Cerita-cerita ini telah diringkas menggunakan AI.
Di Reddit, orang sering berbagi pengalaman mereka di berbagai komentar atau postingan. Untuk membuat informasi ini lebih mudah diakses, detrans.ai mengumpulkan semua potongan tersebar menjadi satu ringkasan dan garis waktu yang mudah dibaca. Semua prompt sistem dicatat di halaman prompt.
Kadang AI dapat menghasilkan halusinasi atau menyatakan hal-hal yang tidak benar. Namun secara umum, cerita yang diringkas adalah refleksi yang akurat dari komentar asli oleh pengguna.
Ringkasan
Saya adalah seorang perempuan yang berdetransisi atau desisted yang bersikap kritis terhadap transisi medis, terutama bagi anak di bawah umur, dan saya berbicara berdasarkan pengalaman pribadi langsung dengan penghambat pubertas, yang saya yakini menyebabkan dampak berbahaya yang permanen. Saya telah aktif di komunitas detransisi setidaknya sejak tahun 2020, menawarkan dukungan kepada orang lain sekaligus mendorong bantuan kejiwaan bagi orang-orang yang saya khawatirkan. Saya berpandangan teguh bahwa terlahir perempuan bukanlah sebuah hak istimewa, bahwa jenis kelamin biologis berbeda dari ekspresi gender, dan bahwa ruang-ruang pro-trans tertentu memicu kebingungan. Saya menentang mereka yang melabeli feminis kritis sebagai TERF sembari merasakan perasaan yang serupa. Identitas saya saat ini adalah seorang perempuan yang berdetransisi/desisted yang bersikap kritis terhadap ideologi gender.
Kisah lengkap
I have been active in detransition spaces since at least March 2020, and much of what I've written there reflects experiences and convictions I hold deeply. Early on, I responded to someone who had transitioned as a minor, telling them that what was done to them was not their fault and, in my view, not truly their choice, because they were a child who shouldn't have had full autonomy over such decisions. I tried to offer them hope that they would find others who had been through similar things and that life would not feel so permanently ruined or frightening forever.
I have direct personal experience with puberty blockers. When someone claimed something negative about blockers, I pushed back firmly, saying I wasn't biased and had actual experience, and I urged them to research blockers outside of an affirmative-care framework — to look up the specific drugs used off-label as blockers and investigate their non-trans medical uses, where, I said, they would find dangerous effects, some of them permanent. This is a conviction I hold based on my own experience and what I've learned.
I've also been open about concerns for other people's mental health in these communities. In May 2020, I told someone directly that I thought they needed to seek psychiatric help as soon as possible, saying I was greatly concerned for their wellbeing and aware others shared that concern. When they accused me of guilt, I defended myself — saying I had in no way guilted them — and ended the conversation, noting that this was precisely why I had stayed quiet before.
I've been critical of certain spaces and framings. I warned someone that a particular subreddit was very pro-trans and might only further their confusion. In another exchange, I told someone that they clearly had some of the same feelings as us yet called us TERFs, framing that as something worth thinking about. I've also tried to be reassuring to detransitioned or desisting people, complimenting their appearance and telling them their faces looked feminine to me.
On the question of sex and envy, I've been quite direct. I told someone that girls aren't lucky to be born female, and that once they understood this it would help with their envy — arguing that it is a privilege to not be born female. When pressed, I invoked sexism as the reason. I've also drawn sharp conceptual lines, insisting that feminine/masculine is not the same as female/male, and I've told people they need to think objectively. I've also defended the position that women can have short hair and still be women.
I don't state my current identity explicitly in these comments, but the consistent framing — speaking as part of a 'we' that includes people called TERFs, defending sex-based analysis, and drawing firm lines between sex and gender expression — indicates I am a detransitioned or desisted female who is critical of gender ideology and of medical transition, particularly for minors.