Cerita-cerita ini telah diringkas menggunakan AI.
Di Reddit, orang sering berbagi pengalaman mereka di berbagai komentar atau postingan. Untuk membuat informasi ini lebih mudah diakses, detrans.ai mengumpulkan semua potongan tersebar menjadi satu ringkasan dan garis waktu yang mudah dibaca. Semua prompt sistem dicatat di halaman prompt.
Kadang AI dapat menghasilkan halusinasi atau menyatakan hal-hal yang tidak benar. Namun secara umum, cerita yang diringkas adalah refleksi yang akurat dari komentar asli oleh pengguna.
Ringkasan
Saya seorang laki-laki yang sedang bertanya-tanya, saat ini menyebut diri desister karena saya kadang tampil secara sosial sebagai perempuan, yang tidak pernah mengonsumsi hormon atau menjalani operasi — hanya penghilangan rambut dengan laser dan pakaian perempuan. Motivasi saya mencakup kecemburuan pada tubuh dan daya tarik perempuan, fantasi seksual menjadi perempuan, dan perasaan bahwa saya gagal sebagai laki-laki, di samping keinginan tulus akan tubuh feminin. Saya pernah menjalani terapi (terapis saya menawarkan penerimaan radikal dan mendukung saya sebagai perempuan) dan saya aktif mencari perspektif pro maupun anti-transisi, termasuk komunitas ini. Saya tetap terjebak pada apakah akan bertransisi, merasa tidak aman dan ragu, sambil sepenuhnya menerima bahwa saya lahir sebagai laki-laki. Tidak ada ide bunuh diri, melukai diri, atau upaya bunuh diri yang digambarkan.
Kisah lengkap
I am a questioning male who has been considering medical transition for several years, and I have never received hormones or surgeries — only some laser hair removal sessions and a closet or two full of women's clothes. I first posted about this publicly in late 2020, describing my desire to take hormones as something I had wanted for a long time, comparing it to how kids have an idea of what career they want to pursue.
My motivations have been layered. Early on I admitted that I crossdressed to get a sexual hit, though by that point I was also dressing femininely when going out with friends. Over time the sexual component became more nuanced: I described liking to imagine that I am the female in a loving relationship, romantically and sexually, and I have had some curiosity with men, mostly when masturbating while romanticizing being female. I also said I like presenting as female in public and being called she/her/woman, and that I would want the physical features of a woman.
Jealousy of women has been a central driver. In a post from December 2023 I wrote that I can't help but always feel like women have something I want, which is part of my motivation to medically transition. I described seeing a friend's sister's Gucci sandals and wanting to feel pretty myself, and being jealous of women's figures — noting that despite exercise I would be far from a feminine figure. I compared this jealousy to obsessing over a sports car I wanted a few years ago: I couldn't let that car pass me on the street, and once I had it I felt at ease despite its flaws. I acknowledged the counterargument that this is the difference between owning an object and committing to a medical lifestyle.
I have been in therapy. My therapist mentioned radical acceptance, which in our sessions meant repeatedly telling yourself something; my phrase was "I am a man, I have feminine interests, and that's ok," and she told me to relax and tell myself that repeatedly. I wasn't sure whether it worked because it put me in a calm state or because it helped realign my life. I also noted that my therapist seemed very affirmative in her support for me admitting I'm a woman, and I framed posting in a detransition community as seeking advice that might be contrarian to my existing beliefs.
I have actively sought out contradicting views: I said I look into different and contradicting views on the whole transgender thing, and that this is why I joined the detransition subreddit. I read transmaxxing forums and noted that there all people do is ask and put into numbers how their dating life would be improved, and I questioned whether those men's chances with women would go down. I have asked detransitioners detailed questions about what transition did and didn't solve, what changes reverted after stopping hormones, how they dealt with jealousy, and what they think the right or best reason to transition is, since mine seemed to be judged a poor one.
I present as female in public when I have the means — wig and makeup — doing chores, grocery shopping, or window shopping. I described feeling like I'm not hiding a part of me when I show up that way, while also being anxious about people's judgment and fearing being clocked, worrying that my mannerisms won't match my feminine appearance. Even so, coming home without regret over not having presented feminine mattered more to me than the anxiety. I said I always feel like a fake when I present female in public because wigs, bras and clothes don't do it for me anymore — I want a body that would let me feel "naturally" like a woman, which I described as a superfluous body modification I want for myself.
I fully accept that I am born male and will die a male, and I said that if I did transition I would effectively be putting on a layer of femininity for my own happiness rather than changing how I was born. I said I would have no problem proclaiming I'm a woman in society but I personally know I'm a highly feminized male. I have also said I kind of feel like I failed as a man because I don't earn much, and that I've found it hard to flirt with women I genuinely adore — maybe adore so much that I would rather be one.
I have dealt with a groin issue I suspect is eczema caused by tucking for passing and sexual gratification, and I wondered whether estrogen might help clear it up, reasoning that many people on feminizing HRT report different skin texture. When someone pointed out that this was a strange reason, I clarified that I see it as an added benefit on top of being closer to the body I want and being seen as female in society.
A turning point in my thinking came from meeting an online friend — a tiny Asian woman who works in a trade surrounded by men — where I, born male, was far more feminine-presenting than she was. That gave me the thought of why bother transitioning if we can simply exist with no other complications, though I added that I don't discount my feelings of wanting a more feminine body without the clothes and makeup.
I have also reflected on aging: I said I'd look at women who are older, frumpy, or seniors and have a hard time wanting to be like them, and I've asked others whether going through hormones and name change but not being conventionally attractive or still looking clocky would change their outlook. I dislike the magical-button fantasy, saying it releases people from responsibility and the real consequences of transitioning in their actual lives.
As of my most recent self-description, I said I would probably label myself a desister given that I somewhat socially present as female sometimes. I have not desisted from the question itself — I described myself as stuck trying to figure out this do I or do I not transition thing, and noted I hadn't felt so insecure about myself since I started questioning these things. I have asked others to PM so I could talk further about their journeys, and I've recommended a local trans subreddit to someone seeking community. In a later comment I compared the social and legislative recognition of trans people to the historical recognition of Black people's equality in America, while also acknowledging the physiological fairness argument in women's sports.