Cerita-cerita ini telah diringkas menggunakan AI.
Di Reddit, orang sering berbagi pengalaman mereka di berbagai komentar atau postingan. Untuk membuat informasi ini lebih mudah diakses, detrans.ai mengumpulkan semua potongan tersebar menjadi satu ringkasan dan garis waktu yang mudah dibaca. Semua prompt sistem dicatat di halaman prompt.
Kadang AI dapat menghasilkan halusinasi atau menyatakan hal-hal yang tidak benar. Namun secara umum, cerita yang diringkas adalah refleksi yang akurat dari komentar asli oleh pengguna.
Ringkasan
Saya anggota komunitas detransisi, tidak pernah bertransisi sendiri, tetapi pada Oktober 2023 saya menulis karena khawatir tentang teman berusia 19 tahun yang merencanakan transisi medis tanpa, menurut saya, disforia gender yang asli. Saya percaya transseksualitas adalah kondisi langka yang bawaan, dan kebanyakan orang yang bertransisi kini sedang menghadapi ketidakpuasan atau stereotip, seperti hampir saya lakukan sebagai anak ketika saya mengira bisa menjadi lelaki. Saya mencoba memperingatkan teman saya tentang hormon dan risiko operasi bagian bawah, tetapi ia menolaknya dan menolak membaca forum ini karena membuatnya meragukan dirinya. Saya memutuskan bahwa dengan hati nurani yang bersih saya tidak bisa menyebutnya perempuan atau mendukung transisinya, meskipun saya tetap ingin menjadi temannya. Saya bukan trans, tidak pernah bertransisi, dan tidak memiliki garis waktu detransisi atau penyesalan pribadi.
Kisah lengkap
I posted on a detransition support forum in October 2023 because a friend of mine — I'll call him T — was planning to medically transition, and I didn't know what to do. I want to be clear about my own background first: I am not trans, and I never transitioned. I never took hormones, never had surgery, and never socially transitioned. What I did have, as a child, was a period where I thought I could actually be a boy, because I didn't fit any of the stereotypes expected of girls. I've told people that if I had been born in this generation, I could have been made trans by my parents. That childhood experience is the main reason I feel so strongly about what T is doing.
T is 19 and wants to medically transition to female, change his name, start estrogen soon, and eventually get bottom surgery. We go to the same school and I'll be spending the next few years around him. I asked him a lot of questions over time — whether he was born with gender dysphoria, why he wants to transition — and his answers worried me. He wasn't born with gender dysphoria; when he was younger he thought he was just a feminine guy. His dysphoria isn't so crippling that he can't leave his house. He said part of why he wants to transition is that he wants to be cute and doesn't like how men are treated in society, and wants to be treated nicer. To me this sounded like a feminine guy feeling pushed toward transition because of stereotypes, not someone with the kind of genuine, crippling dysphoria I associate with the condition.
My general view, which I stated openly, is that I'm not transphobic but I don't like how being trans is becoming so common. I support people like Blaire White, who I see as actively calling this out, and people I believe were actually born with gender dysphoria. I believe it's an extremely rare condition, so most people who are trans nowadays are trying to cope with something else — they're dissatisfied with themselves, want to change in some way, and seek to become trans because they think it will help. The only way I agree with being trans is if you're actually born with gender dysphoria, as it was originally classified, and I disagree with transitioning over stereotypes.
I tried to talk him through the medical realities. I showed him government sites saying that taking hormones heavily increases the chance of heart-related problems; he said he'd rather live a shorter life as a woman than a longer life as a man. I told him that if he gets bottom surgery there's a high risk of complications and that he would have to dilate for the rest of his life, including when he's 90; he said it's a 10% risk of heavy complications, probably life-threatening, which he didn't think was much. I told him that was high and he could easily end up in that 10%. I also told him that the lead surgeon for bottom surgery doesn't even know much about it and that many surgeons are doing it for the first time and aren't fully confident. He didn't seem to be listening and only wanted to hear good stuff, not the reality.
He also told me he thinks minors can consent to transition and wishes he could have taken hormone blockers when he was 12. I heavily disagreed, citing my own childhood experience. I suggested he wait until he's older — I think 23-25 is better, closer to when the brain is fully developed — but acknowledged he's an adult and can do what he wants with his body. I told him he should check this subreddit, but he said he doesn't like to look at it because it makes him question himself. I saw that refusal as proof he isn't 100% sure and is trying to convince himself it's the right choice by avoiding anything that could make him think again.
The hardest part for me is the social and moral dimension. I feel like I will not be able to call him a female because it feels morally wrong to me — I know this isn't right and I believe he will end up regretting it. If I refuse to call him a woman, he'll probably tell others in my class and I'll be cancelled. I debated for over an hour with another friend about what to do when T starts identifying as female and changing his name; they suggested I could play along as long as I'm not actively encouraging it and subtly give my true thoughts, but even that feels wrong to me because it's playing pretend and indirectly encouraging him. I don't think I can support him because I don't feel comfortable with it — I can't go against my gut.
My plan, when the time comes, is not to be overly firm but to tell him he's causing bodily harm to himself and I don't feel right supporting that, then mention how strikingly similar parts of the stories on this forum are to how he feels, while emphasizing how much I care for him and still want to be his friend. I'm afraid he'll be mad at me later if I don't talk to him well enough, and I wish I didn't have to lose friends over this. I don't want to abandon him for becoming trans, but if he pushes me away afterwards I suppose I can't do much. I'm genuinely worried for him and feel like I have to do something.