Summary
In a short editorial, New Zealand mental health nurse Jason Watson builds on his earlier argument that watchful waiting should be the first response to young people with gender dysphoria. He proposes a concrete skill set for that period: distress tolerance, taken from Dialectical Behaviour Therapy (DBT). Distress tolerance is the ability to sit with painful feelings, thoughts and urges without rushing to make them go away or acting on them straight away. He walks through the main techniques: grounding (such as controlled breathing or noticing your surroundings), mindfulness, self-soothing through the five senses, distraction, short-term crisis-survival strategies, acceptance (such as 'radical acceptance') and cognitive strategies like reframing. The goal, he says, is to create 'therapeutic time': calmer, less impulsive young people, so that assessment and careful decisions can happen before anything irreversible. He notes that the idea that seeking medical transition can be a maladaptive way of coping has been suggested but not proven. It is an opinion piece that offers no new data and no trials of these skills for gender dysphoria.
Key findings
- Watson propone la tolleranza del disagio, un insieme di abilità della Terapia Dialettico-Comportamentale (DBT), come strumento pratico con cui gli infermieri possono sostenere i giovani con disforia di genere durante l'attesa vigile.
- Tolleranza del disagio significa essere in grado di sopportare emozioni, pensieri e impulsi dolorosi senza cercare subito di eliminarli o di agire di conseguenza.
- Le abilità che descrive comprendono il radicamento (grounding), la mindfulness, l'auto-conforto attraverso i cinque sensi, la distrazione, le strategie di sopravvivenza alla crisi, l'accettazione (come l'accettazione radicale) e la ristrutturazione cognitiva.
- L'obiettivo è il «tempo terapeutico»: ridurre la sopraffazione emotiva e le decisioni impulsive, così che valutazione e decisioni ponderate possano avvenire per prime, senza dover risolvere subito il problema di fondo.
- Osserva che alcuni studiosi hanno suggerito che la ricerca della transizione medica possa essere un modo disadattivo di far fronte al disagio (Littman, 2018), ma afferma che le prove disponibili non permettono conclusioni definitive.
- Fa seguito al suo precedente editoriale sulla stessa rivista, in cui sosteneva che l'attesa vigile dovrebbe venire per prima quando il consenso informato di un giovane è incerto.
Abstract
This editorial proposes Distress Tolerance (DT), a core component of Dialectical Behaviour Therapy (DBT), as a psychological approach that fits within a Watchful Waiting nursing intervention for young people experiencing gender dysphoria. DT refers to the capacity to experience and manage distressing emotions, thoughts, urges or stressful circumstances without immediately attempting to eliminate them. The editorial describes DT skills and their clinical use: grounding techniques, mindfulness, self-soothing through the five senses, distraction, crisis-survival strategies, acceptance-based practices such as radical acceptance and willingness, and cognitive strategies such as reframing and perspective-taking. It also considers whether gender-affirming medical interventions may represent maladaptive coping, noting that some scholars have suggested this (Littman, 2018) but that the empirical literature offers no definitive conclusions.
Conclusion
Distress Tolerance as a Watchful Waiting intervention provides a potential psychological framework for creating therapeutic time for young people experiencing gender dysphoria, by helping them manage distress without requiring immediate resolution of the underlying issue. DT skills may reduce emotional dysregulation and impulsive behaviour, creating space for assessment, reflection and more considered decision-making.