ともに疑問を抱き、そして友人がホルモンを始めるのを見た
女性 · 断念最初の性別違和 12 → デジスタンス 201269
これらのストーリーはAIを使用して要約されています。
Redditでは、人々はしばしば複数のコメントや投稿にわたって経験を共有します。この情報をよりアクセスしやすくするために、detrans.aiはこれらの散らばった部分を単一の、読みやすい要約とタイムラインにまとめます。すべてのシステムプロンプトはプロンプトページに記載されています。
AIは時々幻覚を見たり、真実でないことを述べたりすることがあります。しかし、一般的に、要約されたストーリーはユーザーの元のコメントの正確な反映です。
要約
私はデシストした女性で、大学で社会的トランズィションをしましたがホルモンは一度も使わず、2022年1月頃にデトランズィションしました。自分のディスフォリアは内面化された女性嫌悪とオンラインのトランスコミュニティへの深い没入から来ていると気づいたからです。一緒に疑問を抱いた後にホルモンを始めた親しい友人に影響を与えたことに大きな罪悪感を感じ、その結果からいくつかの友情を終わらせました。デシストした後、自分は死ぬに値すると短く考え、料理中に自傷の侵入的思考がありましたが、今は自殺念慮はなく、時間と彼氏のおかげだと考えています。ディスフォリアは今はほぼ消え、自分の身体に心地よさを感じますが、見た目はジェンダー非順応のままです。今はジェンダー廃止論的で中道的な立場を持ち、より慎重な医学的アプローチを支持しつつ、一部の人は実際にトランズィションで恩恵を受けると信じています。
全文
I was never girly as a child — a tomboy through and through — and my parents pressured me to be feminine, which I resented. One birthday my mom gave me an expensive hairbrush I had no interest in, and I felt I had to pretend to appreciate it. People always told me I'd 'grow out of it,' which never happened. I developed gender dysphoria starting around middle school, before I really knew what being trans was, and it mostly went away after a few years. It came back in a short wave during my last year of high school, when I remembered a friend who had come out as trans in middle school.
I started reading more about being trans and partially convinced myself that could be me — I fit the characteristics, and the trans community indirectly suggested being trans was the only cure and that they were all super happy. Once I learned what gender dysphoria was, the old dysphoria came back and I felt miserable for months, obsessing over my appearance and longing to be the opposite sex. I came out as trans to my parents at about 17; they questioned me in what felt like an interrogation, insisting girls can look and do whatever they want, which I hated hearing at the time even though I now think they were right.
For my first year of college I lived in the LGBT dormitory because I identified as trans, went by male pronouns, and was desperately trying to affirm myself and find my footing as a guy. I only socially transitioned — I never took hormones. There I met a detransitioned woman who had applied to the dorm when she identified as trans. At the end of the school year she made a PowerPoint about detransitioners' experiences; when she posted it to the group chat people said it made them uncomfortable and she took it down, then the dorm turned on her behind her back, mocking her and making cruel jokes. I had secretly desisted myself by then, and witnessing how quickly the community turned on one of its own severely stressed me — I cried myself to sleep for multiple nights. It made me realize the people there only liked me for who they thought I was.
What actually helped me most was meeting that detransitioned radical feminist and talking with her over a few months; I slowly crawled out of the trans identity shell and realized gender doesn't matter and I could look however I wanted and still be a woman. I also realized my dysphoria was rooted in internalized misogyny and discomfort with my developing female features after puberty — discomfort that lasted at least five years after puberty. Exploring the trans community had intensified my dysphoria dramatically: I browsed trans subreddits for hours a day, sometimes four hours a day, feeling miserable the whole time but unable to stop because those communities gave me hope for a cure. Learning to call my discomfort 'dysphoria' made it worse, and it made me more sexist in other ways, seeing gender roles as a hard box when society is actually far more flexible. I had no diagnosed mental health disorders, though I later reflected that I was 'extremely mentally ill' during that period of my life.
I detransitioned around January 2022. My family was actually far more supportive of me stepping back than they had been of my social transition, which had distressed them. Most friends and even coworkers were kind — people said things like 'I just want to call you what you want to be called.' The only people who weren't supportive were my friends from the trans community: someone in a group chat called me a 'fallen soldier,' my prior best friend approved that comment, and they insinuated I was just repressing. I wrote a carefully worded letter to a trans friend asking him to reconsider why he transitioned; he showed it to his friends and they called me transphobic.
I feel real guilt about a close friend who transitioned. He never had gender dysphoria before, but when I started talking about discovering the trans community he began developing dysphoria for the first time, and eight months after we started questioning together he started hormones. I cut him out of my life partly from guilt and partly because I didn't feel treated as a friend. I also ended a friendship with a childhood friend of over ten years who now identifies as trans; he outed me as detrans to others when I'd told people privately, and I still think about him almost every day two years later. I worry I 'spread' ROGD to him and that he probably didn't need to transition. I know I was also an asshole while I was transitioning, caught up thinking anyone who didn't believe in trans ideology was evil.
After I first desisted I had harmful thoughts: I thought I deserved to die because my views contradicted a movement I cared about, and I internalized memes saying 'repost this and a transphobic person will die.' I never wanted to actually hurt myself, but while chopping vegetables I'd have intrusive thoughts about how I could hurt myself with a knife, which made daily tasks terrifying. I no longer have suicidal ideation or those thoughts — time and having my boyfriend around made me feel safer. My dysphoria is now mostly gone; it's been about two years since I had major dysphoria about my physical characteristics, and while I don't love my body I'm comfortable in it. I still have short hair, wear shorts and t-shirts, and I'm still recognized as a woman — sometimes I'm called 'sir' from a distance based on my haircut and style, but people recognize I'm female once they hear my voice.
I now identify as a desisted woman and see myself as a gender abolitionist who believes gender equals sex. I consider myself a centrist on the issue: I think the medical system needs a more careful, nuanced approach to prescribing hormones, that therapy and worldview reorientation should come before permanent body modification, and that hormones and surgery should be last resorts. I believe legitimate trans people who benefit from HRT exist. I've been active in detrans communities, encouraging questioning people to be introspective, spend less time online, and consider internalized misogyny or homophobia as root causes. Online debate has taken a real toll on my mental health — I've felt exhausted and hurt being called transphobic for nuanced views — but people in person have generally been kind and willing to listen.