Semua kisah

Dibesarkan Katolik, agnostik, lalu komunitas queer sebagai agamanya sendiri

Perempuan · Desistensi111
Cerita-cerita ini telah diringkas menggunakan AI.

Di Reddit, orang sering berbagi pengalaman mereka di berbagai komentar atau postingan. Untuk membuat informasi ini lebih mudah diakses, detrans.ai mengumpulkan semua potongan tersebar menjadi satu ringkasan dan garis waktu yang mudah dibaca. Semua prompt sistem dicatat di halaman prompt.

Kadang AI dapat menghasilkan halusinasi atau menyatakan hal-hal yang tidak benar. Namun secara umum, cerita yang diringkas adalah refleksi yang akurat dari komentar asli oleh pengguna.

Ringkasan

Saya seorang perempuan yang telah melakukan detransisi, lahir dalam keluarga Katolik, menjadi agnostik, dan menjauh dari komunitas trans serta komunitas queer yang lebih luas karena saya merasa komunitas itu telah menjadi seperti sekte dan agama tersendiri. Saya percaya sebagian orang dieksploitasi oleh tekanan untuk menjalani operasi dan prosedur yang kemudian mereka sesali, dan kini saya mengidentifikasi diri sebagai tomboy yang percaya diri alih-alih pria trans, meskipun saya masih merasa tidak nyaman dengan aspek perkembangan perempuan seperti payudara dan menstruasi. Saya menasihati orang lain untuk membiarkan diri mereka berkembang alih-alih menghambat pertumbuhan secara permanen, jika kelak mereka melakukan detransisi. Saya memiliki pandangan yang bernuansa tentang ruang perempuan: saya menentang orang yang jelas tampak seperti pria di ruang ganti, tetapi tidak keberatan ketika seseorang dibaca sebagai perempuan. Saya tidak menjelaskan intervensi medis, operasi, atau penggunaan hormon tertentu dalam pernyataan ini.

Kisah lengkap

I was born into a Catholic household, but I moved away from that and became agnostic, and I stayed agnostic. What made me want to separate from the trans community and the rest of the QIA+ was that they really do feel cult-like to me — it feels like its own religion. I think it's very hurtful to be too deeply invested in something that you lose yourself as a person. It's fine if you are religious or trans, but don't sink so deep that you are not yourself. I honestly do believe that some people are being taken advantage of with the whole 'you need surgery and procedures to fully transition' narrative. I feel like people in power push it so hard so that you feel like you need to spend your money on it, and then once you realize you've ruined something you can't get back, boom, you end up regretting it — obviously not everyone. I'm female and I was born female (I refer to myself as 'a afab' when discussing my fears about developing). I described being so paranoid of periods and growing breasts when I was younger. Even now I still don't feel super comfortable with those aspects of my body, but I'm definitely more confident as a tomboy than I would be as a trans man. I recommended to someone else — and it reflects my own thinking — letting yourself develop instead of permanently stunting your growth or not being able to get rid of boobs if you do decide to detransition after you have already transitioned. I've commented on other people's appearance and passing, noting when someone looks 'kinda androgynous but more female/trying to look male,' and giving feedback like 'you border between... from first glance I thought you were a man but when I get a good look I can see some feminine aspects.' I've suggested growing out hair, using makeup, and losing weight to accentuate bone structure. I also told someone they 'absolutely do not look 100% like kris or like a man at all' when they worried about a resemblance. On women's spaces, I said: 'Genuinely I think it is so invasive for grown men to feel so comfortable being in women's spaces specially like places where you need to change like locker rooms. Honestly if I really can't tell you are not a cis f in the bathroom most of the time I won't bat an eye. I only have an issue if I can clearly tell it's a man who just wants to invade and purposely make women uncomfortable.' I've also acknowledged that dysphoria can have deeper roots: 'Definitely sounds like you have larger issues that contribute to your dysphoria. While it may never go 100% away you can definitely try to alleviate it by attempting to become a little more comfortable in it. You don't need to be super manly to be a man and it's okay to like feminine things.' I've also shown understanding of fears about surgery costs, aging, and hair loss, noting hair loss is 'very genetical' and suggesting looking at family history of baldness. I complimented someone's photos, saying they looked 'so pretty in both pictures' and 'so much more confident and comfortable in the last picture.'