ホルモン3年、そしてどちらの生き方もできなかった1年
男性 · 脱トランジション835
これらのストーリーはAIを使用して要約されています。
Redditでは、人々はしばしば複数のコメントや投稿にわたって経験を共有します。この情報をよりアクセスしやすくするために、detrans.aiはこれらの散らばった部分を単一の、読みやすい要約とタイムラインにまとめます。すべてのシステムプロンプトはプロンプトページに記載されています。
AIは時々幻覚を見たり、真実でないことを述べたりすることがあります。しかし、一般的に、要約されたストーリーはユーザーの元のコメントの正確な反映です。
要約
私はデトランズィションした男性で、女性化ホルモンを使って約3年間女性として暮らした後、2019年1月頃に突然やめました。やめたことには正当な理由があったと今も考えていますが、それでもデトランズィションしたことを後悔しています。ホルモンを断ってからの1年以上は人生で最悪の時期でした。男性化が戻り、怒り以外の感情は死に、私は孤立し、鏡を避け、ほとんど家から出ませんでした。死にたいと繰り返し書き、2020年4月には、トランジションもデトランズィションも生きられるものに感じられないので自殺を考えていると書きました。今も性別違和を感じており、再びトランジションすべきか決められず、現在の自分のアイデンティティは未解決のままです。「性別アイデンティティ」をもはや信じていませんが、出生時の性別でも快適に生きられません。私は性別違和は現実であり、トランジションは一部の人を助けると考えつつ、性別アイデンティティのイデオロギーと性別違和の急進的フェミニスト的解釈の双方を批判しています。
全文
I was born male, and I started wondering if I was "in the wrong body" or "should have been born a girl" long before modern trans culture existed, before I even had private internet access, and without knowing any trans people. I experienced dissociation after puberty — feeling as if I were watching from a distant room while "this unfamiliar male robot navigated the world on my behalf" — along with social anxiety and deep despair over my sex characteristics.
I began seriously questioning around 2014 (about five years before my first detransition posts) and started feminizing hormone therapy roughly three years before I stopped, so I was on HRT for about three years. Hormone therapy and social transition genuinely reduced my sex dysphoria: my dissociation and social anxiety dissolved, I felt more embodied and grounded, I was more confident, I enjoyed socializing, and I was making progress in my academic career. I described it like those allergy medication commercials where a dark filter is peeled off the world. I also noticed my attraction shifted somewhat — I had always been attracted to women but became more bisexual after starting HRT and socially transitioning. I never made trans identity my whole identity, kept my distance from the LGBT community, and got involved only to find transition resources.
My crisis began around January 2019. I stopped taking HRT about a month before that post, after roughly six months of taking it on and off, having become inconsistent and skipping doses while swinging between "this is helping me" and "this is unnatural and making me a freak." I stopped cold turkey in about January 2019, roughly six months before my July 2019 post where I described myself as "amab, 24 y/o" — which puts my birth year around 1994-1995. I had not socially detransitioned; I still felt more comfortable presenting as a woman.
What pushed me toward stopping was a mixture of exhaustion and self-hate. I was tired of anxiety about passing that kept me from going out, tired of trans identity being a political football, and tired of seeing how the world would see me regardless. I hated being associated with the outspoken, obnoxious trans activists and figures like Jonathan Yaniv — a post about him in July 2019 drew strong reactions, and I later edited it to say I regretted it. I also developed a habit of hate-reading hostile spaces: itsafetish, right-wing subreddits, /pol/, and GC forums. I came to believe dysphoria wasn't real, that I had been conned by overzealous doctors, and that everyone I knew hated me anyway. I described feeling "pressured/influenced into stopping" in the way some detransitioners describe being influenced into transitioning.
The year off hormones, from January 2019 through at least April 2020, was the worst year of my life. Physically, my skin became oily and rough, body hair darkened and coarsened, new facial hair came in, fat redistributed away from my chest, hips and face, I had breakouts, thinning hair and male-pattern hair loss that gave me anxiety attacks, and my libido and anger both increased markedly. Breast growth was the one change that did not revert. Mentally, I felt depressed, irritable, quick to anger, emotionally deadened except for anger, numb, dissociated, and anxious. I avoided mirrors, showered in the dark, barely left the house, isolated myself from friends, and often cried in the shower. I wrote that I could not remember the last time I felt truly happy after stopping HRT, while I vividly remembered happiness before.
I never socially detransitioned and continued presenting as a woman, which made the mismatch worse. I missed the friends I made when I presented as female and could not bring myself to tell them what was happening. I also lost touch with old interests — I had been a theater kid, did acting and tech, played music and written, and wanted to do visual art, but those things fell out of my life when school got intense around 11th grade and never came back.
I was stuck at a crossroads, changing my mind every few days. I could not retransition because I believed I would never be a woman, that trans people had no future, that I would never have a stable career or find love, and that long-term hormones might give me a stroke, blood clot, breast cancer or dementia. I could not stay detransitioned because it felt like a lifetime of mental pain. I worried the year off had caused permanent masculinization I could not forgive myself for.
I did not pursue therapy, saying a psychologist would just uncritically call it "dysphoria" and put me back on hormones. I had supportive friends and family but began doubting whether their support was authentic. I had no stated history of formal mental health diagnoses, but I described long stretches of depression, dropping out of school, and burnout in my academic career.
On April 4, 2020, I wrote that I kept thinking about suicide, saying that if the world would give me this condition, punish me for transitioning, and then make detransition unbearable, "then it's not a world I want any part in." Earlier, in December 2019, I had written that if my whole life would be an irreconcilable struggle against dysphoria, "I'm ready for it to end," and that I was "tired. Ready for it to end." I also described detransition at one point as feeling like the self-harm rather than transitioning.
My views on transition for others are mixed and conditional. I believe sex dysphoria is real, that transition shouldn't be the only treatment, and that some people are genuinely helped by it — while also believing current diagnostic criteria are watered down and that many people without classical sex dysphoria are being pushed toward medical intervention and hurt by it. I criticized both gender identity ideology and radical feminist attempts to explain dysphoria away as ideologically motivated. I pushed back on people using detransition narratives as political leverage, told a parent not to dismiss their daughter's dysphoria, and argued that detransitioners should take responsibility rather than just blame "the trans community." I have not described any formal advocacy or activism of my own.
As of my most recent comments in mid-2023, I was still grappling with the question, advising someone else that only dysphoria exists, not an essential "transgender" identity, and that what matters is deciding what is necessary to address your dysphoria while accepting the consequences of each step. I described myself as believing sex and gender incongruence are real while "being transgender" is a culturally specific expression of it, and concluded that "it's ultimately on us, as gender-variant people, to decide what myth serves us best."