Semua kisah

Mengaku trans beberapa pekan setelah coming out — lalu berhenti

Perempuan · Desistensi225
Cerita-cerita ini telah diringkas menggunakan AI.

Di Reddit, orang sering berbagi pengalaman mereka di berbagai komentar atau postingan. Untuk membuat informasi ini lebih mudah diakses, detrans.ai mengumpulkan semua potongan tersebar menjadi satu ringkasan dan garis waktu yang mudah dibaca. Semua prompt sistem dicatat di halaman prompt.

Kadang AI dapat menghasilkan halusinasi atau menyatakan hal-hal yang tidak benar. Namun secara umum, cerita yang diringkas adalah refleksi yang akurat dari komentar asli oleh pengguna.

Ringkasan

Saya perempuan lesbian yang selaras dengan jenis kelamin lahir saya, sempat mengidentifikasi sebagai trans sebentar setelah menyatakan diri secara terbuka, lalu menahan diri dari transisi tanpa pernah memakai hormon atau menjalani operasi. Kini saya memahami kebencian terhadap tubuh saya sebagai produk pubertas dini, pelecehan seksual sejak usia muda, peran gender, homofobia, dan tatapan maskulin, bukan sebagai menjadi laki-laki. Saya tidak pernah menjalani transisi medis, jadi tidak ada perubahan ireversibel atau kekhawatiran kesuburan yang perlu disebut. Saya vokal menentang transisi medis kaum muda dan menganjurkan penghapusan huruf T dari LGB. Kesehatan mental saya membaik dengan berfokus pada hobi, pendidikan, dan tujuan di luar gender.

Kisah lengkap

I am a cis female who grew up preferring what people called "masculine" things — I played with Hot Wheels and rough physical games with my cousins. I started puberty early: my breasts began developing around age 9 and my period started at 10. By 11 I was being sexualised by males, and I realised I was a lesbian at fourteen. When I came out to some friends and family, they responded with the "only man and woman can love each other" line, and I began to question my gender. I had already hated my body, and with that I started to think I was trans. I found the detrans community about a year before I posted in early 2020, and reading other people's stories — especially FtMtF ones — helped me understand how much gender roles, homophobia, and the male gaze had shaped how I saw myself. I came to feel that I didn't hate my body because it was male but because of what had happened to me. I never took hormones or puberty blockers; I describe myself as a desister rather than a detransitioner, and I have said I am glad I was never given drugs for it. Specific memories stand out. When I was 10 or 11 I outgrew my bras while visiting my dad; he wouldn't take me himself, so he asked my old kindergarten teacher, a family friend, to take me to get sized. She took me to Victoria's Secret, and the woman sizing me and my teacher talked about how big they were for my age and how I "wanted them at that age." At 13 I was a summer volunteer at a library when a grown man came over and flirted with me; I clearly looked underage but he didn't care, and it took the librarian kicking him out and putting him on a ban list for him to leave. The librarian walked me to my dad's car because she was so afraid for me. Even after I came out as a lesbian this kept happening. I grew up in a Mormon town and visited my dad in Oklahoma, and there were no consequences for these men and boys — which is part of why I hated my body beyond just my weight issue. I have described having severe anxiety about men staring at me, and I still barely get along with most women, especially straight women. I mostly hung out with guys growing up; I had only four female friends and never more than one at a time. I would not have come out as trans after coming out as gay because of the shame attached to it. I have also mentioned that focusing on hobbies, education, career and relationship goals outside of gender helped me most in realising what I actually wanted. I never medically transitioned, but I have spoken at length about what testosterone does — hair loss, early menopause, destroyed singing voices — and said I don't know how I would react to losing my singing voice. I have advised others to find a non-gender therapist, to look at body dysmorphia rather than gender issues, and to consider whether trauma or male attention is driving the wish to transition. My views on the wider debate are strongly stated: I support dropping the T from LGB, I have been called transphobic for wanting to "de-transition" (technically desisting) and for not dating trans women when I have a real fear of men and their bodies, and I have written critically of trans women in female spaces. I have proposed that no transitioning — blockers, hormones, or surgeries — should happen before age 18, that therapy should explore other factors first, that nothing artificial should be treated as gendered, that girls and boys should not be raised so differently, and that desisting and detransitioning should be discussed openly in LGBTQ+ spaces. I have also expressed relief at never being medicated when I read about others who were put on hormones young. Outside of all this, I love theatre — I cried over Sara Bareilles' show and songs like "She Used to be Mine" and "You Matter to Me."