כל הסיפורים

חמש שנים בפורומים של חוזרים מהמעבר, בלי לשתף ציר זמן

נקבה · עבר/ה דהטרנזישן138
סיפורים אלה סוכמו באמצעות בינה מלאכותית.

ברדיט, אנשים לעתים קרובות משתפים את החוויות שלהם בין תגובות או פוסטים רבים. כדי להפוך את המידע הזה לנגיש יותר, detrans.ai אוסף את כל החלקים המפוזרים הללו לסיכום אחד קל לקריאה ולציר זמן. כל הפרומפטים של המערכת מצוינים בעמוד הפרומפטים.

לפעמים בינה מלאכותית יכולה להזות או לציין דברים שאינם נכונים. אך באופן כללי, הסיפורים המסוכמים הם משקפים מדויקים של התגובות המקוריות של המשתמשים.

סיכום

אני אישה שחזרה בה מהמעבר, ופעילה בקהילות הרדיט של חוזרים מהמעבר ושל ביקורת המגדר לפחות משנת 2019. אני ביקורתית כלפי המעבר, במיוחד כשאני רואה בפורנוגרפיה, בפטיש/באוטוגינפיליה ובחרדה מניעים שלו, והמלצתי לאחרים על מקורות להחלמה מפורנוגרפיה. אני מגנה במיוחד על חוזרים מהמעבר ומעודדת את הקהילה לשמור על מרחבה פרטי ותומך. יש לי השקפה חיובית וחוגגת על נשיות, והרגעתי אחרים שאיבדו את החזה שלהם או התקשו בקבלה עצמית. לא פרסמתי בטקסט זה ציר זמן אישי מפורט של המעבר שלי, ולכן גילים ספציפיים, תאריכי התערבויות רפואיות והיסטוריה כירורגית אינם מתועדים כאן.

הסיפור המלא

I have been active in detrans and gender-critical spaces on Reddit since at least October 2019, and my comments over that period reveal a good deal about where I stand and what I have been through, even though I have never laid out a full step-by-step transition timeline in these posts. I am a woman who has detransitioned or desisted, and I speak from that place. Early on, in October 2019, I was engaged with people questioning religious influence in gender-critical sources, asking whether a website was "Jesusy" and noting that some articles had "religeous overtones," while also troubleshooting broken links on the site. I followed detransition content closely: I praised a video by someone named Kat as being from "an extremely smart and eloquent person" and "really damn brave," and I reacted with sympathy to medical complications people described after transition surgeries, including speculating that "maybe there's a fistula or something" involving a hole between the colorectal area and the bladder or vaginal canal, and responding "Oh my god thats awful" to someone's difficult experience. I have also seen the parental side of this: in November 2019 I noted "Ive seen a lot of worried parents on here as well." I am clearly aligned with the gender-critical community but also protective of detransitioners specifically, writing at one point that "There is lots if space for GC people to exist and have their opinions and conversations, that is certainly not the situation for detrans or questioning people," and urging fellow gender-critical users to "lurk moar" and to share the detrans subreddit privately rather than publicly to avoid unwanted attention. On the question of what drives people toward transition, I have been fairly specific. In November 2019 I told someone questioning whether their transition desire was a fetish that "if you weren't turned on at the idea of having a female body then it wasnt a fetish," which suggests I am familiar with the autogynephilia framework as applied to natal females. I have also recommended the r/TGandSissyRecovery subreddit to someone struggling with "sissy porn addiction," indicating I see pornography as a real contributor for some people. I have been sympathetic when people feel others are being insensitive, saying of a post I thought was rude that "Y'all are just trying to move on with your lives and support eachother," and I have acknowledged that certain experiences are "becoming so common" and that "People need to listen and learn more." I am skeptical of right-leaning sources even when they cover gender topics critically: I warned that a Heritage Foundation publication has "a pretty colourful past and present and very clear 'values'" and should be read "with a keen eye." At the same time I was pleased when critical coverage moved into mainstream outlets, calling it "Refreshing" to see such articles "wafting over from sort of right-wing think tankey publications to more widely accepted, mainstream sources." I have a strongly positive view of womanhood and of female-bodied life. In December 2019 I celebrated women "learning to love womanhood more, because womanhood is undefinable. It just is, it's for women by women," and I shared that I had spent the day "sanding and refinishing furniture and doing drywall repairs" which "Didn't make me feel manly...sure made me feel accomplished and skillful tho!" I have been reassuring to others about lost breasts, telling someone that women "who have lost their breasts are still lovable and worthy of love - full stop!" And I have been encouraging about self-acceptance, telling someone that the "Sad 4 year old you would probably be pretty damn proud of the woman you are today." I have also addressed anxiety directly, telling someone "You might benefit from working on your anxiety above all else," and I have engaged with debates about terminology, arguing that "TERFS" generally include trans men under their umbrella of women and that gender-critical people generally do not use the term "cis." Overall I come across as a woman who has been through some version of transition and detransition, is firmly gender-critical, is thoughtful about the roles of fetish, pornography, and anxiety in driving transition, and is invested in supporting both detransitioners and women more broadly.