Cerita-cerita ini telah diringkas menggunakan AI.
Di Reddit, orang sering berbagi pengalaman mereka di berbagai komentar atau postingan. Untuk membuat informasi ini lebih mudah diakses, detrans.ai mengumpulkan semua potongan tersebar menjadi satu ringkasan dan garis waktu yang mudah dibaca. Semua prompt sistem dicatat di halaman prompt.
Kadang AI dapat menghasilkan halusinasi atau menyatakan hal-hal yang tidak benar. Namun secara umum, cerita yang diringkas adalah refleksi yang akurat dari komentar asli oleh pengguna.
Ringkasan
Saya adalah seorang perempuan yang telah mendetransisi/berhenti bertransisi (desisted) yang hidup sebagai laki-laki dari usia sekitar 9 hingga 17–18 tahun, tidak pernah bertransisi secara medis tetapi melakukan binding setiap hari dan menggunakan minoksidil agar tampak seperti laki-laki. Disforia saya memudar setelah penurunan berat badan, peristiwa pemerkosaan pada Juni 2024, dan menyadari betapa bahagianya saya saat berpakaian sebagai perempuan; sejak saat itu saya hidup sebagai perempuan. Saya mengalami dampak fisik yang menetap akibat binding (nyeri punggung dan tulang rusuk, payudara kendur, penipisan rambut di pelipis) serta tekanan emosional yang berat terkait pengalaman masa kecil yang hilang, ciri-ciri maskulin yang tidak bisa saya abaikan, dan permusuhan dari mantan teman-teman trans. Saya telah menjalani terapi sepanjang proses detransisi saya dan kini mengaitkan disforia saya dengan seksisme yang terinternalisasi dan rasa takut terhadap seksualisasi. Saya bersikap kritis terhadap transisi medis bagi anak di bawah umur dan menyuarakan aspirasi orang-orang yang mendetransisi, dan meskipun saya masih bergulat dengan penampilan saya, saya dapat mengatakan bahwa saya bahagia hidup sebagai diri saya sendiri.
Kisah lengkap
I am a female who identified as a boy for about eight years, roughly from age 9 or 10 until I was 17 or 18. I never took hormones and never had surgery, but I did everything I could to look male: I wore a binder for 24 hours a day, I put minoxidil on my face and eyebrows trying to grow a beard, I wore baggy clothes, hats, and unflattering haircuts, and I taped my chest down. I skipped prom because I couldn't bring myself to wear a dress, and I never really dated in school. The dysphoria went away a few months before I was 18, and I decided to live as a girl. I like being a girl. I am a girl.
The detransition wasn't a single event. A big part was losing weight — I had an eating disorder, and I hated being fat, but it felt much better to think of myself as a fat boy than a fat girl, because a fat boy was funny and people still liked him, while a fat girl seemed to have nothing. When I slimmed down, my hips and breasts looked fine to me and I looked good as a woman. Another part was that I was raped in June 2024; dealing with the police and the doctors meant that for once I wasn't thinking about gender, and strangely that was some of the freest I had ever felt. The final thing was dressing up as a girl to go steal liquor without being recognized — hiding in plain sight — and when I got home I realized I felt genuinely happy in the skirt and makeup, and crushed when I had to take it off. Around the time I turned 18, my trans friends started pressuring me about hormones; when I said I wasn't sure they turned hostile, which opened my eyes.
The physical damage I have to live with is from binding, not from testosterone. My back and spine constantly hurt, my ribs ache when I yawn or cough, I can't hold my breath like I used to, and my breasts are saggy and deflated from years of being smashed down or taped. I also thinned the hair at my temples with minoxidil, lost eyebrow hair, and grew tiny mustache hairs that grow back within a day even if I wax. I also feel like my hairline is masculine, though I never started T.
Emotionally I feel stunted. I mourn the childhood and high school years I lost — prom, dating, real friendships. The only kids who accepted me were the other trans kids, and even there I was the punching bag. I am angry at myself for wasting ten years hiding in a lie. When I look in the mirror I still see a man; I spent eight years obsessing over every millimeter of skin that looked masculine and being happy when people pointed out my masculine features, and now I can't unsee it. I've cried for ten minutes straight after seeing myself in my phone in a skirt and makeup, feeling like an ugly man painting his face. I feel like a failure of a woman, like I'm masquerading as a girl, and I'm embarrassed by old photos — I tell people it was just a cringe phase and I don't tell anyone who I used to be.
The social fallout was severe. When I started presenting as a girl, long-term friends turned on me with vile things — that I was a liar, a trend hopper, taking the easy way out, that I just wanted to show myself off, that I was 'asking for something to happen.' I changed my socials to my birth sex and most of the trans friends stopped talking to me on their own; I ignored the rest because I couldn't handle it. I can't leave the house now unless I'm fully done up in makeup, hair, and clothes, because I have to be obviously a girl, and even then I hear what people said about me showing myself off.
I have been in therapy through every step of my detransition, before and after, and I believe therapy is very beneficial for this kind of thing — that many people who end up in this position are heavily damaged individuals and treating the root issue helps them not seek comfort in trans groups, which I feel are trauma-bond focused. I now think the root of my dysphoria was internalized sexism: I didn't want to be sexualized, have my worth boiled down to my body, be talked down to, or be what women are in the media; I had come to believe women were inferior because that was how everyone treated them. I didn't want to be a man, I wanted to be my idea of a man — someone taken seriously. I also think everyone experiences some gender dysphoria, comparing myself to Billy Joel in the Uptown Girl video.
I am now critical of medical transition for minors. I say I would 100% have jumped on hormones as a kid if my parents had allowed it, and that if I had gone on testosterone I'd have killed myself by now. I'm glad my parents were transphobic because the hate saved me in a way. I argue kids can't get tattoos, cigarettes, or alcohol, so they shouldn't be able to take body-altering hormones before their frontal lobe has developed, and that what they need is therapy, medication, and support, not hormones. I've gotten heavily downvoted for this on Reddit but I take it in stride and say someone has to speak up for these kids. I consider myself an advocate for detransitioners' voices being heard — that it's just as important to hear detransitioners as transitioners, and that we are proof that sometimes it is a phase and precautions need to be taken. I am not transphobic myself. As of my most recent posts, I still identify as a girl and say I cherish every moment living as me, though I still hurt and still struggle with how I look.