Semua kisah

Bertransisi sosial di kelompok aktivis, tak pernah memakai hormon

Perempuan · Desistensi331
Cerita-cerita ini telah diringkas menggunakan AI.

Di Reddit, orang sering berbagi pengalaman mereka di berbagai komentar atau postingan. Untuk membuat informasi ini lebih mudah diakses, detrans.ai mengumpulkan semua potongan tersebar menjadi satu ringkasan dan garis waktu yang mudah dibaca. Semua prompt sistem dicatat di halaman prompt.

Kadang AI dapat menghasilkan halusinasi atau menyatakan hal-hal yang tidak benar. Namun secara umum, cerita yang diringkas adalah refleksi yang akurat dari komentar asli oleh pengguna.

Ringkasan

Saya seorang perempuan yang detransisi yang bertransisi secara sosial dalam kelompok aktivis kiri pada usia pertengahan dua puluhan saat pulih dari kecanduan heroin dan hubungan yang penuh kekerasan, tetapi tidak pernah mengonsumsi hormon atau menjalani operasi. Saya perlahan-lahan desisted seiring membaiknya kesehatan mental, pertemanan, dan karier teknologi saya, dan feminisme radikal membantu saya memahami bahwa disforia saya berakar pada misogini yang terinternalisasi, didikan Muslim, serta penelantaran emosional dan kekerasan dari orang tua saya pada masa kecil. Saya menduga saya memiliki ADD dan OCD, dan saya memandang identifikasi trans sebagai pelarian yang umum di kalangan orang neurodivergen dan nonkonformis gender yang mengalami trauma. Kini saya gender critical dan secara terbuka menyuarakan posisi itu kepada teman-teman, sambil berupaya menerima tubuh saya dan kembali mengenakan pakaian feminin. Saya tidak menyesal karena tidak pernah bertransisi secara medis dan terus mengolah trauma di balik disforia saya.

Kisah lengkap

I was always pretty gender nonconforming — an awkward, nerdy girl who wore boys' clothes and flat sports bras, with stereotypically masculine hobbies and a career in software development/engineering. I developed breasts at 11 and had strong dysphoria about my chest from puberty onward, made worse by my Muslim family: my mom treated buying bras as shameful and secretive, tried to make me buy a too-small bra after learning I was a c-cup, my dad would yell if I wore shorts, and my mom would comment on my breasts or shirts where "the neck is too big." I only started feeling comfortable with my body in college. I started thinking I was trans in my mid-twenties, early in recovery from heroin addiction and while leaving an abusive relationship. My parents made me move back in with them, I was embarrassed and isolated myself from old college friends, became super depressed, and lurked in trans subreddits out of curiosity. I joined a leftist/communist activist group where people showered me with affection and attention as soon as I mentioned being transmasculine. I socially transitioned in that group. I saw transitioning as the solution to everything — maybe my "male brain" explained why I was depressed, anxious, socially awkward, and never fit in with "normal" girls. I told a friend I felt more like a *guy* than a *man*. I never came out to many people because my parents are religious, and I never liked the idea of a big coming-out post. I never got on testosterone. Learning about T's side effects like hair loss scared me away, and I only wanted to be a man if I could be tall and attractive — not a short guy with big hips. I gradually lost interest once I stopped feeling depressed. My communist group became more gender critical, then I researched on my own and concluded trans ideology is nonsense. Getting out of the house, making friends, being in a happy relationship, and getting a tech job effectively ended any desire to transition. I now identify as a woman and describe myself as a reidentified/detransitioned, gender critical person. I got into radical feminism and meditation/feminist spirituality/witchcraft, which I found more helpful than any therapy I'd tried — ritual and constructing a personal narrative of my trauma helped me heal. I realized my dysphoria came from internalized misogyny (I liked being gendered male online because it meant people took me seriously), internalized homophobia, and childhood trauma and emotional neglect from my parents. I thought I was bisexual but realized I'm not sexually attracted to men at all — I convinced myself because I thought I "owed" my parents a marriage, and subconsciously thought that if I'd been born a son I'd have had a real relationship with my dad, since he was verbally and emotionally abusive and I'd always sought emotional intimacy with men. More recently I realized I actually do like feminine clothes; I'd been scared of skirts and dresses at work fearing male coworkers would sexualize me. I wore a knee-length skirt and blouse to work and panicked that it was "too sexy," then reminded myself it was fine. I have an hourglass figure and have spent huge amounts of time self-conscious about whether outfits are too seductive. I was diagnosed with ADD as an adult and suspect I have OCD — I obsessively pick up interests (trans stuff, then communism, then dating a guy, then radical feminism) and pick at the skin around my nails. I believe I'm neurodivergent and that this plus GNC, trauma, and internalized misogyny/homophobia underlies most people's trans identification, which I view as escapism. I'm critical of the "trans industry," informed consent clinics, and pharmaceutical parallels to the opiate crisis, and I actively argue with friends about queer theory and try to make my gender critical friends more critical. I find pronoun circles and the "trans hug box" exhausting and hate talking about my gender identity. I'm a communist who views gender as bourgeois ideology; I believe sex is material and gender is a social construct.