Nämä tarinat on tiivistetty tekoälyn avulla.
Redditissä ihmiset jakavat usein kokemuksiaan useissa kommenteissa tai viesteissä. Jotta tämä tieto olisi helpommin saatavilla, detrans.ai kerää kaikki hajallaan olevat osat yhdeksi helposti luettavaksi yhteenvedoksi ja aikajanaksi. Kaikki järjestelmäkyselyt on merkitty kyselysivulle.
Joskus tekoäly voi hallusinoida tai väittää asioita, jotka eivät ole totta. Yleensä tiivistetyt tarinat kuitenkin heijastavat tarkasti käyttäjien alkuperäisiä kommentteja.
Tiivistelmä
Olen detransitioinut mies, joka vietti noin kymmenen vuotta estrogeenilla ja kävi kivespoistossa, ja uskon nyt, etten koskaan ollut trans vaan autistinen mies, jolla oli käsittelemätöntä ahdistusta, pakko-oireisia ongelmia ja ratkaisemattomia luonteenpuutteita, jotka pakenivat uuteen identiteettiin. Aloitin äskettäin testosteronin päätettyäni detransitioitua, mutta olen edelleen syvästi jakautunut, koska olin onnellinen transnaisena ja kohtaan nyt katumusta, juomista ja surua menetetystä perheestä, urasta ja lapsista, joita minulla tuskin koskaan tulee olemaan. Tunnen tuhonneeni vanhempieni elämän kieltämällä heiltä lapsenlapset ja hylänneeni unelmani tulla opettajaksi. Olen kriittinen transkulttuuria kohtaan, joka kannustaa narsismia ja kaikki-tai-ei-mitään-transitioita, tunnustaen että todellisia transihmisiä on olemassa — minä vain en ollut yksi heistä. En kertonut kertomuksessani itsemurha-ajatuksista tai yrityksistä, vaikka olen julkaissut halustani kuolla ja kehottanut muita olemaan transitioutumatta.
Koko tarina
I spent about ten years on estrogen and had an orchiectomy, and I've come to the realization that I made a huge mistake — I think I was just an autistic man with normal sexual fantasies who got way too fixated on them. I don't mind living as a woman, but I deeply regret what I've done to my body.
Looking back, I believe my transition came out of OCD. I was obsessively fearful of being trans and I mistook that obsession for proof that I was. Many of the drastic steps I took were driven by fear that if I didn't act immediately I would never pass and would become some terrible person or object of ridicule. I didn't know much about OCD at the time, but I'd had a similar obsessive fear about being depressed. I also remember multiple times when I started dressing like a "butch lesbian" — indications I would have been perfectly fine as a man — which I ignored. I had an idealized vision of femaleness as a kind of freedom, totally divorced from the reality of life and parenthood. I think I was trying to escape into a new identity because I couldn't believe I was loved by my family and girlfriend, and I needed therapy to learn to trust the people in my life, slow down, and imagine myself as a competent father. I also think I transitioned partly because I was worried about becoming an unmarried "incel" male, and transition was a way to escape that, and partly because I had severe emotional issues and was afraid of developing into a large, strong man with those issues. I stopped watching porn at some point. I feel like I was in a fugue state for ten years.
The regret is enormous. I miss being my father's and my son — I mean, I miss being my parents' son tremendously. I feel like I slowly murdered my parents: I radically altered the body I was born with and deprived them of grandchildren forever. I never got promotions or career advancement because I was a weird freak, so I'm broke too. I gave up my dream of being a schoolteacher — I was all set up for it and would have been good at it, but I didn't want to teach when I was trans because I didn't want to confuse the kids. I distanced myself from family members and lost everything good about myself. I also came out as a trans woman to my three younger, impressionable cousins and feel tremendous guilt about that. I worry constantly about getting older with no kids; I realized I did want children but believe it's far too late. I've said I want to be the parent my parents always wanted me to be.
I've struggled with how to fix relationships with family, and I've posted about wanting to die and asking others not to transition, writing "I wish so bad i had my balls back" and "I miss my healthy natural body." I've described feeling like an objectively worthless man — a eunuch with no strength, no children, nothing accomplished outside of transforming into a woman — and that I destroyed my mind. I've said I only feel angry at myself and that I destroyed my life for no reason with nothing to look back on with pride.
Six years after my orchiectomy I decided to detransition and started testosterone. I'm self-conscious about the "pencil neck" I got from estrogen and hope the muscle comes back. Physically I'm very far along in transition: my fat is distributed in a female pattern, I have awkward male proportions with a big butt and thighs, gynecomastia, and my penis has shrunk. This has made me reconsider detransition altogether — I worry that as a detransitioned man with a weird body I'd be lonely and unwanted, even though as a trans woman it was very easy to get a girlfriend. Detransition has been hard: I'm full of regret, drinking to cope with having wasted ten years, and I can't deny that as trans I was carefree and happy, hooking up with and dating other trans women. I've said I had deep character flaws I refused to address and found refuge in a new identity rather than age as a man with them.
I now believe I was never trans, just mentally ill, and that I developed severe mental illness in my teenage years and transitioned to escape it. I've been critical of trans culture, arguing it enables narcissism and Peter Pan syndrome, and that there's no room for in-between — you're either all the way or not at all, with no brakes on the train. I've said that for someone like me the idea of reinventing ourselves, propagandized in those spaces, is almost impossible to resist, while also acknowledging that real trans people exist — I just wasn't one of them. I've encouraged others not to transition and to get off hormones, and I've said the idea that people who don't transition will fight a lifelong psychic war with themselves is simply not true.