Surgery at 18, revision avoided for six years
女性 · 脱トランジション146
これらのストーリーはAIを使用して要約されています。
Redditでは、人々はしばしば複数のコメントや投稿にわたって経験を共有します。この情報をよりアクセスしやすくするために、detrans.aiはこれらの散らばった部分を単一の、読みやすい要約とタイムラインにまとめます。すべてのシステムプロンプトはプロンプトページに記載されています。
AIは時々幻覚を見たり、真実でないことを述べたりすることがあります。しかし、一般的に、要約されたストーリーはユーザーの元のコメントの正確な反映です。
要約
私はデトランジションした女性で、10代でトランジションを行い、18歳で膣形成術を受け、現在はもうすぐ24歳です。私は『二度死んだ』ように感じています——一度はトランジションによって元の自分を殺したとき、もう一度はトランジションの絶頂期にいた無邪気な自分を失ったときで、今は元に戻せない変化を抱えて行き詰まっていると感じています。排尿が今では困難と痛みを伴うため、必要な修正手術を6年近くも先延ばしにしており、それを直せる外科医は主にトランス患者を扱っています。実生活でデトランジションする人に一度も会ったことがないため、私は孤独で孤立していると感じ、トランジションに関連するトラウマは日記を書くことで処理しています。私はデトランジション研究の質とサンプルサイズをめぐる議論に参加し、デトランスの空間がトランスフォビアだと主張されることに対してそれを擁護しています。
全文
I was born female and I transitioned as a teenager, coming out and beginning my medical transition while still a minor. I had bottom surgery — vaginoplasty — when I was 18. I am nearly 24 now, so I have been living with the results of that surgery for close to six years.
I feel like I have died two times. When I initially transitioned as a teenager, I killed off my old self, who I really was. Now I also grieve the person I was during the height of my transition, because I was naive and the ignorance genuinely was blissful, whereas facing reality is not. I feel like I have become an entirely different person for the third time, and I feel stuck in something I cannot undo and cannot unsee for what it really is. I don't know myself or how to perceive myself when everyone around me seems to be falling into place, which is a weird and isolating experience.
I went into transition with unrealistic expectations about certain aspects that I treated as absolutes but that were actually built on subjectivity. I have struggled to pinpoint what causes someone to be trans or where dysphoria stems from — whether it is metaphysical, mental or emotional, physical or developmental, or innate, or some combination. I think the conclusiveness people ascribe to many aspects of this worries me, because we are only at the peak of understanding it.
I have put off a necessary revision surgery for nearly six years. It has now gotten to the point where basic functions like urinating are causing difficulty and pain, and I need help to fix it. Most doctors who have experience fixing this kind of complication exclusively work with trans patients, which leaves me navigating whether to pretend to still be trans, be honest, or whether it even matters. It also feels like reopening an old wound. I have had frustrating encounters with surgeons in this field — I know how horrid a surgeon Dr. Gallagher is, even within the trans community.
I have struggled to get adequate medical care here in the US; it honestly feels like I am forgotten and expendable. I have also dealt with people claiming that spaces like detrans communities are transphobic cults, and I have defended these spaces against such claims.
I journaled for the first time in a long time, writing about transition-related trauma and about every facet of childhood I still think about and how they are interconnected with the struggles I have now. That experience made me feel lonely and isolated — I have never met a detransitioning or questioning person in real life, though I know I am not truly alone. I cannot always vent about every specific feeling and experience I have had, either to others in person or online. Journaling was extremely therapeutic and felt like a healthy step in finally processing everything that has happened; it helped me get my memories and thoughts out in an objective and organized way, and I hope to look back on those entries one day to see how I have grown. I think journaling every day could make one depressed, so I plan to space it out.
I care about the integrity of detransition research. When someone was kicked out of a study or survey, I said this would lead to inflated and skewed statistics and false claims that detransitioning is rarer than it is, since surveys rely on self-assessment and participation. I have also argued about research methodology: I maintained that a good sample size is not purely subjective, that reliable and verifiable data needs hundreds to thousands of patients over years through repeated trials, and that applying data to general populations of millions, a sample size of 68 people is extremely small and not representative — while acknowledging that for an initial trial it gives insight and an immediate need for more research. I cited the central limit theorem and typical initial trial ranges of 20-80 patients in support of my argument.