Semua kisah

Sebuah diagnosis, bukan identitas — dan pelajaran suara yang mengubah segalanya

Perempuan · Detransisi42
Cerita-cerita ini telah diringkas menggunakan AI.

Di Reddit, orang sering berbagi pengalaman mereka di berbagai komentar atau postingan. Untuk membuat informasi ini lebih mudah diakses, detrans.ai mengumpulkan semua potongan tersebar menjadi satu ringkasan dan garis waktu yang mudah dibaca. Semua prompt sistem dicatat di halaman prompt.

Kadang AI dapat menghasilkan halusinasi atau menyatakan hal-hal yang tidak benar. Namun secara umum, cerita yang diringkas adalah refleksi yang akurat dari komentar asli oleh pengguna.

Ringkasan

Saya seorang perempuan detrans. Saya percaya disforia gender itu nyata tetapi, seperti diagnosis DSM lainnya, mudah tertukar dengan kondisi yang tumpang tindih, dan saya tidak suka bahwa orang di Reddit tidak begitu saja mengatakan "saya tidak berpikir ini membuatmu trans". Saya lebih suka frasa "saya memiliki disforia gender" daripada menjadikannya identitas, sama seperti saya mengatakan "saya memiliki disabilitas" alih-alih "saya penyandang disabilitas". Saya mengambil pelajaran suara, yang secara drastis mengubah cara orang menjenderai saya. Saya tidak percaya transisi tidak pernah tepat.

Kisah lengkap

I am a detransitioned woman. My own transition and detransition are not the subject of these comments — what I have written publicly is mostly about how I think about gender dysphoria as a diagnosis, and about my own disability and voice. I do believe gender dysphoria is a real condition, but I compare it to other entries in the DSM: its symptoms overlap with other conditions, so diagnosis is genuinely difficult, in the same way that distinguishing depression from the depressive phase of bipolar disorder is difficult. I have been frustrated by what I see as a reluctance on Reddit for people to tell someone, honestly, "no, I don't think that makes you trans." When someone pushed back on me by arguing that this kind of diagnostic difficulty is just the entirety of mental health rather than something specific to gender dysphoria, I countered that they were describing mental health generally, not gender dysphoria specifically. In that exchange the other person seemed to me to hold the position that transition is never appropriate, and I told them I was not interested in arguing that point — I do not hold that view. I also pushed back on a comparison to schizophrenic delusions, pointing out that the first step in treating delusions is not to challenge or disprove them, citing the British Columbia Schizophrenia Society, though I acknowledged that was beside the point of the discussion. I have also written about a person with dissociative identity disorder who transitioned because of a gender-discordant identity — which I described as a common symptom of DID — and who, once he received proper treatment for DID, detransitioned. I noted that he did not have gender dysphoria but DID, and that after detransition he came to assume every trans person was him. On identity language, I have a disability, and I do not consider it part of my identity: I never say "I am a disabled woman" or "I am disabled" — always "I have a disability." Following that same logic, I said I really like the language "I have gender dysphoria," and that I had independently started using it myself. On passing and voice, I told someone that I thought they were at the point where their voice would make or break them, and asked whether they had taken voice lessons. I explained that I myself took voice lessons and noticed it made a drastic change in how people gendered me. I also described how hearing a person's voice flips my own perception: I first read a long-haired ski instructor as "she," and then, many minutes later, the first time I heard her voice, my perception flipped to "he."