Cerita-cerita ini telah diringkas menggunakan AI.
Di Reddit, orang sering berbagi pengalaman mereka di berbagai komentar atau postingan. Untuk membuat informasi ini lebih mudah diakses, detrans.ai mengumpulkan semua potongan tersebar menjadi satu ringkasan dan garis waktu yang mudah dibaca. Semua prompt sistem dicatat di halaman prompt.
Kadang AI dapat menghasilkan halusinasi atau menyatakan hal-hal yang tidak benar. Namun secara umum, cerita yang diringkas adalah refleksi yang akurat dari komentar asli oleh pengguna.
Ringkasan
Saya seorang pria yang memiliki pikiran berkepanjangan tentang transisi dari pria ke perempuan tetapi tidak pernah menjalani transisi medis atau sosial, dan pikiran itu memudar bagi saya setelah saya fokus pada olahraga dan membangun disiplin mental. Pada Juni 2022 saya berulang kali memposting di r/detrans dengan berargumen bahwa disforia gender yang sejati lebih jarang daripada yang diyakini, bahwa gerakan trans memangsa orang yang tidak percaya diri, dan bahwa kebanyakan orang lebih baik dilayani dengan memperkuat diri dalam gender mereka sendiri daripada dengan bertransisi. Saya menawarkan saran bantuan diri dan terapi yang terperinci kepada pengguna lain yang bergulat dengan melukai diri dan disforia gender. Saya juga berdebat panjang tentang kekerasan pria dan peran gender, dengan berargumen bahwa kekuatan pria menjelaskan dominasi mereka dalam kejahatan kekerasan dan pertempuran. Saya tidak menyatakan penyesalan pribadi tentang transisi, karena saya tidak menggambarkan pernah bertransisi, dan saya tidak menyatakan identitas saat ini selain menjadi pria dengan pikiran trans yang telah terselesaikan.
Kisah lengkap
I'm male, and while I've had trans thoughts myself I have very little direct experience — my comments were about the male-to-female direction in general rather than my own medical transition. I never describe undergoing hormones, surgery, or a social transition; what I describe is having 'lingering thoughts' about transitioning that, in my own case, faded as I put effort into my masculinity.
I came to the r/detrans community in June 2022 and posted a series of comments over about ten days. My central claim, from my own experience, was that 'the more things i did to progress my masculinity (working out, and just being stronger and more dedicated mentally and physically) made me have those lingering thoughts practically disappear.' I framed transition as something that 'tends to happen to teenagers whose hormones are all over the place, and usually aren't very masculine themselves,' and I argued that while some people have genuine gender dysphoria, it 'might be much rarer than what people think.' My view was that someone who hasn't undergone medical treatment and simply tries to be their best self within their own gender 'will most likely be satisfied with what they got,' whereas someone on puberty blockers 'will probably still want to transition even in adulthood.'
Over the following days I became more critical of the wider trans community. I wrote that 'the more I read these posts the more I understand what the trans movement is about, it's about tricking insecure people in general to follow their transformation,' while carving out an exception for 'people with true dysphoria, the one that doesn't disappear once you reach your 20's.' I softened this in a follow-up, clarifying that a comment was 'not about you but more about the trans community in general and somewhat the push to turn someone trans.' When someone asked for advice about transgender thoughts, I recommended against transition: 'Yea no need to transition, i'd recommend getting into working out and trying to make your mental discipline stronger if your transgender thoughts are bothering you too much.'
I also gave a long, structured piece of self-help advice to another poster whose history showed self-harm, telling them their 'problems run deeper than just gender dysphoria' and recommending therapy first. My steps were: progressively overloading productivity starting with a clean environment and making your bed (and never compensating for missed days by doubling up); daily walks alone with your mind; practicing gratitude, especially toward people you dislike, possibly writing letters of gratitude; cultivating self-trust by forcing yourself to do things you don't feel like doing; and actually living in the world — speaking to people, holding eye contact for a few seconds, and reducing internet use, which I called 'one of the many dopamine faucets,' singling out Reddit as 'an extremely pessimistic place.' I said these methods 'helped with me but might not help with you,' while vouching that they would '100% help' people who feel dejected or worthless.
Separately, I engaged in extended debate about male violence, arguing that men are both perpetrators and victims of violent crime largely because of strength differences: 'Men are much stronger than women and tend to be the protectors and providers of society,' and 'if women were the stronger gender from the start women would be at the same 90% violent crime rate.' I argued masculinity itself is a driver of violence and risk-taking, discussed deterrence and the role of weapons ('it allows weak men to be strong in a fight'), and argued that men are genetically predisposed to violent rather than non-violent crime without being 'inherently crazier or violent.' I also argued that men have historically been sent to war and the frontlines because 'women are inherently more valuable than men (wombs are more valuable),' and that physically demanding, high-stress roles are 'always left to the man.'
I don't describe any diagnosis, medication, surgery, therapy I personally underwent (though I recommend therapy to others), family situation, relationship history, sexuality, or current identity beyond being a male with fading trans thoughts. I express no personal regret about transition because I don't describe having transitioned; my critique is directed at the trans movement and at encouraging insecure people to transition.