Nämä tarinat on tiivistetty tekoälyn avulla.
Redditissä ihmiset jakavat usein kokemuksiaan useissa kommenteissa tai viesteissä. Jotta tämä tieto olisi helpommin saatavilla, detrans.ai kerää kaikki hajallaan olevat osat yhdeksi helposti luettavaksi yhteenvedoksi ja aikajanaksi. Kaikki järjestelmäkyselyt on merkitty kyselysivulle.
Joskus tekoäly voi hallusinoida tai väittää asioita, jotka eivät ole totta. Yleensä tiivistetyt tarinat kuitenkin heijastavat tarkasti käyttäjien alkuperäisiä kommentteja.
Tiivistelmä
Olen desistoinut mies, joka identifioitui transnaiseksi verkossa ja muutamalle läheiselle noin kahden vuoden ajan mutta ei koskaan ottanut hormoneja tai käynyt leikkauksissa. Ymmärrän nyt dysforiani vakavana kehodysmorfiana sekä kateutena naispuolista vuorovaikutusta kohtaan, juurtuen epäonnistumiseeni sopeutua sosiaalisesti teinipoikana. Kadun syvästi menetettyjä kriittisiä vuosia eristäytymiseen, mikä saa minut edelleen kyyneliin, ja häpeän sitä, että vanhempani tietävät tuosta ajanjaksosta. Olen toipumassa, rakennan sosiaalista elämää uudelleen ja suhtaudun kriittisesti siirtymiseen vastauksena dysmorfiaan sekä trans-yhteisön kulttuuriin. Tällä hetkellä identifioidun detransitioituneeksi/desistoinneeksi mieheksi.
Koko tarina
I am a detransitioned (desisted) male who identified as a trans woman online and to a few close people in real life for about two years. I never went on hormones, though I came close multiple times, and I never presented as a woman in public.
Timeline: I struggled to integrate into society as a teenage guy for years. Around age 16 I felt like I had failed socially — in talking to women, in fitting in as a guy — and I started spiraling. Sometime during my teenage years I told myself I was a woman, which I now describe as desisting after roughly two years of identifying that way online. By September 2024 I described myself as having desisted. I am 19 as of September 2024.
Causes and contributors: My dysphoria turned out, in my own reading, to be jealousy of female interaction plus very severe body dysmorphia — I hated my face and seeing it feminized made me feel better, but I never wanted secondary female sexual features or a vagina. I also had purely sexual fantasies. I felt I could never be attractive enough to have a clear life as a guy, and I thought I could 'pass' but that it would ruin my life. I used identifying as trans as a comfortable excuse to isolate myself because I never fit into society as a male. I found trans community spaces toxic, incoherent, and off-putting from day one — their constant affirmation and lingo repulsed me — and I struggled to fit into trans spaces more than I ever struggled to fit into society as a man. I also note the sunk cost fallacy as the only thing still mildly drawing me toward the identity.
Process of desisting: I came to understand my feelings by looking deeper, recognizing the dysmorphia and jealousy underneath. I realized being trans was, for me, a cop-out and felt like a form of self-harm, and that giving it up felt like going back to having no way out. I recognized I had to learn to adapt to society rather than escape it.
Medical: No hormones, no surgeries. I almost went on hormones multiple times but had doubts from day one. I wasted money on clothes. I had long hair. I starved myself at one point trying to make my body more feminine.
Mental health: I was in depression spirals and reclusive for about two years, forgetting how to live my normal life. I still struggle socially but am recovering and seeing signs I was never actually ugly.
Adversity/social: I missed basically all of my high school years and never had a girlfriend. I shut myself in and deprived myself of the few social contexts where I was happy as a guy. I was mortified of presenting as a woman in public and petrified of being hate crimed, so I never did.
Sexuality: I had purely sexual fantasies; I never wanted female secondary sex characteristics or a vagina. I struggled as a teenager in talking to women.
Regret: I deeply regret the critical years I wasted — it brings me to tears more often than I want to admit. I regret the isolation, the lost high school years, and I call identifying as trans 'stupid' and a 'stupid grievance.' I am extremely ashamed that a select few people, including my parents, know about that part of my past; I get along with them but keep that part of my life away from home.
Attitudes: I am critical of transition, especially for body dysmorphia, and critical of trans community culture and what I see as porn-related fetishization in some trans people. I resent the claim that detransitioners always retransition. I have reached out to other detransitioners with support and encouragement, and I asked one if I could DM them a question about detransitioning.