ノンバイナリーとして4年、ホルモンは不要だった
女性 · 断念社会的移行 14 → デジスタンス 18278
これらのストーリーはAIを使用して要約されています。
Redditでは、人々はしばしば複数のコメントや投稿にわたって経験を共有します。この情報をよりアクセスしやすくするために、detrans.aiはこれらの散らばった部分を単一の、読みやすい要約とタイムラインにまとめます。すべてのシステムプロンプトはプロンプトページに記載されています。
AIは時々幻覚を見たり、真実でないことを述べたりすることがあります。しかし、一般的に、要約されたストーリーはユーザーの元のコメントの正確な反映です。
要約
私は14歳から18歳頃まで社会的にトランス/ノンバイナリーとして自認していたものの、ホルモンも手術も一度も受けていない、移行を思いとどまった、デトランジションした(ftmtf)女性です。今は自分を、それを楽しんでいるからこそ女性性を再発見しつつある男の子っぽい少女だと考えており、レーベルを望まずに自分の性的指向(おそらくバイセクシュアル、あるいは異性愛)をまだ整理しています。私はインターネットと同世代のクィア文化が、自信のなさ、不器用さ、遅い思春期、他の少女たちへの馴染めなさを説明する手段として私をトランスの自認へと押しやったと考えています。自分をトランスと見るのをやめ、仕事や外での活動、人と過ごすことに集中したことで、うつは改善しました。今は若者の医療的な移行に批判的で、若い少女たちには何も変える必要はないと伝えたいと思っています。
全文
I've always been an adventurous, independent tomboy kind of girl — I like to hike, explore new places, write and draw, and build entire worlds in my head. I identified as trans (FtM, and sometimes non-binary) on and off for about four years, roughly from age 14 to 18, but I never actually took testosterone — my transition was social only, and I have since desisted.
Looking back, I know I never actually wanted to be a man or wished I'd been born a boy. What I felt was envy toward FtM timelines — especially the pre-T ones, or the pictures of them as tomboy girls before they knew they were trans. I also looked up to fictional women who dressed like boys or defied traditional femininity, like Mulan and Arya Stark.
I never fit in with other girls my age. Not since I was about five years old did I feel like I was one of them, and after puberty they might as well have been a different species. I would have been miserable trying to be as feminine or trendy as everyone around me. People constantly told me they thought I was a lesbian, especially in middle and high school, because I was such a tomboy who loved sports, climbing trees, riding rollercoasters, superheroes, and just being active. I was called gay a lot as a preteen and teenager for not being hyperfeminine. I was also a total nerd — no driving, no dating, no drugs, no sneaking out — basically a square in everyone else's eyes. On top of that, I had a delayed puberty: I was prepubescent until 14 and then looked like an awkward middle schooler throughout high school, which made me feel ugly and immature.
I began identifying as queer in some way — mostly lesbian — at age 13, and I stayed in the LGBT community in some form for five years, until 18. Growing up in that community, being a masculine woman was portrayed as the only way to be strong and cool, while femininity was seen as weak or shallow, so I didn't allow myself to like girly things until I was 18. I rationalized being weird and different by calling myself gay or trans rather than just accepting that I was weird and different. I also didn't think I was pretty enough to be a girl, never mind a straight girl, and I never could relate to the stereotypes of a straight girl or want the classic stereotypical female role in a relationship.
The internet and peer environment played a huge role. Entire friend groups at my middle school, high school, and even my job (with people in their twenties) were trans or LGBTQ+. I watched a single 3–5 minute FtM transition video once and it made me question whether I was trans for weeks. I've come to believe the ideology is like a drug to insecure teenagers, especially girls. It gives easy explanations for the confusion of adolescence — and it stretches beyond trans identity to mental illness labels, neurodivergence labels, and sexuality labels. I also think a lot of young people are trying to escape misogyny and stereotypes: 'Yes I'm wearing makeup and dresses and have a boyfriend but I'm not a DUMB GIRL, I'm a cool BOY,' which is sexist overall. Before the internet, I knew who I was; I hate to say it, but I think the internet can make someone think they're trans who isn't.
What moved me out was largely just stepping away. I completely removed myself from the trans discourse and dismantled the ideas of feminine and masculine — clothes are clothes, and wearing a suit as a woman doesn't make you trans or gay. I started buying and wearing things I liked, without attaching labels like 'girl/boy' or 'masc/fem.' I also got less depressed simply by getting up, going out, working, and talking to people — doing things and focusing on other people worked miracles for my depression. When I stopped identifying as trans and attributing all my problems to that, I had to face the fact that I really hated myself and felt ugly and immature.
I never took hormones or had any surgeries, so I have no medical complications or irreversible changes to deal with. I don't have trauma. I did go through a phase of 'well if I can't transition, nobody can' and would have been considered internally transphobic; now I don't really know how to feel about trans people. I don't want anybody to hurt themselves with experimental drugs or puberty blockers, and I think transitioning pushes the narrative that 'if I'm not a traditional girl/boy, I NEED to become the opposite sex to do/be the things I want.' I've been critical of the 'lesbian masterdoc' — I noted the author ended up realizing she was bi and in denial of it at the time of writing — though I said I'd give it another read for self-reflection.
Sexuality is still something I'm figuring out. I've had huge crushes on male characters, celebrities, and some guys I know in real life, though my only boyfriend was a disaster that lasted a week. I used to like girls too. Depending on whether I identified as straight or gay, I'd only look at the desired gender. I may be bi, but labels feel complicated to me; I'm not even sure I'm LGBT at this point. I don't think I experience comphet. Right now it's more about figuring out things about myself than slapping a label on anything.
Coming out of all this felt like going through the coming-of-age most 13-year-old girls experience, but at 18 — makeup, bras, building the confidence to wear a swimsuit after eight years. I didn't accept that I liked girly things until 18, and now I'm trying to be more feminine just because I enjoy it. I'm back to being a 'girl tomboy' as an adult. I frequently think that if I'd grown up in the 80s like my mom, I'd have been just one tomboy in a crowd of tomboys, it would have been totally normal, I wouldn't have been called gay at 11 or 12, and I'd never have thought I was anything other than a girl — a straight girl at that. Now everything is so black and white: you're either sexualized at 15 or you're trans.
I don't regret any specific medical procedure because I never had one, but I do regret the years lost to the identity rabbit hole and the confusion. I'd do anything to tell young girls they're perfect as they are and don't need to change a thing. I was just barely old enough to have the sense to get out of what I now see as a cult.