Nämä tarinat on tiivistetty tekoälyn avulla.
Redditissä ihmiset jakavat usein kokemuksiaan useissa kommenteissa tai viesteissä. Jotta tämä tieto olisi helpommin saatavilla, detrans.ai kerää kaikki hajallaan olevat osat yhdeksi helposti luettavaksi yhteenvedoksi ja aikajanaksi. Kaikki järjestelmäkyselyt on merkitty kyselysivulle.
Joskus tekoäly voi hallusinoida tai väittää asioita, jotka eivät ole totta. Yleensä tiivistetyt tarinat kuitenkin heijastavat tarkasti käyttäjien alkuperäisiä kommentteja.
Tiivistelmä
Olen detransitioitunut mies, joka eli trans-naisena ja käytti hormonihoitoa (mukaan lukien syproteronia ~12,5 mg) alle kaksi vuotta ennen kuin lopetin noin vuoden 2023 lopulla. Hormonihoito aiheutti minulle vakavia fyysisiä ongelmia — ekseema, hermovaurio, jonka liitän matalaan B12-vitamiiniin, näkö- ja liikeongelmat, aivosumu ja erektiohäiriö — joista useimmat paranivat parissa kuukaudessa lopettamisen jälkeen, vaikka jotain hermokipua ja pysyviä muutoksia on jäänyt. Identifioidun nyt biologiseksi mieheksi, vaikka maaliskuussa 2024 myönsin, että tunnen edelleen, että minulla on »naisen sydän«, kun pysyn detransitioituna. Vastustan voimakkaasti transition tekemistä toisille, kutsun trans-tiloja kulteiksi ja olen julkaissut julkisesti varoittaakseni ihmisiä hormoneista ja leikkauksista. Henkisesti olen paljon onnellisempi detransition jälkeen, ja minulla on päivittäisiä onnellisia hetkiä, vaikka pelkään yhä liukuvani takaisin dysforiaan ja minulla on aiemmin ollut pelko siitä, että minut murhataan.
Koko tarina
I was born male. I first started questioning my gender and feeling dysphoria in my late teens/early twenties; I was a lurker on detrans forums before I ever transitioned, and I described myself back then as a "desisted male" who then went ahead and transitioned anyway. I lived as a trans woman for a while and was on HRT — cyproterone at around 12.5 mg for some months, plus estrogen — for a total of less than two years. I never had surgeries.
What pushed me toward transition was, in my own reading now, being gullible and being immersed in trans online spaces. I also had pre-existing mental health difficulties: dysphoria, depression, and what I now describe as a fear of people trying to murder me (I still check packaging in the market to see if seals are intact). I had envied women and felt effeminate, and I think that envy plus online influence led me to identify as trans. I also noticed I was influencing people around me to become trans, and that was one of the concrete things that pushed me to detransition.
The physical effects of HRT were severe for me. I developed eczema, hives, itchy dry skin, intestinal problems, brain fog, fatigue, panic attacks, agoraphobia, anxiety, blurred and tired eyesight, increased allergies, intrusive thoughts, confusion, and motor coordination problems. I also had erectile dysfunction, no morning wood, almost no erections, and lost my libido. I later came to believe HRT had caused low B12 and nerve damage: I experienced nerve pain in my chest, neck, shoulder, back and jaw, mild temporary dementia-like episodes, difficulty talking, difficulty washing dishes, dropping my toothbrush, accidentally burning my arms and hands in the kitchen, bumping into furniture, and vision so poor I couldn't look at screens long. I posted about this publicly to warn others. I also had a period where I forgot to flush in a public bathroom.
I detransitioned around December 2023/January 2024. Within a month or so off HRT, fatigue, agoraphobia, anxiety and panic attacks improved quickly; my skin took longer but got better; my vision improved. Sexual function returned: morning wood came back in the first two weeks off HRT, erections without touch returned later, libido partially returned, I had an erotic dream, and my sperm became whiter again. By mid-January 2024 I was walking an hour a day, doing pelvic exercises, and said my body was changing a lot and my erections and libido were coming back. I still had nerve pain and was uncertain whether I would heal 100%.
I do have some permanent changes I've decided to accept — I mentioned "not bewbs you know..." implying some breast development — and I described going from a "strange peculiar man" to a "disfigured weird weird unhappy man with erectile dysfunction (recovering)." I also said people used to have more respect for me and that I've hit bottom and don't get the same respect as before.
Mentally, I was the "dysphoric depressed person that started transitioning." Since detransitioning I've had happy times daily where going back makes no sense, and I say detransition has been great. I do worry about whether I'll slide back into dysphoria, and I hope to stay strong in my detransition resolution and not become someone who wishes to retransition but cannot. I've had a sleepless night after a trans woman spoke to me and felt scared, like I was being followed home.
On sexuality and gender, I said being trans is humiliating and that my personality changed from "proud, young and reckless" to that of a "humble menopausal women that no men wanted to marry." I said I now accept I'm a biological male, that I can be a husband, father, male friend, son, but not a sister, mother or wife. In a March 2024 post I said I now believe in "having the wrong body" — that I have a "woman's heart" — but I'm still detransitioned, and that hormones and surgeries only push me further from physical reality. I said being a man feels like being a slave or prisoner but I can't change it, and that I don't feel joy from being a man, it's just how I avoid punishment. I also said I plan to avoid dating women "like a plague" and don't expect to become a husband.
I'm strongly opposed to transition for other people. I said "there is no happy transition" and that I'm against transition; I said I hope trans care becomes banned; I called trans spaces cults (comparing them to Osho's cult) and said I've been banned by Reddit mods for calling trans a cult. I said I believe transition is self-destructive and self-harm, that "transness is not real," and that biological sex is real. I said part of my own treatment for gender dysphoria is erasing trans women from my thoughts, which I call repressing and say makes me happier. I've posted publicly about HRT dangers (the B12/nerve damage post) and about being banned from another detrans sub for telling someone considering SRS not to do it. I don't identify as cis or trans anymore — I said "I don't believe in cis or trans, I believe that people transition."