Cerita-cerita ini telah diringkas menggunakan AI.
Di Reddit, orang sering berbagi pengalaman mereka di berbagai komentar atau postingan. Untuk membuat informasi ini lebih mudah diakses, detrans.ai mengumpulkan semua potongan tersebar menjadi satu ringkasan dan garis waktu yang mudah dibaca. Semua prompt sistem dicatat di halaman prompt.
Kadang AI dapat menghasilkan halusinasi atau menyatakan hal-hal yang tidak benar. Namun secara umum, cerita yang diringkas adalah refleksi yang akurat dari komentar asli oleh pengguna.
Ringkasan
Saya laki-laki heteroseksual yang selaras dengan jenis kelamin lahir saya dan tidak pernah bertransisi atau detransisi; saya anggota pendukung yang lama dan tenang di komunitas r/detrans. Pada April 2020 saya mencoba membagikan subreddit ini kepada seorang teman lesbian untuk menunjukkan sisi lain debat transisi, dan saya dilarang serta diberi tahu bahwa pendapat seorang "laki-laki hetero kulit putih yang selaras dengan jenis kelamin lahirnya" tidak relevan. Saya tidak memiliki posisi yang mapan tentang hukum transisi bawah-18 di Inggris, tetapi saya percaya pada informasi yang seimbang dan tak memihak serta diskusi terbuka. Saya tidak memiliki riwayat kesehatan mental, riwayat medis, atau penyesalan pribadi yang dilaporkan, dan saya terus mendukung hak orang yang detransisi untuk menceritakan kisah mereka.
Kisah lengkap
I've never identified as trans or detransitioned — I'm a bystander who has been a long-time lurker on this subreddit (on a newer account) because I'm genuinely interested in these issues. I'm a cisgender, heterosexual man, and I live in the UK.
In late April 2020, the UK passed a law requiring people to be 18 before fully transitioning with surgery and similar interventions. I hadn't looked into the details of the law itself and I explicitly hold no opinion on whether it is good or bad. A personal friend of mine — a lesbian I used to work with, who lives close enough that I see her out and about regularly — was ranting on social media calling the UK government "sick" and transphobic for passing it.
I messaged her privately, trying to be polite and neutral, and linked her to this subreddit and the stories of its posters, many of whom change their mind by the time they turn 18. I suggested the law might not be "sick and transphobic" as she claimed, but could actually help young people who might otherwise inflict lasting damage on their bodies which they may later regret. My aim was not to prove the law was good or bad, but simply to expose her to another side of the trans community that doesn't dogmatically agree with her on every issue — to get her to look at, or at least acknowledge, more than one side of the coin.
She refused to even entertain the idea. She told me I was trying to spread my "het cis white male" opinion and invalidate trans people — simply for linking her to real trans and detrans people's stories. Despite living in close proximity and seeing her regularly (before the quarantine), she blocked me on social media.
The post attracted a lot of pushback in the comments, including people labeling me transphobic and accusing me of hateful comments. In one instance, a commenter claimed I had made a hateful comment replying to them, then — after somehow knowing they had read it — claimed I had edited the comment to make it seem nice, and reported me. I've noticed this kind of thing happening for a while and picking up lately: people reporting opinions, facts, quotes and studies they don't like, and brigading. I noted that the mods are active and aware of it, and that if I were transphobic or hateful the mods would have removed my post or banned me.
My broader philosophy is: "if you're not hurting anybody else or infringing on anybody else rights - go crazy!" But I also think there's something to be said for protecting people and making sure everyone gets good, balanced and unbiased information. I believe that if the mere existence of something contrary to an ideal makes it crumble, it wasn't really strong to begin with, and that when people try to censor and shut down speech rather than debate, it suggests their position is weak or unfounded in logic, science, evidence or history. This experience made me understand what some posters here talk about — that the LGBT community can have a very "you're with us or against us" attitude and may push, pull or manipulate people in certain directions. I love what this subreddit attempts to be and the space it creates for real conversation, which is why I tried to pass it along to a friend, albeit unsuccessfully.
I've also engaged supportively with detransitioners' posts — congratulating one on their progress, telling another "you've got to do what's right for you, it's your life," and expressing that I found it strange that one poster's mother was resistant and almost manipulative regarding their detransition, advising them to look out for themselves.