Semua kisah

Berencana bertransisi — lalu membaca kisah-kisah detransisi

Perempuan · Desistensi741
Cerita-cerita ini telah diringkas menggunakan AI.

Di Reddit, orang sering berbagi pengalaman mereka di berbagai komentar atau postingan. Untuk membuat informasi ini lebih mudah diakses, detrans.ai mengumpulkan semua potongan tersebar menjadi satu ringkasan dan garis waktu yang mudah dibaca. Semua prompt sistem dicatat di halaman prompt.

Kadang AI dapat menghasilkan halusinasi atau menyatakan hal-hal yang tidak benar. Namun secara umum, cerita yang diringkas adalah refleksi yang akurat dari komentar asli oleh pengguna.

Ringkasan

Saya adalah orang yang telah detransisi atau desisted yang, per Maret 2022, berada dalam kondisi ‘belum melakukan apa pun’ dan berencana mencoba fase latihan beban yang hiper-maskulin sebelum memutuskan apakah akan menempuh MTF atau transisi non-biner. Membaca kisah orang lain di forum ini mengubah pikiran saya dan membuat saya melihat transisi sebagai pilihan ekstrem dan mungkin tren yang buruk, bukan gangguan identitas. Saya tetap berhaluan kiri dan mendukung otonomi tubuh serta perlindungan antidiskriminasi, tetapi saya kritis terhadap ideologi, terhadap serangan daring massal terhadap orang-orang yang detransisi, dan terhadap influencer media sosial yang menirukan pendapat mayoritas. Saya tidak menjelaskan intervensi medis, operasi, atau penggunaan hormon apa pun dalam transkrip ini. Identitas dan status saya saat ini setelah fase latihan beban tidak disebutkan.

Kisah lengkap

I first wrote in March 2022 that I was 'pre everything' and that the thread I was reading described me. I said I was going to start a 'hyper masculine weight training phase' and that if that didn't work out, I would 'go MTF or non-binary.' In the same month I thanked someone for pointing out that 'the fetishizing and fixation is real,' adding that I really needed to get healthy regardless. I am leftist and believe in body autonomy and in all legal and anti-discrimination protections. Reading the experiences people shared on this board changed my mind and made me think more clearly about how extreme transitioning is. I reasoned that seeing spotty trans cases here and there would make sense, but seeing parents cheering on two out of two, and three out of three of their own kids transitioning seemed less like an identity crisis and more like a bad trend. I have thought about how expectations get assigned. I noted that in Asian horoscopes you can be assigned feminine or masculine, and that in my family my Mom was assigned masculine and my Dad assigned feminine — my Mom loves confrontation, is independent, an entrepreneur, and has a temper, while my Dad has attention to detail and is small in stature. My conclusion was that sometimes we fit into what is expected of us or it's just random with confirmation bias. I also wondered aloud whether my thinking was coherent, saying that sometimes my mind makes connections where others don't see it. In October 2022 I reacted strongly to the phrase 'burden of upholding feminism,' saying that ideologies come and go and that conforming oneself to uphold an ideology makes you an ideologue, which is a terrible way to live. I pointed to the Iranian protests as an example of what female expectation can look like under a given country/government/community, and asked why we should beholden ourselves to certain ideas. My advice to myself and others was: 'Live, be free, scrape enough to get by, and squeeze a little enjoyment out of life.' That same month I posted a thread titled 'Dunking on KCMiller1225,' expressing that the trans community's pile-on against this person on Twitter was disconcerting — posts saying things like 'why are you discounting my transition' and 'it's your fault you signed up to be male.' I felt the dogpiling was going on and on everywhere and that many people lacked the context of what was happening on Twitter. I also commented that most influencers seek out the majority opinion and speak their 'take,' or they are idiots, because in the online career and social media game being cancelled is the end, and that sadly they had already covered their ass. I have been supportive and encouraging of others here, telling one person their revelations were powerful and would help them get better, and thanking another for sharing, calling them eloquent and wishing them the best going forward. As of my last activity in July 2024, I had seen a couple of people ask a question and then disappear, and I asked for an update if anyone found out.