Nämä tarinat on tiivistetty tekoälyn avulla.
Redditissä ihmiset jakavat usein kokemuksiaan useissa kommenteissa tai viesteissä. Jotta tämä tieto olisi helpommin saatavilla, detrans.ai kerää kaikki hajallaan olevat osat yhdeksi helposti luettavaksi yhteenvedoksi ja aikajanaksi. Kaikki järjestelmäkyselyt on merkitty kyselysivulle.
Joskus tekoäly voi hallusinoida tai väittää asioita, jotka eivät ole totta. Yleensä tiivistetyt tarinat kuitenkin heijastavat tarkasti käyttäjien alkuperäisiä kommentteja.
Tiivistelmä
Kävin läpi MTF-transition hieman yli vuoden ajan yliopistoaikoina, mihin vaikuttivat osittain depersonalisaatio/derealisaatio sekä uppoutuminen transkulttuuriin Twitterissä ja perustamallani queer-alaredditillä, ja olen sittemmin detransitioitunut ja identifioidun jälleen mieheksi. Detrans-kaapista tulo oli pelottavaa, mutta kukaan ei suhtautunut asiaan kielteisesti, ja olen rakentanut itseni uudelleen käymällä kuntosalilla ja hankkimalla menetettyjä lihaksia takaisin. Olen harkinnut rintakehäleikkausta jäljellä olevan rintakudoksen hoitamiseksi, mutten ole vielä käynyt siinä. Kirjoitin laajaa keskustelua herättäneen julkaisun, jossa esitin transsukupuolisuuden leviävän meemisten/kulttuuristen tartuntamekanismien kautta, ja olen jättänyt transyhteisön täysin taakseni. Pohdin edelleen, miten kertoa detrans-taustastani kumppaneille.
Koko tarina
I was mtf for a little over a year in college, and I've since detransitioned. I'm pretty young still, and I live in the New York City area. When I was questioning and transitioning, I had depersonalization/derealization that nobody else seemed to understand except for the trans community, and I think that was a big part of what pulled me in. I was also drawn in through Twitter, where I became immersed in a full-fledged culture — people with similar values, sources of truth, and reactions to events. I created a pretty large queer subreddit at one point, so I saw firsthand how these memes operate, with jokes built around trans = good, cis = bad. I think the ideology has good intentions, but it spread so well because it had strong mechanisms of spread. I don't think any trans lobbying group sat in a room and planned it, and I don't blame any single trans individual.
Coming out as detrans was scary because I had staked a lot on my transition and had to go back. I started by stopping dressing up, acting more masculine, and saying I wasn't sure for about a month, then cut my hair and fully embraced masculinity again. I already knew I was a man, but it helped me get accustomed to it and softened the blow to other people. Not a single person cared — if they were supportive before, they'd be supportive now. Family was a bit of a question box; I told them not to talk about it or make a big deal because it's uncomfortable for me. I was surprised by how much people didn't really care.
Going to the gym was probably my first lifestyle change during detrans, and it made me feel way more masculine. I had to regain the muscle I lost. I work out regularly, so I've gotten more attractive. I've thought about whether porn inspired my transition — personally I don't see a connection, and I didn't hear about it inspiring anyone I knew, though I did find it weird how common piss kinks, pet play, free use and other things were in that space. I was disgusted by some threads in detrans communities too — one in particular was toxic, probably anger based on past traumas.
I've thought about getting top surgery as a detrans person (MTFTF). I think I'm finally close to a place of financial means and independence where I can do it. I don't have large breasts, but they stick out a bit and look a little weird, though I don't know if most people notice. I had questions about what would be removed, whether there would be scars (scars would be a dealbreaker for me), cost, and recovery time.
On disclosing to partners: it doesn't affect me now so it doesn't need to be immediately disclosed. As you get to know each other, let them know. For me, it's unknown to anyone who didn't know me during transition. I would tell my partner, but only if it's relevant or if we're talking about our past or I want to vent about something related to that.
I wrote a long post theorizing about how transgenderism spreads as a memetic set, focusing on the male-to-female experience because that's what I'm familiar with. I described how it starts with general left-wing politics and a desire to help oppressed groups, moves into cognitive reframing through repeated memes, and then hooks people who are insecure in particular ways — like my depersonalization/derealization, or for others, lack of female attention or serious depression. I argued that 'you don't need dysphoria to be trans' is told to people in the final stages of questioning as a last push, and that it's irresponsible because it allows retroactive declaration of old behavior as dysphoria. I noted that friend groups often transition together, that newly trans people prime their brains to notice signs in friends, and that some people glamourize the lifestyle on social media. I also described how the community excommunicates people deemed gender critical as an 'antibody' to outside ideas. I acknowledged my theory isn't proven and much of what I cite is anecdotal, more like an anthropology paper than research. I've completely left the trans community now. I wish I could share these ideas with trans people so they could build systems to avoid unintentionally dragging people in, resulting in fewer detransitioners and less trans hate.
I believe there are people who are really trans and people who are infected by a memetic set. I don't think dysphoria itself is social contagion, but the identity itself can be. I also believe you can internally feel a sense of gender, even though I don't think you can internally feel a certain race. I'm aware people might be against me for speaking against the current trans narrative, though it's not always the case. I think it's important for something as serious as gender transition that people be aware of the factors at play that make them do certain things.