Nämä tarinat on tiivistetty tekoälyn avulla.
Redditissä ihmiset jakavat usein kokemuksiaan useissa kommenteissa tai viesteissä. Jotta tämä tieto olisi helpommin saatavilla, detrans.ai kerää kaikki hajallaan olevat osat yhdeksi helposti luettavaksi yhteenvedoksi ja aikajanaksi. Kaikki järjestelmäkyselyt on merkitty kyselysivulle.
Joskus tekoäly voi hallusinoida tai väittää asioita, jotka eivät ole totta. Yleensä tiivistetyt tarinat kuitenkin heijastavat tarkasti käyttäjien alkuperäisiä kommentteja.
Tiivistelmä
Olen detransitioitunut nainen, joka samaistui mieheksi teini-vuosinani mutta ei koskaan ottanut hormoneja enkä käynyt leikkauksessa. Uskon nyt, että dysforiani johtui sisäistetystä misogyniasta, kehostandardeista ja trans-yhteisöstä, jonka koen groominganneen minut, ja se haihtui neljän–viiden vuoden aikana itseään rakastamaan oppiessani. Olen iloinen, etten koskaan transitioitunut lääketieteellisesti, ja sanon olevani paljon onnellisempi kehossani nyt, vaikka tunnenkin minut ryöstetyn teini-iästäni ja ajattelen asiaa pakonomaisesti päivittäin. Olen kriittinen transitioitumista hoitona, alaikäisten murrosiän estäjiä ja sukupuoliroolien pakottamista transsukupuolisuuden kautta kohtaan, ja pidän nämä näkemykset pääosin yksityisinä. Tällä hetkellä samaistun naiseksi ja olen detransitioitunut/desistoinut naistaiteilija.
Koko tarina
I was born female, and I identified as transgender for part of my teenage years — I started identifying as male at some point during middle or high school. I never took hormones, never had any surgeries, and I am genuinely glad about that. Looking back, I can see that questioning my gender was pushed on me constantly throughout middle and high school by the people around me; friends would tell me that whenever I did typical "masculine" things or acted tomboyish, they had a feeling I was trans and I should look into it. I was truly convinced I was male, or at the very least not female, for much of that time.
When I first started identifying as male, it made me feel as though my voice would be heard and I would be taken more seriously — I now recognize internalized misogyny as part of what drove that. Being female also made me dislike my body because of body standards for women and the oversexualization of women. I felt self-hatred for my body and would always envision myself as the opposite gender, with male body parts. It took me roughly four or five years to come to terms with being a woman and to realize all of this had been pressured on me. I never needed to question my gender; I could have just lived as a female without any second thought.
I describe having been "basically groomed by the trans community," and I say that transgenderism was for me a coping mechanism, a form of self-hatred, and a way to fit in. I also think it functioned as an "escape." My partner, who went through being transfem for a few years, described it as his "safe space to be someone else and escape himself"; he struggled badly with gender dysphoria and wanted to be allowed to like feminine things without being judged. He was genuinely going to start treatment until I started being open about detransitioning and what I see in the community — now he is detransitioning too. I also had a 13-year-old friend who was already starting HRT, which I found scary, especially since they changed their name and pronouns every other day. One of my best friends from about seven years ago, an artist friend, went through HRT and full surgery after years of gender-affirming care with officially diagnosed gender dysphoria; he was happy for around five years, but his dysphoria later faded, he became simply a feminine male, and he now regrets the entire transition.
What moved me toward detransition was largely time — the dysphoria faded over time for me, and I learned self-love. I also looked into detransition communities and spoke with people dealing with the same thing, which changed how I see things, especially hearing about people who were "abused by doctors and having their perfectly healthy body parts changed." I don't recall formal therapy being described as helpful or harmful; my account emphasizes self-acceptance, unlearning stereotypes, and stepping away from online spaces.
I now think gender dysphoria is a mental illness, and that no one is born in the wrong body. I believe transition is not the treatment we should be using, and I compare affirming gender dysphoria to giving liposuction to an anorexic person. I think gender dysphoria is largely a social illness that would not exist without gender roles, body judgment, oversexualization, and body-image problems. I am critical of puberty blockers for minors, citing effects on bone density and the need for long-term studies. I also oppose what I see as the enforcement of gender roles through transgenderism — the idea that masculine girls must be trans guys and vice versa — and I believe abolishing gender roles would resolve much of the "gender crisis." I am opposed to plastic surgery generally and believe in teaching self-love instead of altering bodies.
I censor myself around most of my friends; only my partner and one close friend who shares my views know how I truly feel. I worry about being screamed at for being "transphobic" or called an "EVIL TERF" if I speak openly, and I have expressed a wish for a small Discord server of like-minded people. I am an artist who loves drawing cartoons and wants to create my own cartoon someday.
I feel robbed of my teenage life — I couldn't just live normally without constantly questioning my gender. I haven't gone a day in a long time without thinking about the transgender issue, and I describe obsessively reading through both trans and detrans communities, saying "I focus on this every day man, it hurts" and that I just want it to go away. Despite that distress, I also say I am much happier in my body at this point and glad I never took hormones; the pain is about what I went through and lost, not about my body now. I have not described suicidal ideation or self-harm.