ホルモンなし、手術なし——それでも自分の身体で生きることを学んでいる
女性 · 断念43
これらのストーリーはAIを使用して要約されています。
Redditでは、人々はしばしば複数のコメントや投稿にわたって経験を共有します。この情報をよりアクセスしやすくするために、detrans.aiはこれらの散らばった部分を単一の、読みやすい要約とタイムラインにまとめます。すべてのシステムプロンプトはプロンプトページに記載されています。
AIは時々幻覚を見たり、真実でないことを述べたりすることがあります。しかし、一般的に、要約されたストーリーはユーザーの元のコメントの正確な反映です。
要約
私は医療的移行は一度もしなかったが性別違和に苦しんだ離脱した女性で、今も時折それを経験しています。ラディカル・フェミニズムのために離脱し、今は身体を人格から切り離し、女性であることが自分にとって何を意味するかを考え直すことで違和を管理しています。私は移行医療に強く批判的で、ホルモンと手術は研究不足で、潜在的に危険で、美容的に一時的だと見ており、他の人に迅速な経路の性別専門家を警告しています。私はトランスだったことはなく、移行関連の処置も受けていません。言及された唯一の医学的問題は24歳のときの持続する目の問題で、医師は手術を勧めませんでした。
全文
I was born female and I have never identified as trans, but I have struggled with dysphoria for a long time. I am desisted, and I still occasionally struggle with dysphoria, though overwhelmingly I just don't think about my body anymore.
What dissuaded me from ever transitioning was a set of realizations I came to on my own: that transition is cosmetic and doesn't actually change your sex, that it is under-researched, that SRS is not even close to resembling a penis and depending on the route you choose can lead to lifelong health complications, and that cross-sex hormones seem to indicate risks of different health complications like tumors. I've managed my dysphoria by addressing what it means to be a woman to me. At the end of the day I realize it's more detrimental to my health to seek these procedures versus reworking in my mind what it means to have a vagina. I realized, simply, that I was putting too much meaning on what having a vagina meant. Although sometimes I still struggle, I now think of my body and my personality as two separate components of my entire being, my femaleness having nothing to do with my more masculine presentation and personality.
I also think it's important for anyone considering transition to understand that pursuing something you can never achieve will most likely never resolve the issues, and to ask honestly how you can claim to know what it means to feel like a different anatomy you've never experienced. I'd ask whether someone is assigning more meaning to their physical body than they should, and to explore why they think so much about their body in relation to their psychology — or whether it's just our culture that pushes the belief that masculinity can only exist in men and femininity can only exist in women.
I'm deeply skeptical of gender specialists. I believe they put people on a fast track to under-researched lifelong changes, and I've said plainly that it is not a stretch to say the procedures they are performing are on par with lobotomizing people. I don't say that to scare anyone; I say it because I believe all of these treatments for transitioning are under-researched, if not straight up dangerous. I also think something that's never talked about is how temporary the treatment is — hormones might make you feel better today, but the cosmetic changes you seek degrade over time with age, so it isn't worth seeking cosmetic changes that hurt your long-term health and are only temporary. I'd urge anyone to try to understand what's causing their dysphoria before doing anything that will impact their health, because you won't feel that dysphoria is worse than any health complication once you're actually in the middle of a health crisis.
I've thought a lot about the surgical and hormonal consequences. I've discussed how cauterizing the vagina is a matter of how much medical trauma you want to be put through in the future, how losing your uterus and becoming more or less menopausal carries its own plethora of potential issues — hot flashes, night sweats, insomnia, chills — and how you'd basically experience menopause 20-30 years earlier than you'd need to and live with it. If you lose your ability to produce estrogen naturally, you'll have to be on one or another HRT drugs for the rest of your life, meaning if you decide to stop taking testosterone you'll still need to supplement with estrogen. I've also noted that it's suspected synthetic sex hormones correlate with different cancers, so it's almost always a safe bet not to take synthetic hormones if you're able to produce your own. I've raised concerns about vaginal prolapse from the uterus not being present causing a weakened pelvic floor.
I'm wary of quitting medications cold turkey too — I stopped taking one of my medications cold turkey a while back and it completely ruined me without me realizing at the time that stopping the med was what caused it. I advise anyone getting off HRT to definitely talk to their doctor, because it's always potentially dangerous to quit something cold turkey without knowing the ins and outs. I also noted that breast growth from hormones won't go away on its own and will typically require some sort of surgery.
On surgery generally, I feel that downplaying the aftercare or potential consequences of surgery is a huge problem in the trans community. I'm only 24 and have had ongoing eye issues, and my doctor advised I go the non-surgical route since I'm so young and surgery on my eye at this stage could cause issues in the future. Almost every doctor I have met with for any issue, who cared about my actual well-being, has advised I don't go a surgical route because of my age and because none of my issues warranted the risk. It's really stomach-churning to me how lackadaisical surgery is treated by both doctors enabling them and the lies that they're easy-breezy.
As for what ultimately led me to desist: I desisted because of radical feminism. I have not done any advocacy or activism beyond sharing my views in online discussions.