סיפורים אלה סוכמו באמצעות בינה מלאכותית.
ברדיט, אנשים לעתים קרובות משתפים את החוויות שלהם בין תגובות או פוסטים רבים. כדי להפוך את המידע הזה לנגיש יותר, detrans.ai אוסף את כל החלקים המפוזרים הללו לסיכום אחד קל לקריאה ולציר זמן. כל הפרומפטים של המערכת מצוינים בעמוד הפרומפטים.
לפעמים בינה מלאכותית יכולה להזות או לציין דברים שאינם נכונים. אך באופן כללי, הסיפורים המסוכמים הם משקפים מדויקים של התגובות המקוריות של המשתמשים.
סיכום
אני גבר הומוסקסואל שעבר דה-טרנזישן שמתחרט על הדה-טרנזישן כל יום ורוצה מאוד לחזור ולעבור מעבר, אם כי אני גם מרגיש לכוד באובססיה לטרנסיות. חייתי כאישה טרנסית והייתי מאושר יותר, מקובל יותר ופחות אובדני אז, אך עברתי דה-טרנזישן כדי לא לחיות „שקר“. מאז הדה-טרנזישן לא היו לי חיי חברה, יש לי דיספוריה מגדרית יומיומית עזה, ומחשבות אובדניות. גורמים תורמים כוללים חרמות קשות בילדות, צורך נואש באישור, מערכת יחסים גרועה עם אבי, ולחצים של תרבות אסתטיקה/אופנה. אני נשאר גבר הומו שחור ונשי שמשלב נשיות במראהו וקרוע בין הזדהות כטרנס לבין קבלת עצמי כגבר הומו נשי.
הסיפור המלא
I am a black feminine gay man who was born male and has detransitioned from living as a trans woman. I detransitioned more than a year before August 2023, and the year since has been a nightmare for me, from social interactions to my appearance. Life was good as a trans woman — I liked my appearance for the first time in my life, I was attracting the men I wanted, women didn't perceive me as a 'threatening' man or the weird gay best friend, and I was actually celebrated for my femininity. Since detransitioning I feel like the big weirdo that makes everyone uncomfortable. I detransitioned because I didn't want to be the fool living a 'lie', but life is so bad now that I think I was and will be happier being the 'blissful fool', and I regret it every day. I really want to retransition.
When I was presenting as a woman it felt like I was normal and living the life I was supposed to be. Finally feeling like I belonged, like I was valued for the qualities that make me, me — and not wanting to die for the first time in a long time. Whenever I see really masculine looking men I have this instinctual feeling of I really don't want to become that. I said I would still say I want to transition even on a desert island. I think my mind still operates in binaries. I noted that presenting femininely while still identifying as a man sounds freeing — 'There's no pressure to change my voice or force a really feminine walk.'
Away from transness I'm a feminine gay man who likes to incorporate femininity into my appearance. Then in transness I'm 'not good enough' and I'll never be a woman, which causes me a lot of angst and depression. I'm on a merry-go-round that brought me joy and hope but I've now been on it for too long. Gender dysphoria is causing me suicidal ideation and a constant obsession with transness; I have no social life or passion for anything other than transition. It's weird and confusing because if I never found out what trans was I would've been dead a long time ago — the thing that saved my life is now ruining it and I don't know how to let go. I've watched pretty much every detrans male video on YouTube, but I feel like if there's one trans woman out of a million that ends up happy, that can be me too. I feel fake when I deny that transition will help my dysphoria. Pushing it away and forcing myself to say 'I'm not trans' hasn't helped me.
My dysphoria is made worse when I see trans women that look like me that are passing and living life happy with themselves, because it feels like this whole time I've been denied that possibility. When I entertain the idea of trans, that's when the hyper fixation on my appearance starts. I'm still battling intense gender dysphoria every day and can't stop obsessing over the idea that I need to transition for a better life; it feels like I've been cursed.
Contributing factors: I've always had a desperation for approval — I was bullied quite badly, and I almost don't even know how to live without seeking approval. I don't have a good relationship with my dad. I'm still obsessed with labels. I'm extremely aesthetic-oriented, as is my generation, and I noted that the aesthetic-orientation culture (Instagram, TikTok, E-girl looks, multicoloured hair) pressures people to constantly change their wardrobe and look the same.
I'm black, and I've observed that MTFs from predominantly black culture are far less likely to detransition than those from white culture, because majority black communities have higher superficial standards for trans women (lace fronts, false eyelashes, full makeup, breast augmentation). Stricter gender roles play a part, and many black men aren't good at hiding disapproval, so a black trans woman must pass to live stealth. I'm not American; where I live is still a little more old school and employers aren't really looking for diversity. I use a throwaway account because I'm not on social media other than Reddit.
I've argued with people who call transition cowardly or escaping reality — I don't think identifying as a trans woman is escaping reality because you know you're a biological male and different from a biological woman; maybe misguided but not cowardly. I'm not forcing others, I'm not going into women's bathrooms, and I don't care what pronouns are on my ID. I've advised someone else to consider transitioning if their internal struggle quiets down, noting they pass without HRT. I've said I'm 'not normal anyway according to society — a feminine gay man is abnormal' and I'm just trying to be in as good a place as I can be.
Current status: I still identify as a detransitioned gay male, I regret detransitioning every day, I want to retransition, and I'm struggling with intense dysphoria, suicidal ideation, and obsession.