すべての体験談

r/detransに何年も、他者に医療化をやめるよう助言

女性 · 脱トランジション74
これらのストーリーはAIを使用して要約されています。

Redditでは、人々はしばしば複数のコメントや投稿にわたって経験を共有します。この情報をよりアクセスしやすくするために、detrans.aiはこれらの散らばった部分を単一の、読みやすい要約とタイムラインにまとめます。すべてのシステムプロンプトはプロンプトページに記載されています。

AIは時々幻覚を見たり、真実でないことを述べたりすることがあります。しかし、一般的に、要約されたストーリーはユーザーの元のコメントの正確な反映です。

要約

私はかなり年配の r/detrans の長年の参加者で、何年も性別違和を管理して過ごし、今は他人に、トランジションを病状にすることなく、明晰さを求め、自分自身をすべての中心にしないよう助言しています。数学の能力の限界から理論物理学を諦めた後、プログラミングの仕事をしており、共感を自分の職業上の強みとしています。医療制度がデトランシションした人を治療することへの抵抗に批判的で、責任を法的リスクと WPATH におけるデトランシションのガイドラインの欠如に負わせています。バランスは自分への集中ではなく、コミュニティへの関与と外の諸問題から生まれると考えています。心理療法と、摂食障害、自傷、性別違和を結びつけるポッドキャストを勧めています。

全文

I first found r/detrans back in September 2018, when it was still a small community - I remember checking web.archive.org and seeing only about 22.5k readers around 2021, and I've watched it grow since. I'm quite old now, and I've spent so much time and energy over the years trying to manage my dysphoria by centring myself, when I could have been doing good things for others instead. Looking back, I realise that periods when I was focused on good things - at work, volunteering, helping out in a community - were also the periods when I was much less affected by the dysphoria. When I was young I desperately wanted to work in theoretical physics, but it became clear that my maths skills were never going to allow that to happen. I went into programming instead, and I've been able to support scientists and scientific projects during my career, as well as working in the government and commercial worlds. I'm basically happy with what I've been able to achieve, but I've had to come to terms with my limitations and work with them. One thing that has become clear is that my greatest strength as a programmer is my empathy for the user of the tools and services I have worked on. I actually feel distress when I see an inhumane interface or process. I see things which are literally invisible to my (almost exclusively male) colleagues, to the point that I've frequently been ignored or patronised when making suggestions. I tend not to get much credit for things, because many of the suggestions I've made are obvious in hindsight, so they become invisible very quickly. I've come to believe that having skills which might often be described as stereotypically feminine can often be akin to a superpower when applied in areas where those skills are rare. On medical transition, my advice to others is blunt: stop taking T if you hate everything that comes with transition. I told someone they're not a fake, and they never have been - they had a question which they felt they needed to answer, and now they have an answer: transition is not for them. That's not being fake, it's having clarity and self-knowledge. I've said there will be reasons why a person has been unhappy, reasons that can run deep, and that there are ways to find peace with yourself which don't involve medicalisation. I've also warned people not to be bullied or gaslit by partners who can't handle them making their own decisions. I'm critical of how the medical system handles detransition. I've explained that while there may be an ideological aspect to being turned away, it's mostly about liability: transing people has an official process with 'standards of care', and provided a doctor can show they at least gestured towards following WPATH guidelines they are much harder to sue for malpractice. There are no equivalent guidelines for detransition, so no way to deflect responsibility. Like transition, detransition really requires a team - endocrinologists, psychologists, surgeons - and insurers need to be on board. Networks of professionals working to help detransitioners is rare. Everyone involved is potentially liable if any of them admit they've made mistakes, which makes them resistant to treating people they have harmed. Denying transition regret is important if any of these people ever needs to justify in court carrying out damaging treatments on gender confused patients in the past. I suggested finding a doctor who has never been involved in transgender treatments. I've also been critical of therapy being withheld: ruling out exploratory therapy for anyone who needs it is to deliberately prolong and deepen people's mental suffering. I called it evil. On gender expression generally, I've said that while some female-positive presentations through strange kinds of presentation are 'a bit cringe, and more than a bit ridiculous', I'd much rather people like that have their fun, use whatever labels they want, and show that you can express yourself however you want without needing to medicalise yourself. Ultimately it's a female being positive about being female. If more people felt comfortable playing around in a basically harmless way, maybe fewer people would end up damaged and regretting their decisions. I admitted that dealing with this kind of thing is something I struggle with as well. My core advice now is about balance: find an external activity or cause that makes 'self' fade into the background - helping at a children's hospice, animal shelter, hospital, charity. It wouldn't be good to become dependent on external factors to feel OK, but a lot of the problems people have with accepting themselves as they are is that they're trying to do that without situating themselves in society. We can't function outside of social connections. Trans society seems to constantly centre the self and that's unhealthy for literally anyone. My motto: 'Look after yourself, but don't centre yourself.' I've recommended the Beyond Gender podcast, particularly an episode featuring Deanne Jade, founder of the UK's National Centre for Eating Disorders, discussing the 'golden thread' between eating disorders, self-harm and gender dysphoria as socially reinforced behaviours that persist despite harm.