自ら脱移行した医師 — かつて選んだ治療に今は反論する
女性 · 脱トランジション656
これらのストーリーはAIを使用して要約されています。
Redditでは、人々はしばしば複数のコメントや投稿にわたって経験を共有します。この情報をよりアクセスしやすくするために、detrans.aiはこれらの散らばった部分を単一の、読みやすい要約とタイムラインにまとめます。すべてのシステムプロンプトはプロンプトページに記載されています。
AIは時々幻覚を見たり、真実でないことを述べたりすることがあります。しかし、一般的に、要約されたストーリーはユーザーの元のコメントの正確な反映です。
要約
私はトランジションをやめた女性です——女性として生まれ、トランジションを行い、その後、手術を受けずにデトランジションしました——そして今は、トランジションに批判的な異性愛の女性であり医師であると自認しています。性別違和は精神疾患であり、医学的トランジションではなく精神科的治療を要すると考えており、トランジションは根本的な問題を解決しないと主張しています。私は政治的には保守的で、トランプの熱心な支持者であり、トランジションを促すうえでの左派と医療体制の役割と私がみなすものに対して、とりわけ子どもに対して、公然と批判してきました。この記述では希死念慮や自傷については述べていません。デトランジションした人には、ジム、瞑想、そして生活の再構築に集中することを勧めています。
全文
I am a medical doctor and I have been posting in r/detrans since at least September 2019. I write from a strongly critical, conservative perspective on transition, and I describe myself as a straight man and an unapologetic Trump supporter on the political right.
I came to my views partly through lived experience: I transitioned at some point in the past, and I later detransitioned. In November 2019 I wrote that what I would want for myself now is 'a detransitioned straight biologically female woman that never underwent surgery and who left most of her issues behind,' which tells me I was born female, transitioned, and did not have surgery during that process. I have also written about going to the gym to 'get your male body back' when advising someone who appeared to have masculinised, and I have spoken about my own experience of gender dysphoria as something I now regard as a medical condition that needs psychiatric treatment rather than transition.
My professional identity matters to how I engage: I repeatedly sign off 'Greetings from a medical doctor' and answer surgical questions as a physician. In September 2019 I reassured someone recovering from top surgery about sensation loss, nipple swelling and possible chest concavity, explaining that nerves take much longer than normal tissue to regenerate and that inflammation after surgery causes swelling. I told them to give it a month or two unless there was an infection.
I hold very strong views about transition, especially for minors. I have argued that transsexual prevalence statistics mean there should statistically be no more than one trans student in a given school, so a school with many trans kids means 'teachers are actively brainwashing immature children into gender dysphoria,' and I suggested the affected families consider a class action lawsuit. I have compared the affirming approach to a cult that isolates you from doctors, friends and family and then shuns or threatens you when you leave. I told a teenager considering a hysterectomy that they were 'making stuff up' to justify it, that they likely did not know what a hysto was at ten, and that removing the uterus would lead to ovarian atrophy and severe long-lasting side effects including cancer. I described the teenager's belief that internal parts did not belong to them as 'classic body dysmorphic disorder' and told them to see a psychiatrist. I have argued that children's brains are not biologically mature and that there is a reason children are not allowed to vote, have sex or drink alcohol, so they should not make permanent medical decisions; I told one teen, 'In 20 years, you will scratch your head and will be wondering how you could believe in the stuff you did as a teen.'
I believe gender dysphoria is a mental illness and that transition does not resolve the underlying problems. I have written that 'Trans is a mental illness. It's called Gender Dysphoria. Ex trans is a step toward becoming mentally healthier,' and that 'I personally don't believe transitioning solves the problem as it won't change the underlying (mental) issues.' I have argued that suicide rates remain almost unchanged after transition, which I take as proof that the treatment does not work, and that 15 years ago a person would have received counselling to help them accept their sex instead of having their body 'destroyed with chemicals.' I have also stated that over 90% of children will eventually leave gender issues behind and accept their sex, illustrated with the story of my ex-girlfriend's little brother who thought he was a T-Rex.
I am politically outspoken. I have said the left hates everyone who goes against its narrative, including detransitioners, and that the left uses trans and LGBT people as tools to divide society. I have argued there is no male privilege and no white privilege, calling both concepts far-left brainwashing. I have defended Trump supporters as accepting of LGBT people and contrasted this with what I described as hostility toward gays and trans people among Muslims, drawing on roughly two decades of living in Europe where I say I met 'countless muslims who described in great gory detail what they would do to gays and trans people if they got away with it.' I have defended participants in monument protests against being labelled white supremacists and dismissed Vox and The Atlantic as 'far left rags.' I have said the College Fix 'massively red pilled me and played a huge role in me leaving the left behind permanently.'
I have posted four threads in r/detrans: one sharing a news story about 'hundreds' of young trans people seeking help to return to their original sex; one titled 'I am a trans woman – but I think this woke world has gone too far'; one asking why the LGBT subreddit trashes people who post on detrans, which I called 'detransphobic'; and one sharing a video titled '"I Want My Gender Back.." - TEEN DE-TRANSITIONERS.'
I have also given practical advice to detransitioners: I recommended working out hard at the gym because it builds self-esteem, discipline and self-awareness and makes you look more masculine and attractive, adding 'Chicks dig both, trust me. Everything else will fall in place at this point. Been there, done that.' I suggested meditation to others as well. I have commented supportively on photos of detransitioned women, calling them 'pretty girl' and saying one looked better without a nose ring and ear piercings. I have described the affirming medical establishment as a cult and said of detransitioners, 'You made the right choice.'
On sexuality and harassment, I have described myself as a straight man, noted that women have slapped my ass and commented on my looks at work, and said that gay men grabbing me at parties was odd but that I like flirty people and find being checked out reaffirming. I mentioned my wife, and that she and her female cousin were sexually harassed by an uncle who later married a woman less than half his age who was still a teen. I have also referred to an ex-girlfriend.
I do not describe any current suicidal ideation, self-harm, or suicide attempts in this transcript. My regret about transition is expressed indirectly rather than in a single explicit statement: I frame my ideal outcome as having been 'a detransitioned straight biologically female woman that never underwent surgery and who left most of her issues behind,' and I advise others that going to the gym will help them 'get your male body back,' implying I have worked to reverse masculinisation myself.