Cerita-cerita ini telah diringkas menggunakan AI.
Di Reddit, orang sering berbagi pengalaman mereka di berbagai komentar atau postingan. Untuk membuat informasi ini lebih mudah diakses, detrans.ai mengumpulkan semua potongan tersebar menjadi satu ringkasan dan garis waktu yang mudah dibaca. Semua prompt sistem dicatat di halaman prompt.
Kadang AI dapat menghasilkan halusinasi atau menyatakan hal-hal yang tidak benar. Namun secara umum, cerita yang diringkas adalah refleksi yang akurat dari komentar asli oleh pengguna.
Ringkasan
Saya seorang wanita yang melakukan detransisi, mengonsumsi estrogen lalu berhenti, dan tidak mengonsumsi apa pun sekarang, dan saya bertransisi sekitar 2018-2022. Saya percaya transisi saya, dan peningkatan yang lebih luas dalam jumlah orang yang mengidentifikasi sebagai trans, didorong oleh penularan sosial, pengaruh budaya, dan homofobia internal di kalangan pria gay feminin selama 5 tahun terakhir. Saya sangat kritis terhadap kedokteran yang menegaskan trans dan medicalisasi gender, melihatnya sebagai bagian dari kemajuan ilmu pengetahuan Barat yang berlebihan. Saya tidak menggambarkan operasi, diagnosis kesehatan mental, atau ide bunuh diri dalam materi yang tersedia.
Kisah lengkap
I was born male. I took estrogen at some point but stopped and now take nothing at all; as of January 2024 I said I had turned 25 and that many people still think I look close to 18. I went through my transition around 2018-2022, which I described as the same period when trans topics were scaling up, and I said I am around the same age as Trevor Moran. I speculated that if I had been born 3-5 years earlier I might not have transitioned.
When I discussed testosterone with someone who was 20, I explained that non-natural hormones, especially testosterone, interfere with physical development including facial structure, and that at 20 the face is still changing fast, so the dose matters. I described two components to facial appearance — a soft tissue/muscle component and a permanent bone structure component — and said that if you stop T some parts revert but you should be prepared for permanent changes because of bones. I noted a community consensus that T makes you look older while E can make you look younger. On recovery, I said that if someone had never had SRS or an orchiectomy it is likely they would recover to their potential just fine.
My thinking about why people transition is heavily cultural. I said internalized homophobia is becoming more of a thing as the trans movement advances, and that a lot of gay guys are quite feminine and were previously conditioned to think it was okay to just be gay, but are now being taught that if they were feminine they should become female. I referenced Ray Blanchard and the HSTS type, and said the rise in numbers transitioning is about cultural influences and social contagion over the past 5 years. I said the increase in people identifying as trans is purely because of increased social influence and contagion. I also said the trans movement is in some ways eliminating the sterility of gay and lesbian people by convincing them to transition, which some call a genocide.
I observed that Trevor Moran came out as trans when COVID started, and that Gigi Gorgeous was the original example of a feminine gay teenage boy who became a trans girl. I felt that twink-like gay guys have faded from public view in the past 3-5 years, overshadowed by the trans movement, with many becoming femboys or trans girls. I mentioned I was taking visual design courses and that there is a 28-year-old gay guy in one of my classes, and I was happy he wasn't trans, even though I acknowledged that would have sounded weird a few years ago.
I am critical of trans-affirming medicine. I argued that western science tries to convince us we can engineer and reverse-engineer every aspect of the human body, citing Bryan Johnson spending millions to reverse-engineer his body to that of an 18-year-old. I said trans-affirming doctors try to convince the public it is okay to artificially modify someone's hormonal make-up when they don't even understand the entire endocrine system and its consequences, and that the over-advancement of western science and medicine will someday drive humankind into a dark place, while most people are too dumb to realize it. I also said identity labels are used to divide people into categories to advance a cause, and that you can't just be ordinary without a label.