男性のアイデンティティと誤認された内面化されたミソジニー
女性 · 脱トランジション1180
これらのストーリーはAIを使用して要約されています。
Redditでは、人々はしばしば複数のコメントや投稿にわたって経験を共有します。この情報をよりアクセスしやすくするために、detrans.aiはこれらの散らばった部分を単一の、読みやすい要約とタイムラインにまとめます。すべてのシステムプロンプトはプロンプトページに記載されています。
AIは時々幻覚を見たり、真実でないことを述べたりすることがあります。しかし、一般的に、要約されたストーリーはユーザーの元のコメントの正確な反映です。
要約
私はデトランシションした女性で、自分が間違った体に生まれたと信じさせたのは男性のアイデンティティではなく、学んだミソジニーと身体像の歪みだったと気づきました。摂食障害、大うつ病性障害、オピオイド依存、一度の自殺未遂を経験し、生き延びたのは精神科の薬のおかげだと考えています。異性ホルモンを極端な最終手段と考え、若者のトランジションと無規制の自己調達薬に反対し、デトランシションした人の可視性を唱えています。今はやや男性的な個人スタイルの女性として自認し、トランジションの問題以外ではリベラルだと考えています。他人に根源的な自己受容を促し、どう見られるかではなく自分が誰であるかに集中するよう励まし続けています。
全文
I was born female, and looking back I can see now that what pushed me toward identifying as trans was a mix of internalized misogyny and body dysmorphia. I remember thinking that because I didn't fit in with the girls, that must mean I was a boy in the wrong body. In high school I wore only boxers, didn't own a bra, had short hair, and wore a mix of women's and men's clothing. I had a father who was very supportive of me as a girl and showed me incredible women role models to look up to since I was itty bitty, yet I still ended up with the 'not like the other girls' mentality and thinking I was born in the wrong body. It wasn't until my late twenties that I finally came out the other side of that internalized misogyny.
I don't lay out a specific medical transition timeline in these posts, but I speak from familiarity about testosterone's effects — I noted that testosterone levels can make it physically harder to cry, and I referenced a first-hand account of a woman who lived as male for a few years who said she couldn't cry and all she did on testosterone was smoke weed and masturbate. I've discussed hormones as an 'extreme treatment' and said I'm okay with hormones when therapy and psych meds haven't worked for persistent and unwavering dysphoria, but that it should maybe be a last resort. I've expressed alarm about unregulated self-medication: 'Hormones can be so dangerous, idk how or why anyone can support the unregulated self medication when it's rough enough with close medical supervision.'
I've dealt with an eating disorder — I said I found avoiding mirrors to be a big help with it so I could do all the typical life stuff without bothering with what I look like. I've recommended others avoid mirrors and not look down at their body unless something is medically wrong. I've described myself as naturally flat chested and enjoying 'butching up' when I feel like it, and I only use small mirrors to check my teeth.
Mental health has been a major struggle. I've experienced major depressive disorder episodes — as of October 2023 I said 'I'm in a major depressive disorder episode rn' and was trying to learn to enjoy my own company. I disclosed two suicide attempts by overdose ('toaster bath attempts'), joking that I'm 'a failure' because they didn't succeed, and described the mindset of believing loved ones would be better off without me, comparing it to being inside a burning building where jumping out a 10+ story window feels like the only way out. I've also disclosed being an opiate addict who quit cold turkey. I've mentioned having adverse reactions to around 10 different psychiatric medications, and that psych meds made my life worth living and are the reason I'm still alive. I've also mentioned medical providers being negligent — twice prescribed medications that cancel out my psych meds without knowing until I was 'in shambles.'
On adversity, I've referenced childhood abuse indirectly in encouraging language to others ('the love you deserve that was stolen from your childhood by those depraved scumbags'), but I don't lay out my own abuse history explicitly. I have described male-inflicted trauma and internalized misogyny as the two common factors among FtM detransitioners, paired with the body dysmorphia most young females experience around puberty.
On sexuality and social life, I mentioned not having had sex in over a year as of September 2023. I've discussed internalized homophobia as something to bring to a counselor. I've reflected on friendships: I warned a young person that they might lose their girl friends if they pass as male. I've also talked about how when we perform the version of ourselves people are accustomed to, they'll see us being jovial and believe our suffering has passed.
I now consider myself a woman with a unique style and eclectic self-expression — I still wear boys' clothes pretty regularly and consider myself pretty feminine now even though I wear men's clothes, because when I wear men's clothes they simply become women's clothes since I'm a woman wearing them. I consider myself pretty feminine now. I consider myself a liberal aside from the trans issue.
On regret and outcomes, I don't spell out a specific list of surgical regrets in these posts, but I express strong views about irreversible changes and about the harm of medical transition when poorly supervised. I've referenced harrowing YouTube videos by detransitioners about their SRS. I've advised people to give themselves time before making permanent medical changes, and told a 16-year-old the same. I've said 'natal sex cannot be changed' and that biological reality matters, while also urging people to focus on things outside of their appearance and to pursue radical self-acceptance.
My attitude toward transition for others is conditional and critical: I support it only as a last resort after therapy and psych meds, I'm opposed to youth transition ('Once they're a legal adult, right?'), opposed to unregulated self-medication, and opposed to what I call the 'gender ideology cult' and 'affirm-only' medical culture. I've been active in advocating for detransitioners' visibility, criticizing clinicians and media for being afraid to acknowledge detransitioners for fear of being labeled phobes. I've also been called a TERF for defending a trans woman's right to joke about her own anatomy and was banned from a subreddit over it. In February 2024 I said I would leave a subreddit after my kind words were received poorly, though I continued posting in the community into late 2025.