.
Tiivistelmä
Olen detransitioitunut nainen, aloitin testosteronin 18-vuotiaana, kävin läpi mastektomian ja hysterektomian ja elin miesidentiteetissä noin 14 vuotta, kunnes hyväksyin vähitellen naispuolisen biologiaani noin 2022–2023. En koskaan mennyt läpi hyvin miehenä lyhyen vartaloni ja naisellisten piirteideni takia, mikä vahingoitti työ- ja sosiaalista elämääni. Hormonien lopettamisen jälkeen koin nopeita naisellisia kehomuutoksia (leveämmät lantiot, paksuuntuneet reidet), jotka olivat aluksi vaikeita hyväksyä. Hyväksyn nyt she/her ja sen, että minut nähdään naisena, vaikka kuvailen itseäni yhä poikatyttömäiseksi (tomboy) ja sanon, etten tunne olevani nainen sukupuolimielessä. Olen neuvonut muita, että transitio on "vain harvoille".
Koko tarina
I was born female and started testosterone at 18, so by the time I was writing about my situation in 2021 I had been on T for about 14 years. I had already had a mastectomy, a hysterectomy, and a legal ID change, but I never wanted genital surgery. Despite all of that, I never passed convincingly as a man: I am very short (5'3"), with a small, delicate, feminine face, and people regularly called me "ma'am," "miss," "young lady," or sometimes "fellow" or "young man." I described myself as an advanced trans man who still felt uncomfortable and unrecognized as a man, always caught between two genders. Someone once called me a "half-man," and that stuck. I had ruined my professional life trying to live a hidden life because I was too androgynous.
I hated being female — I wrote that I hated having XX chromosomes and was extremely demanding about male passing: wanting to be taller, stronger, with a more masculine jawline. I said I had seen myself as male since forever, but experienced it as a curse rather than something neutral. Sports, swimming, and video games were the things that let me escape; I loved swimming but said I would never wear a women's swimsuit.
In April 2021 I posted asking whether I should live as an androgynous trans man or as a butch woman, saying I sometimes thought it would be simpler to assume myself as a butch woman to avoid the daily confusion. A week later I reversed course, saying that even though I was not satisfied with the transition, I definitely felt like a man and would never become a butch woman. Through late 2021 and into 2022 I kept affirming I had decided to stay a trans man, though I acknowledged I was androgynous and trying to accept it.
A shift was happening though. In February 2022, at 32, I said that unlike at 18–28 when being treated like a woman made me furious, I was caring less about being perceived as one. By March 2022 I posted about a grocery store interaction where a cashier called me miss, then offered to say sir, and I said "No, miss, it's okay." I wrote that after 20 years with average passing I was accepting not being seen as a man, that what mattered was the perception of my loved ones, and that I was making peace with being a biologically feminine person — while still saying "I don't feel like a woman." I said I could accept she/her and miss/ma'am because they refer to biological reality, not social identity, and that I had given up the "vain fight" to be male biologically.
Around the same time I started calling myself a tomboy rather than a man, saying "there's 'boy' in that term" and that it didn't deny my biological reality. In April 2022 I posted advice to others saying "We cannot choose our sex, it is a biological reality. I was born a woman like you and I will remain so for life," and that transition is "only for a few people." In April 2022 I was in a relationship with a heterosexual man I described as great and very manly; I told him I had identified as a trans man, and he was respectful about my body, but I felt vulnerable naked, tried to hide my curves and sex, and said I had never been able to tolerate penetration even with foreplay and lubricant, fearing he would be disappointed.
Physically, after stopping testosterone my hips widened, thighs thickened, and buttocks increased rapidly — changes I said were "even too fast" for me and which I tried to hide under wide tracksuits. I noted I no longer had breasts. I live in France, where public pool rules are strict, and I described the awkwardness of being called "miss" at the entrance and then using the men's locker room. By May 2022 I was posting about swimsuit options post-detransition, embarrassed by both men's and women's swimsuits.
By December 2022, at 33, I wrote that I had recently accepted being a woman and being gendered accordingly: no one called me Mister anymore, only Miss or Madam, men treated me like any woman, and I now wore one-piece women's swimsuits. I said I had lived longer under a male identity but that with my wide hips and 5'1" stature I was more in my place as a woman. In February 2023 I wrote "I have XX chromosomes so I am a woman," that I felt ridiculous pretending to be a man, and that while I was not really a woman in the gendered sense, I was sure I could never be a man. In May 2023 I posted asking whether a detransitioned woman could date a trans man without tension. I never described suicidal ideation or self-harm.