Cerita-cerita ini telah diringkas menggunakan AI.
Di Reddit, orang sering berbagi pengalaman mereka di berbagai komentar atau postingan. Untuk membuat informasi ini lebih mudah diakses, detrans.ai mengumpulkan semua potongan tersebar menjadi satu ringkasan dan garis waktu yang mudah dibaca. Semua prompt sistem dicatat di halaman prompt.
Kadang AI dapat menghasilkan halusinasi atau menyatakan hal-hal yang tidak benar. Namun secara umum, cerita yang diringkas adalah refleksi yang akurat dari komentar asli oleh pengguna.
Ringkasan
Saya melakukan detransisi dan kini menggambarkan masa saya mengidentifikasi sebagai trans sebagai fase yang saya lalui. Saya rutin memposting di ruang detransisi dengan argumen bahwa transisi terlalu dipromosikan, bahwa realitas bedah ditekan, dan bahwa penegasan tanpa kritis terhadap remaja berbahaya. Saya menduga disforia bisa berasal dari autisme atau dari mengatasi pelecehan seksual masa kecil, dan saya berharap kisah saya meyakinkan orang lain yang tidak 100% yakin untuk tidak bertransisi. Saya tidak menyatakan label identitas saya saat ini secara eksplisit selain telah melampaui transisi. Tidak ada ide bunuh diri, melukai diri, atau upaya bunuh diri yang disebutkan dalam transkrip ini.
Kisah lengkap
I have been active in detransition discussions since late 2019, and what I say comes from my own experience of transition and from watching others around me. Early on I made the point that when you transition your dating pool shrinks to almost nothing, and I called that an illogical reason to transition — I had clearly thought about the social and romantic costs of going down that road. When people pushed back on how many people transition has harmed, I argued it is not far-fetched that transitioning could have negatively affected a large number of people, and I insisted that this is not the place to gatekeep who transitioning has harmed.
I have been blunt about the medical side. I said that nobody will talk about the sick reality of SRS (sex reassignment surgery), and that a place where that information was readily available got banned because it lacked moderation and hateful comments were left up — I clearly think the raw, unfiltered accounts of surgical outcomes are important and are being suppressed. I have also commented on regret and on how transition is sometimes pursued for reasons that have nothing to do with genuine dysphoria.
On causes, I have speculated openly. I said I wonder if dysphoria can be caused by autism, or whether it just looks similar — I have thought about neurodivergence as a possible contributor. I also described a coping mechanism I believe occurs after sexual abuse: that children often respond to sexual abuse by convincing themselves it didn't happen, and that some may hold a deep belief that if they had a penis the event would not have occurred, so they try to convince themselves they do in fact have a penis. That reasoning suggests I see some gender distress as rooted in trauma rather than in an innate identity.
I have been critical of how trans issues are discussed publicly. I questioned what about a particular article stigmatizes trans people, and I defended the idea that it is fine for guys to wear makeup. I also pushed back on what I see as uncritical affirmation: I said that uber-positivity is part of the problem, that there is no need to validate every feeling, especially during the teenage years. In the same spirit I remarked that sounds like they wanted control when discussing someone's motives, and I made a blunt comment that ugly vaginas exist and it is not misogynistic to call a spade a spade — though I accepted another person's correction when they pointed something out, replying that it didn't even cross my mind and that they were right.
The most direct statement about my own history came near the end of 2019 into January 2020: I wrote that this stuff is often a phase, and that it was a phase for me. I added that if others are persuaded not to transition by these stories, then it is a good thing, because they weren't 100% sure in the first place. That is the core of where I stand — I went through transition myself, came to see it as a phase I had been in rather than who I am, and I now talk openly about it in the hope that people who are not certain will think twice. I have also expressed sympathy for others' situations (simply writing that I am sorry when someone shared something bad) and made practical observations, like noting that 14 is not the age of consent and that it should be 16 because 14-year-olds are dumb.
I have not, in this transcript, given exact ages, dates of my own transition steps, medical details of my own, diagnoses, or specifics about my current identity beyond framing transition as a phase I went through. What I have done is argue publicly, repeatedly, that transition is over-promoted, that the medical realities are under-discussed, and that people who are not certain should be discouraged rather than affirmed.