Cerita-cerita ini telah diringkas menggunakan AI.
Di Reddit, orang sering berbagi pengalaman mereka di berbagai komentar atau postingan. Untuk membuat informasi ini lebih mudah diakses, detrans.ai mengumpulkan semua potongan tersebar menjadi satu ringkasan dan garis waktu yang mudah dibaca. Semua prompt sistem dicatat di halaman prompt.
Kadang AI dapat menghasilkan halusinasi atau menyatakan hal-hal yang tidak benar. Namun secara umum, cerita yang diringkas adalah refleksi yang akurat dari komentar asli oleh pengguna.
Ringkasan
Saya adalah seorang perempuan yang telah mendetransisi, yang bertransisi secara sosial dan mulai menggunakan testosteron saat kelas sembilan, menjalani top surgery, dan akhirnya memutuskan untuk mendetransisi setelah operasi tersebut tidak meredakan depresi saya. Saya mengalami disforia jenis kelamin yang parah dan rasa iri terhadap laki-laki, tetapi akhirnya meyakini bahwa disforia saya sebagian besar timbul dari keinginan akan hak istimewa dan peran sosial laki-laki, bukan murni bawaan lahir. Saya berencana berhenti menggunakan testosteron setelah mendetransisi secara sosial, dengan kekhawatiran akan kehilangan kekuatan fisik tetapi sama sekali tidak menginginkan rekonstruksi payudara. Saya masih merasa tertekan karena terlahir sebagai perempuan dan bergulat dengan keinginan seandainya saya terlahir sebagai laki-laki, meskipun saya menyadari bahwa detransisi diperlukan untuk melepaskan diri dari ketergantungan hormon seumur hidup. Saya memiliki pandangan kritis terhadap sikap komunitas trans maupun sebagian komunitas detrans terkait disforia dan detransisi.
Kisah lengkap
I first heard about the concept of being trans around fourth or fifth grade, around eight to ten years old, but I had no idea about specifics like gender dysphoria. Up until eighth grade I did not have significant sex dysphoria — I fantasized about being male occasionally but never to a serious extent. There were isolated incidents that people around me, particularly my mother, considered indicative of dysphoria, but in my opinion they didn't signify anything. In seventh grade I went through a non-binary/agender phase and convinced myself I had chest dysphoria to validate it, and that chest dysphoria persisted for a while even after I stopped identifying as non-binary.
I socially transitioned near the start of ninth grade and started testosterone near the end of ninth grade. I always hated the trans community and refused to use their words; I didn't self-identify as anything related to transgenderism and called myself transsexual around doctors. I later came to believe my dysphoria was partly inborn but largely 'self-actualized' — produced by the contradiction between my desire to be seen as male and a body that didn't fit that description. I knew I wanted to be male because everything about male roles and expectations seemed better, so I convinced myself I was dysphoric. The idea of living as a 'man' with female body parts made me feel subhuman.
I had top surgery. When I had it I felt nothing — no relief, no euphoria, no happiness. I waited and still felt nothing, just minor relief from not having to bind. The complete lack of relief from such a major surgery disillusioned me to the idea that fully transitioning would fix my depression. I don't exactly regret it and I'm fine with having a flat chest — the scars are the only part that bothers me. I never developed reverse dysphoria.
By December 2021, as a junior in high school, I was not entirely certain of detransitioning but viewed it as a definite possibility. My past two school photos showed me presenting as male, and it bothered me that I was stuck with them. I saw a picture of myself from about two years earlier, when I considered myself male and dressed as such but had no hormones, no chest surgery, no legal changes. I looked androgynous and happier. I felt I should have gotten therapy other than gender therapy, maybe psychiatric medication. I was depressed and found a scapegoat that made everything make sense — my discomfort with puberty, my depression, my masculinity, my inability to relate to women.
Every picture of myself I looked at was warped. Every interaction felt wrong. My name felt like a lie. My life felt like a lie. My therapist and parents asked what changes when I detransition. My detransition wasn't about changing my appearance — I'd be able to dress however I wanted without basing it entirely on passing as a cis man. The main change would be no longer being dependent on synthetic hormones.
I was a little over one year on testosterone when I posted in May 2022 that I wasn't getting off until I'd socially detransitioned, which I hadn't yet. I was scared of getting weaker — my max bench was 100 pounds. I planned to work out constantly when I stopped T so muscle would compensate. I had a thick neck, broad shoulders from working out, was completely flat-chested from surgery, and had an androgynous-masculine voice. I would never have reconstructive surgery on my chest but might wear a padded bra.
I struggled with wanting to stop wishing I was male. I wanted to stop feeling jealous of men. I was terrified of how people would see me, both as detrans and as a woman. I had casual acquaintances who were guys and didn't want them to see me differently. I wanted to pass as female but was unwilling to present feminine — I hated women's pants, wanted substantial pockets, wouldn't wear makeup other than maybe emo-type eyeliner, and would only go as long as a chin-length bob.
I never found female characters relatable. Their personalities felt really different from how I was or wanted to be. I related more to men. I didn't want other women to think they could relate to me or that I was 'one of them.' I hated the idea of being seen as a woman. I was woman on the sole basis that I was born female, no different than a man, and didn't want to be seen as different. I wanted to be tough, strong, not soft or feminine or nurturing. I recommended lifting weights to others in similar situations.
I experienced intense distress about being born female. I wished I'd been born male more than anything. I said if I could chop my arm off with an axe and it would make me male, I'd do it in a heartbeat. My lowest point was when I was near incapacitated by OCD over being completely dependent on synthetic hormones. I was scared of spending my entire life in limbo making sure I had access to hormones, or ending up abusing steroids to maintain broad shoulders and neck. I was happy I was flat-chested, happy my voice was deeper, happy I looked like a man, but my chromosomes were still female. I had sex dysphoria — distress with female body parts and sex characteristics on myself. I wanted lower surgery because men have penises.
I found detrans kink content on Tumblr when searching for normal detrans posts, tagged with #detrans by people I believed resented detransitioners. I thought a lot of it was severely misogynistic. I believed many detrans kink accounts were 'trans men' with internalized misogyny — not wanting to live as women daily because it's more difficult, but wanting to be a woman in bed because they view being female as hypersexualizing and degrading.
I did not have PCOS but had seen an unusually high number of ftms and detrans women who mentioned having it. I thought detransition was more common than recognized, and that the trans community didn't want people to talk about it because it made people question how accessible transition is with little to no counselling. I believed transition only breaks even for people with medium levels of dysphoria — never encouraging it for mild dysphoria, and believing it couldn't fully fix severe dysphoria since a transsexual could never be biologically of the sex they wished to be. I thought medical transition should be available but therapy's main aim should be helping cope with dysphoria without it.
I was upset that trans people viewed non-trans dysphorics as ticking time bombs, calling them 'repressors.' Even my gender therapist acknowledged dysphoria could be treated without transition. I felt the detrans community was great if you were just a GNC person who made a mistake, but if genuinely dysphoric it was hard to find useful advice. I believed the medical industry profited by touting medical transition as the only treatment for dysphoria.
Choosing a unisex name was extremely stressful — every name labeled unisex seemed to have a clear skew one way or the other. I wanted one starting with the same letter as my current name but couldn't find one.