Nämä tarinat on tiivistetty tekoälyn avulla.
Redditissä ihmiset jakavat usein kokemuksiaan useissa kommenteissa tai viesteissä. Jotta tämä tieto olisi helpommin saatavilla, detrans.ai kerää kaikki hajallaan olevat osat yhdeksi helposti luettavaksi yhteenvedoksi ja aikajanaksi. Kaikki järjestelmäkyselyt on merkitty kyselysivulle.
Joskus tekoäly voi hallusinoida tai väittää asioita, jotka eivät ole totta. Yleensä tiivistetyt tarinat kuitenkin heijastavat tarkasti käyttäjien alkuperäisiä kommentteja.
Koko tarina
I've been thinking a lot lately about how I ended up here, writing in a detransition community, and how much of my own story I see reflected in the conversations we have. I was born female, and I dealt with gender dysphoria when I was young. Looking back, I think a lot of what I was struggling with was internalized misogyny — a sense that being a girl was somehow lesser or wrong. What actually helped me when I was a youth was having riot grrrl punk friends. They instilled in me this notion that there's no wrong way to be a girl. I had short hair and wore boy clothes, but I also learned this mentality of "fuck you! I'm a girl!" Whichever way I am is still a good way to be a girl. I genuinely believe that if I were a young person in this day and age, my punk rock girlfriends would most likely have affirmed my discomfort and confusion about my body, my personality, and what I am — and that worries me, because I don't think that would have helped me the way their actual approach did.
I count myself lucky that my gender dysphoria subsided once I sorted out my internalized misogyny and embraced that "fuck you! I'm a girl!" mentality. I don't talk in detail about any medical steps I may or may not have taken, but I do know what it's like to sit with a feeling of incongruity and wonder whether changing your body will fix it. When people reach out to me now, I tell them what I wish someone had told me: please work on healing your trauma and improving your brain first, because changing your body over a mental state will not solve it. I point people toward therapyfirst.org because I used to feel the same way they do — skeptical, hopeless, sure that transition was the only answer — and I'm beyond thankful that I gave myself time and care for that feeling to pass. I suspect they will be too.
I still wear male clothing sometimes, honestly. It's cute, and it's more affordable, lmao. But I no longer read that as evidence that I'm something other than a woman. There's no wrong way to be a girl, and XX and XY can be anything except the other.
On the broader cultural conversation, I have strong opinions. I think detransitioners are twice victims: of gender ideology, and then of the system's overcorrection in response. I believe there should be a biological sex marker in addition to a gender identity marker on documents — let there be two. You know, the things I believed were separate: gender identity has nothing to do with sex. Can we acknowledge reality and still be nice? I'd hope so. But I also recognize there are many who won't acknowledge reality and let identities step on sex-based rights.
I'm skeptical of a lot of the claims I see from activists. When people call transition "life saving," I ask: is it chemotherapy? A blood transfusion? An organ transplant? I've never understood that language. When I see claims about intersex people being invoked in these debates, I note that none of them have been tested — they're just ✨identifying✨ as intersex. And people with DSDs have repeatedly asked to be left out of these arguments because they know they are still male or female.
I've spent time reading and watching other people's stories, which has helped me process my own. I've recommended Buck Angel's YouTube channel, where he interviews detransitioners and talks about the problems with gender ideology — he's very compassionate and rides hard for women. I've pointed people toward Gender: A Wider Lens and Benjamin Boyce for thoughtful discussions about gender, and suggested searching "detransition" on YouTube filtered by newest. Scott Newgent's interview on Buck Angel's channel about how phalloplasty destroyed his health and life struck me as powerful yet devastating. I've also followed Shapeshifter, an MtF who can't afford to detransition — medical transition was a horrible path for him that destroyed his health, and insurance won't cover his breast implant removal. He feels he was groomed and manipulated into transitioning by a group of AGPs. Grayson's Projects is another person I've mentioned — she lived male-presenting for six years and then simply detransitioned without announcement, deciding pronouns never really mattered as much as people convinced her they did.
I have complicated feelings about sexuality and ideology. I've told people that innate sexual orientations aren't allowed in gender ideology, and that the language espoused by activists makes such little sense that nobody knows what they mean — but they chant it with such fervor that those without the time or energy just say, "okay, sure." I've described gender ideology as a religious faith. I've also been blunt with people I think are transitioning for the wrong reasons, asking directly about AGP and porn use when I think it's relevant.
I don't have a formal advocacy role, but I do speak up — in comment threads, to friends, to strangers reaching out. I try to be kind while still being honest. I tell people they don't have to "come out" or make announcements; just keep being your beautiful self in the only body you have. I believe accepting your biological reality is much more likely to lead you to a romantic partner whose attraction and affection will help you understand how perfectly good your body always has been. I'm grateful for where I've landed, even if the road was longer than it needed to be.