Semua kisah

Butch lagi, dan tak lagi menjelaskan alasannya

Perempuan · Detransisi193
Cerita-cerita ini telah diringkas menggunakan AI.

Di Reddit, orang sering berbagi pengalaman mereka di berbagai komentar atau postingan. Untuk membuat informasi ini lebih mudah diakses, detrans.ai mengumpulkan semua potongan tersebar menjadi satu ringkasan dan garis waktu yang mudah dibaca. Semua prompt sistem dicatat di halaman prompt.

Kadang AI dapat menghasilkan halusinasi atau menyatakan hal-hal yang tidak benar. Namun secara umum, cerita yang diringkas adalah refleksi yang akurat dari komentar asli oleh pengguna.

Ringkasan

Saya seorang perempuan yang melakukan detransisi, yang kini tampil dengan gaya butch, nonkonformis gender, dan nyaman dilihat sebagai perempuan. Saya tidak membagikan garis waktu rinci tentang transisi atau detransisi saya dalam komentar-komentar ini. Saya memiliki pandangan kritis tentang bagaimana transisi sebenarnya tampak dalam praktik, mencatat bahwa orang trans sering kali tidak tampil sesuai gender yang dituju sebaik yang mereka kira, dan saya skeptis terhadap pertumbuhan gerakan trans yang lebih luas. Saya meremehkan orang yang menilai penampilan saya dan telah mengabaikan permusuhan dari orang lain. Saya tidak membahas penyesalan spesifik, detail kesehatan mental, atau hasil medis dalam materi ini.

Kisah lengkap

I was born female. I identified as trans and lived as a man for a period of time before detransitioning; I have not given a precise timeline of when I first felt dysphoria, came out, started hormones, or had any surgeries in these comments, so I will not guess at those dates. After detransitioning, I've been navigating how the world sees me. At one point I commented on a photo of myself, joking 'You forgot a photo of me,' and elsewhere I've been told I 'look like a woman' and 'don't look trans at all.' I've also reflected on how being visibly butch in the world can come with some of the social advantages people call 'male privilege,' which is something I noticed during and after my transition. I have strong opinions about how transition actually reads in practice. I've said that when I see trans men in person, even ones with full beards, men's clothes, and men's hair, I can still often tell they were born female because of their body shape and how they carry themselves — 'this little dainty, soft, and round body. They carry themselves delicately and it's easy to spot that they are AFAB and are taking hormones.' I've been even more blunt about trans women, saying 'they almost never even slightly pass.' These observations have been some of my most upvoted comments, which suggests other detransitioners or observers resonate with them. I've also thought about the broader cultural moment around transition. After attending pride events in Portland, I noted there were 'A LOT' of people, and I've wondered aloud about the social dynamics driving the trend: 'I just wonder what all these kinda nerdy dudes were all doing before the trans movement really blew up.' That reflects a skeptical view I hold about the rapid growth of the trans movement, particularly among certain demographics. On a personal level, I've dealt with people being judgmental or hostile about my appearance. My attitude toward that criticism has been dismissive: 'Don't have any respect for them. I could care less what some idiot loser thinks of me.' I've also encouraged others facing similar treatment to keep going: 'just keep trying, you'll find the cool gig.' I haven't discussed specific mental health diagnoses, therapy experiences, or the precise reasons that led me toward transition or detransition in these comments. I also haven't spoken about regrets in detail, medical complications, fertility, or my current romantic life. My current identity is that I am a detransitioned female who presents in a butch or gender-nonconforming way and is comfortable being read as a woman.