すべての体験談

フェムドムの素材が、男性のままでいられると彼に示した

男性 · 断念2850
これらのストーリーはAIを使用して要約されています。

Redditでは、人々はしばしば複数のコメントや投稿にわたって経験を共有します。この情報をよりアクセスしやすくするために、detrans.aiはこれらの散らばった部分を単一の、読みやすい要約とタイムラインにまとめます。すべてのシステムプロンプトはプロンプトページに記載されています。

AIは時々幻覚を見たり、真実でないことを述べたりすることがあります。しかし、一般的に、要約されたストーリーはユーザーの元のコメントの正確な反映です。

要約

私はトランジションを見送った男性で、何年も自分をトランス女性(mtf)だと思っていました。主に性的に受け身であること、女性への共感、そして男性は悪い性であると教えたフェミニストの母が理由でした。約10年前、一晩でデトランシションしました。支配的な女性と femdom のコンテンツに出会い、性別を変えなくても従順な男性でいられることを示されたのです。ホルモンも手術も受けていません。兄、そして1年後に母が自殺で亡くなり、私は10代に深く抑うつでした。今は36歳で自分の男性性に満足している男性で、技術職に就き、子供のトランジションと現代の LGBT 活動に批判的で、他人を助けるために自分の話を共有しています。現在アイデンティティの混乱はありませんが、時折疑念が生じ、検証が難しい関係上の欲求を未解決のまま抱えています。

全文

I've never really told this story in full, but if it helps someone, it's worth writing down. About ten years ago I gradually came to think I was trans (mtf). It's hard to pin down exactly why. I identified with women more than with men. It was most apparent when I watched porn — I'd watch normal porn, but I would imagine myself as the woman, the one receiving. I never made actual plans to transition; I assumed it would be some secret I carried with me my whole life. After a few years I randomly came across F4M femdom porn and it changed everything. Overnight my trans feelings went away and I started feeling comfortable as a man. I came to think the trans thoughts were really caused by being submissive (a bottom) by nature, and the only examples of submissiveness I had ever seen were of women being submissive. I've been happy as a submissive man ever since. I think in my case I just needed an example of how I could be myself — how men don't need to be stereotypical dominant brutes. I later described the process as a slow build: "Maybe the bulk of it happened within a 5 year period." I wasn't certain I was trans, but I was growing more certain over time, and I was sort of anticipating the dysphoria would grow over time — "but then it all stopped." I also said: "I learned how to be submissive as a man, and it made most of the dysphoria feelings go away." I've never had hormones or surgeries; there's no medical intervention in my story at all. When people ask what I feel about my sex I say: "I was born this way and that's that. I don't feel anything about it." And on the question of proof: "I have a penis in my pants. That's all the proof I need." What fed the trans thoughts, looking back: - Empathy across the sex line. I felt I always empathised more with women than men, "as if I was going to be one when I grew up." - Sexual orientation and role. Sexually I never wanted to top. I'd watch porn and always identify with the woman, not the man. It wasn't a turn-on to think of myself as a woman, but it was a turn-on to be a bottom. I don't think I actually have AGP — "the turn on was the idea of getting fucked, not the idea of wearing women's clothing or anything like that. I was attracted to the female role in society more than dressing like one." - Video games. I could play badass female characters where I get to be myself but also look hot. Picking female characters seemed like a no-brainer, especially because they tended to get treated better by other players. - A sense that living as a man was living life on hard mode: "You have to work your ass off and everyone blames you and no one cares about what you go through." - My mother's feminism. I grew up with a feminist mother who told me men are dumb and violent and that we would only have world peace when no more men were in power — that women can do everything men can do and more. I later wrote a whole post about it: "Looking back, being taught that my sex is the bad sex, and the opposite sex is the good sex, it's no wonder I was interested in transitioning." I also recall her saying straight out that men are violent and we'd have world peace if women were in charge: "It kind of explains a lot about how I ended up though." - Male role models who were soft. All the male role models around me growing up were "soft like sheep"; I never saw a man be violent or aggressive, but I did see abusive and manipulative women. - Not having any examples of the kind of relationship I wanted. "Standard" male/female relationships didn't interest me at all, which made things confusing. What pushed me back the other way was contact with actual women: talking to and being around women makes me notice how different I am from them. "Women aren't just a sexy body in a dress. A man can't just put on women's clothing and become a woman. Being a woman is not just skin deep." I also use a trick now: watching YouTube videos aimed at a female audience, something clicks like "oh, that's not for me." Playing a female character in a game is easy — "but that's just skin deep (or pixel deep)." The moment of desistance itself. I've described it a few times: I met a dominant woman and desisted overnight. "Once I accepted that I can be a submissive man my life got way better and I never looked back." We've since parted ways, but the lesson stuck with me. I also told someone else: "Porn helped me with desistance as well. It's odd, but it happens. lol" I place my desistance at about ten years before 2024, and elsewhere I said I "went through my desistance about 10 years ago when things were nowhere near as cringe." How I think about it now. I don't really think about gender; I think more about sex. "From my experience, sex tells you more about a person than gender." I've come to think the idea of a "cis" person is a myth — most people don't feel a gender, they just go with the flow. I think rigid gender stereotypes and expectations can exacerbate dysphoria, and my story helped me accept the range of gender expression within genders. Sometimes we don't 100% fit and that's okay. I decided to stop overthinking it: "I have male parts, so I'm a man. And I have just as much right to claim being a man as anyone who was born male." The real turning point in my self-talk came when I told myself: "I'm an adult male and there's nothing more masculine than being an adult male and that's the end of it." If I do something someone considers feminine, that doesn't change anything. "If I put on a dress I'd be an adult male wearing a dress not a new gender. Not having to fit into categories is liberating." I still get doubts from time to time — thoughts like whether I'm a female mind in a male body. What helps is noticing how women actually behave around other women; when I see how women think and behave I don't see myself in them. Being around women IRL is the corrective. Sexuality and relationships. I'm attracted to women, but I'm a bottom, and it complicates things. It makes me shy away from relationships because part of me thinks the odds of compatibility are so low — "would this woman top me? And how?" All my feelings about what I want in a relationship feel "impossible." I've said: "I'm 35 now and I still haven't really figured it out. Why am I like this? Why do I have to want things that are impossible? Why can't I just be 'normal?'" Maybe people who don't fit in can fit in with each other. I also have a fragile libido: "I'm 36 and I still haven't figured it out. I can be totally in the mood one second and I hear someone say something the wrong way and I get an 'ick' and the libido is gone." My advice to others in that spot is to take things very slow and gradually escalate. Family and adversity. My mother's misandry was formative. Much worse: I lost my brother to suicide, and then lost my mother to suicide a year later. I've said the brother's death didn't involve transition in any way. Those losses left me with a hard-won perspective — "Having difficulty relating is a price I'm willing to pay. I'd rather have that than have other people go through this." I also recall a psychologist telling me there's no way I'm autistic because "autistic people don't have souls and I clearly have a soul. wtf." That's part of why I'm skeptical of therapists: "People put way too much trust in psychologists." Mental health. I was super depressed as a teenager and couldn't even say why, though the depression was real. As a teenager I didn't see myself living into my 20s and couldn't imagine making it to 30 — "I was so miserable I thought for sure I'd die one way or another before then." I'm 34 (later 35, then 36) now and life is better than ever. I'm generally wary of therapy: "Sometimes bad therapy is worse than no therapy," and I think over-analysing yourself is a recipe for unhappiness. What helped me was goals, other people, cutting out sugar (a life-changer even without exercise), and getting my GED and going to college at 30. I work in tech now on a diverse team where the focus is getting the job done. Where I stand now. I'm a desisted, comfortably male, submissive straight man. I don't regret transition because I never medically transitioned — my "regret," if anything, is lost time and the confusion itself. I'm comfortable with my body and who I am: "Maybe in some ways I don't fit in but that's not a me problem." I have feminine traits and I just own them now. On transition for others, I'm critical but not opposed to adult choice. My stated position: encouraging transition in someone who might not otherwise transition should not be allowed; someone of sound mind, old enough to consent, who really feels they must transition shouldn't be forced to stop — but "if someone isn't thinking of transitioning you have no business putting that in their mind." I compare transition to anorexia: not illegal, not a valid solution, shouldn't be encouraged in children, but I don't hate anorexic people. I think puberty blockers and cosmetic mastectomies on children are dangerous, and I've been vocal about parental and medical pressure on kids. I believe detransitioners will have a big role in breaking the cycle of abuse in the LGBT community, and that detrans awareness is going to be a big factor in helping people accept themselves before making drastic decisions. I'm not active in formal activism — in fact I think politics is mostly a narcissist's game — but I do share my story and comment regularly to help others. I'm wary of the LGBT community specifically: "I've witnessed too much toxic stuff coming from the LGBT movement that I recoil at the thought of being included even if I technically am."