Semua kisah

Satu artikel psikoanalitik, 100 suntikan, dan sedekade pelarian

Laki-laki · Detransisi119
Cerita-cerita ini telah diringkas menggunakan AI.

Di Reddit, orang sering berbagi pengalaman mereka di berbagai komentar atau postingan. Untuk membuat informasi ini lebih mudah diakses, detrans.ai mengumpulkan semua potongan tersebar menjadi satu ringkasan dan garis waktu yang mudah dibaca. Semua prompt sistem dicatat di halaman prompt.

Kadang AI dapat menghasilkan halusinasi atau menyatakan hal-hal yang tidak benar. Namun secara umum, cerita yang diringkas adalah refleksi yang akurat dari komentar asli oleh pengguna.

Ringkasan

Saya adalah seorang pria detransisi yang teridentifikasi sebagai trans selama lebih dari satu dekade, bertransisi secara medis dengan spironolakton, progesteron, dan lebih dari 100 suntikan, serta mulai berdetransisi sekitar bulan Desember 2019 setelah membaca artikel psikoanalitik Ruth Stein tentang transeksualisme, yang membuat saya untuk pertama kalinya merasa muak terhadap kecenderungan trans saya. Saya kini mengaitkan identifikasi trans saya dengan trauma masa kecil dari kedua orang tua yang disfungsional — termasuk seorang ibu yang menginginkan saya menjadi anak perempuan dan seorang ayah yang kasar serta tidak hadir secara emosional — ditambah kompleksitas psikologis yang belum terselesaikan dan penggunaan transgenderisme sebagai pelarian dari keharusan menghadapi hubungan dan kenyataan. Saya berencana untuk berdetransisi, menemukan seorang wanita untuk dicintai, memiliki anak, dan menjadi seorang suami serta ayah. Saya sangat kritis terhadap komunitas trans dan terhadap transisi sebagai sebuah ideologi, dan pada Mei 2020 saya aktif mencari saran terapi (CBT, DBT, mindfulness) untuk mengatasi detransisi.

Kisah lengkap

I had believed I was transgender for over ten years — at one point I said it had been twenty years of feeling trans — and I'd carried a deep skepticism about it the whole time. In December 2019 I read Ruth Stein's article "Analysis of a case of transsexualism," and for the first time in my life I felt disgust at my own trans inclinations. Reading it made my stomach and body churn, because it put into a coherent story things I hadn't been able to articulate: all the years I had suppressed transitioning because something in my mind insisted there was more to it, and all my unresolved conflicts and the ways I'd handled them. The article's framework matched my own psychology almost exactly, except that my father was simply emotionally unavailable and abusive rather than whatever the article described. I came from two dysfunctional parents, psychologically broken people who projected their brokenness onto me. My mother wished I was a girl — that's a fact I stated plainly. I recognized in myself a majority of the psychological complexes the article described. I feared falling in love with a real woman because of the mental complexity I thought it required to rewire my brain to be a man and accept her femininity as genuine rather than manipulative or meant to harm me. I described a "sick urge" for women to love me and then nurture me "like some fucked up child," and I said this had hindered my ability to have relationships because I didn't want to project my damaged self onto anyone. I also worried about internalized attitudes toward women, saying I'd rather be a man and fall in love with a woman and face that experience than create myself into a woman and escape reality. I had medically transitioned: I said I had stabbed 100+ needles into myself and taken spironolactone and progesterone, among other things. By late December 2019 I was publicly saying I was going back to find a woman I could love, like the ones I had given up, go back to being a man, hopefully have some kids, and be an excellent spouse and father. I acknowledged I was "feminine" and wanted to sew, cook, and grow a garden, but said I still didn't want to be something I am not. I started reading the psychological literature because, between euphoric moments of acceptance, I was deeply questioning the legitimacy of my own mental states and their biological origins — whether this was truly a biological condition or a psychological one. What I found was the realization that I had been using transgenderism as an escape from conquering mental barriers: refusing to "man up," refusing to face my own ego death in relationships with women, refusing to accept the genetic truth I believed God gave me and to feel comfortable in my own skin. I came to believe that parental relationships, family, community, and individual psychology can contribute to this psychological disorder manifesting itself, and that without a reality check it turns into transgenderism. I described it as projecting my feelings into an identity. I was critical of the trans community. I said the trans community hates anyone who doesn't believe in their ideology, that there is a typical narrative in trans groups and rarely do people deviate, and that when someone detransitions you completely destroy the security of their narrative, so they push you away. I said I'd been in trans groups for years and had come to see why many people lie about transitioning — they hide things — and that the unconscious bias in the community is harmful. I also said most trans people I met didn't have their lives together, their cognitive functioning was off, they never acknowledged family or community issues, and that being transgender is "the greatest escape from reality," a crutch, and that you could see "utter freaking emptiness" in their eyes. I allowed I might be wrong. In May 2020 I posted asking what kind of therapy others were doing to cope with detransitioning — how they were mentally healing and coming to accept themselves, and what they'd been thinking when they transitioned that they now realize is different. I asked others to articulate what went on in childhood that caused them to believe they were trans versus how they see those things now, and what they were misinterpreting. I said I wished I could have seen the underlying premises in my brain that made me think "because of I, II, III, IIII, therefore I felt being trans was the best solution to life." I was also asking people about using CBT, DBT, and mindfulness, and asking for examples of how therapy contributed to changing their thoughts. I described most transgender people, myself included, as stemming from an unwillingness to accept themselves in their totality — sublimating their fears, anxieties, and stresses into another persona in hopes of alleviating the true struggles they face with family, friends, themselves, and life.