Semua kisah

Empat tahun transisi sosial, tanpa hormon, dan masih mempertanyakan

Perempuan · Desistensi215
Cerita-cerita ini telah diringkas menggunakan AI.

Di Reddit, orang sering berbagi pengalaman mereka di berbagai komentar atau postingan. Untuk membuat informasi ini lebih mudah diakses, detrans.ai mengumpulkan semua potongan tersebar menjadi satu ringkasan dan garis waktu yang mudah dibaca. Semua prompt sistem dicatat di halaman prompt.

Kadang AI dapat menghasilkan halusinasi atau menyatakan hal-hal yang tidak benar. Namun secara umum, cerita yang diringkas adalah refleksi yang akurat dari komentar asli oleh pengguna.

Ringkasan

Saya desist setelah sekitar empat tahun transisi sosial (tidak pernah memakai hormon, karena ibu saya memblokir HRT), menyadari bahwa transisi saya berakar pada trauma masa kecil. Saya kehilangan sebagian besar teman queer saya saat desist tetapi mendapat yang baru, dan menjauh dari lingkaran aktivisme trans sangat mengurangi disforia saya. Saya seorang perempuan desist, biseksual, yang masih tidak terlalu menyukai menjadi perempuan dan berencana menjalani pengangkatan atau pengurangan payudara karena payudara besar yang menyebabkan nyeri fisik. Saya masih agak ragu apakah benar untuk desist, dan saya memiliki pandangan kritis terhadap transisi, terutama untuk anak di bawah umur.

Kisah lengkap

I realized I was transitioning because of childhood trauma, and the process of desisting has been one of the most isolating experiences of my life. I was socially transitioned for about four years before I desisted — social only, because my mom wouldn't let me do HRT. All of my "queer" friends basically disowned me when I desisted; they assumed I was desisting because of transphobia or something. My normie friends, by contrast, were basically just like "aight so what do we call you?" I lost most of my friends when I desisted, which forced me to find new groups and make new friends. It was scary, but I still think it's better to be yourself alone than be someone else with everybody else. I worry a lot about my younger trans cousin hating me, because after four years of mostly socializing with other young trans people I know what they say about desisted/detrans people. I also realized that the transmed circles I was in were kind of "radfem lite" and talked about having sexual trauma a lot — and in my personal experience, transitioning doesn't help trauma-induced dysphoria. After disengaging with my more trans activist and trans teen circles, my dysphoria lessened a lot. I came to the conclusion that I would act and dress how I liked, and if the dysphoria persisted I'd go do the medical stuff. I never did HRT. I have always had a large chest, so there's physical pain to add onto the mental discomfort. I plan to either get them removed or reduced. Honestly these feelings make me question if I was right to desist. I'm bi and I still don't particularly like being female, so it's a bit different for me — but it frustrates me how much some people would prefer we be men than non-conforming women. Once I desisted I got a lot of "why do you still look and act like a guy even if you're not trans anymore," mostly from lgbt activists. My advice to others is to find friends who didn't know you before you desisted. People might assume I'm a guy off the way I look, but most won't tell me I should transition when I correct them. I'm critical of the idea that only trans people question their gender, so if you question your gender you must be trans — I think it's ridiculous. I don't think lgb issues really align with trans issues; we want very different things. I think a large part of transition among minors is social — I remember seeing something about 50 percent of kids at a particular clinic were neurodivergent or autistic — and that minors who don't have gender dysphoria, want the love bombing that comes with being in trans circles, and don't present their gender to adults' satisfaction are way more at risk of regretting transition. I also think people don't stop being gay, and that the medical system will let any old person start hormones without therapy or an actual diagnosis.