Cerita-cerita ini telah diringkas menggunakan AI.
Di Reddit, orang sering berbagi pengalaman mereka di berbagai komentar atau postingan. Untuk membuat informasi ini lebih mudah diakses, detrans.ai mengumpulkan semua potongan tersebar menjadi satu ringkasan dan garis waktu yang mudah dibaca. Semua prompt sistem dicatat di halaman prompt.
Kadang AI dapat menghasilkan halusinasi atau menyatakan hal-hal yang tidak benar. Namun secara umum, cerita yang diringkas adalah refleksi yang akurat dari komentar asli oleh pengguna.
Ringkasan
Saya wanita yang detransisi (desisted) yang sangat disforik sebagai remaja, tetapi disforianya mereda sekitar usia 17 setelah bertahun-tahun terapi untuk gangguan kecemasan sosial, keluar dari hubungan beracun, fokus pada sekolah, dan dewasa dari masa pubertas yang sulit. Saya tidak pernah menyebut menjalani hormon atau operasi. Kini saya mengidentifikasi sebagai tomboy dan wanita nonkonformis gender, masih kadang merasa iri pada tubuh pria tetapi mengelolanya dengan memakai pakaian yang lebih longgar. Saya menasihati orang lain untuk tetap sibuk, berolahraga, menghindari ruang gema media sosial, dan pergi terapi, dan saya mengkritik narasi transisi tertentu, menggambarkan beberapa kasus sebagai 'fetish' dan membela perbedaan sosialisasi berbasis jenis kelamin.
Kisah lengkap
I was extremely dysphoric as a teenager and struggled for years, but the dysphoria faded away at around 17. Looking back, several things converged to make that happen. First, I was too busy with school to think about my appearance because I wanted to get into my dream college. Second, I got out of a toxic relationship with a guy who destroyed my self-esteem — he clearly wasn't into me but wouldn't break up with me either, and left me to struggle in the relationship on my own. Third, around the time I turned 17 I became less of a hormonal teenager; my body stopped aching and changing. Fourth, I had already spent years in therapy dealing with a social anxiety disorder, and I was finally able to properly communicate and trust others.
I disisted (desisted) without ever going on hormones or having surgery, as far as my posts describe. The way of thinking that helped me most was reminding myself that "being a woman" doesn't entail much more than literally being called one and having female pronouns — nothing else about me changed compared to when I considered myself a man. Any other qualities tied to being female were also still there when I considered myself a man, so not much changed at all. I also worked on the subconscious associations I had with the word "woman" — the exaggerated associations people might have, like Barbie or Kim Kardashian, or qualities such as soft, nurturing, and submissive. In reality, being a woman doesn't mean any of those things; it only means being a human being with the capacity to bear children, which isn't even necessary to do. Working on that subconscious way of thinking helped me.
I still occasionally get jealous of a male physique, but I combat the feeling by dressing in baggier clothes. I identify as a gnc (gender non-conforming) woman and a tomboy. I try to accept and love myself as I am so other gnc people can follow suit — I told someone else considering escaping manhood, "Why narrow down the definition of manhood by trying to escape it when you could do your best to accept and love yourself as you are, so other people can follow suit and do the same about themselves? That's what I'm trying to do as a gnc woman myself, even if it's hard at times."
My advice to others in a similar place has been to stay busy and active: get a job if you don't have one, pick up a sport or work out more frequently, and avoid social media echo chambers where people talk about these types of issues as though there is no hope — that's what helped me. I also suggest going to therapy if you haven't already. I don't describe any specific trauma beyond the toxic relationship and the social anxiety disorder I was treated for over years of therapy.
On related questions, I've said it's possible to admire or be jealous of other people's bodies without it being dysphoria. I've been blunt in saying that some cases of male transition desire are "a fetish." I've also argued strongly that having a female or male body does affect how you're socialised and treated by society and by doctors, calling the denial of that "male entitlement" — "only a man who hasn't had to deal with menstrual pain and being looked down upon for being a girl would deny that." On dating, I've noted as a tomboy that there are men out there who like or prefer tomboys, usually gnc themselves, so if that's your type you're in luck.
I don't describe my current mental health in detail beyond the social anxiety disorder I was treated for as a teenager, and I don't mention any suicidal ideation, self-harm, or suicide attempts.