すべての体験談

慢性疾患、そして医者と共に過ごす一生

女性 · 脱トランジション275
これらのストーリーはAIを使用して要約されています。

Redditでは、人々はしばしば複数のコメントや投稿にわたって経験を共有します。この情報をよりアクセスしやすくするために、detrans.aiはこれらの散らばった部分を単一の、読みやすい要約とタイムラインにまとめます。すべてのシステムプロンプトはプロンプトページに記載されています。

AIは時々幻覚を見たり、真実でないことを述べたりすることがあります。しかし、一般的に、要約されたストーリーはユーザーの元のコメントの正確な反映です。

要約

私はデトランジションした女性で、低い自尊心と「男の子のもの」への愛着をもって育った後にトランジションし、今は医学的トランジションは絶対的な最終手段であるべきだと他者に警告しています。自身の慢性疾患を踏まえ、医師、手術、薬局通いの生涯にわたる負担を描写し、トランジションは人の恋愛と性の見通しを劇的に制限すると考えています。私は自分自身と他者に自分を許すよう促し、制度的なもの、専門家、社会的/政治的潮流が——私たちではなく——私たちをトランジションへと押しやった真の責任を負っていると論じています。子どもへのトランジションには今も批判的で、性別違和のある子どもの約90%のデシスト率を引用しています。私の後悔は失われた時間、社会的損失、医療制度への縛りに集中しており、日々それと向き合い、理想的には同情的な非ジェンダー肯定のセラピストとともに取り組んでいます。

全文

I have been posting in this community since late 2019, mostly encouraging other people who are detransitioning or questioning transition, and in doing so I have gradually revealed pieces of my own story. I was born female. As a youth I had low self-esteem and I liked "boy things," but I wrote that "it never ever occurred to me that I *was* a boy" — partly, I believe, because the society around me at the time was pushing an entirely different message than the one young people receive today. I now describe myself as having been "temporally unlucky," coming of age at a moment when, in my view, gay rights organizations had won their main battle and needed a new cause, and when wealthy older trans donors helped launch the next one. I transitioned and later detransitioned, though I have not laid out the exact dates of those steps in what I have written here. What I have been open about is the aftermath: I described my "current situation" in early 2020 as truly sucking, and I referred to people who "faked friendship" with me, which suggests a period of social loss and betrayal. I also wrote about struggling with feelings of being a "freak" and worthy of contempt, and I told others in the same position that being misled into a "misguided course of action" doesn't make someone a freak — it makes them human. I repeatedly urged myself and others toward "one day at a time" coping and suggested finding a sympathetic therapist; I also floated EMDR for old, buried trauma, and cognitive behavioral therapy with a "not-gender-therapist" as options worth considering. A major theme of my writing is self-forgiveness. I told one person in my situation that institutions and people who should have been gatekeeping "utterly failed in their duties towards people like you and your parents," that they were "forced to make decisions that you had neither the maturity nor the life experience to make," and concluded, "In short, forgive yourself. You knew not what you did." I made the same argument again later: "When it comes to deciding who's at fault for your situation, you're nowhere *near* the head of the line. I hope you can forgive yourself for the mistakes of your youth and move forward." I framed the mistake as a product of "a confluence of social and political trends" and said "The 'experts' lied and you believed them... it certainly wasn't a sin and you're not alone." I also have a chronic medical condition, which I have referenced repeatedly as the basis for warning others about medical transition. I wrote that as someone with a chronic condition I can say "being tied to the medical establishment sucks," describing "unending doctors' appointments, lab tests, and surgery," post-surgical pain management being limited because doctors are "scared of addiction," and the daily burden of fitting life around doctor/therapist appointments and pharmacy visits. My advice to people considering transition has been consistent: "Medical transition should be an absolute last resort," it will "tie you to the medical establishment for life," it will "drastically limit your romantic/sexual possibilities," and "you probably wouldn't end up as the pretty lady of your dreams - most transitioners don't." I have also warned that physical transition limits romantic and sexual choices because "Gay guys aren't generally attracted to trans-guys" and "the surgical options aren't the best." On the broader question, I have been openly critical of pediatric and adolescent transition. I have cited the figure that "~90% of dysphoric children will grow up to be healthy (often gay/lesbian) adults at peace with their birth sex" and asked why society would "medicalize that 90% for the sake of 10%." I have argued that body dysphoria in dysphoric kids "fades as one nears neurological maturity," that in a different social environment such feelings might be "successfully channeled into (less destructive) transvestism rather than a succession of surgeries and a life-long dependence on the medical establishment," and I disputed claims that gender-affirming surgery doesn't happen to under-18s, saying I'd read published accounts of it. I have also commented on a case involving chronic pain "from something that's not even there any longer," calling it evidence of "costs to this madness," and I wondered aloud whether a girl's transition might have gone differently if her parents had been "just a bit less accepting and a bit more ... inquisitive." I have not written explicitly about my sexuality before or after transition, about fertility, or about specific surgeries I may have had. I have not described any activism beyond posting in this community. Overall I would say my regret is real and tied to lost time, social losses, and being permanently enmeshed with the medical system, but I have also been working steadily toward forgiving myself and moving forward, one day at a time.