6年間、他者の脱移行を助言して — そして彼女が議論を拒むもの
男性 · 脱トランジション84
これらのストーリーはAIを使用して要約されています。
Redditでは、人々はしばしば複数のコメントや投稿にわたって経験を共有します。この情報をよりアクセスしやすくするために、detrans.aiはこれらの散らばった部分を単一の、読みやすい要約とタイムラインにまとめます。すべてのシステムプロンプトはプロンプトページに記載されています。
AIは時々幻覚を見たり、真実でないことを述べたりすることがあります。しかし、一般的に、要約されたストーリーはユーザーの元のコメントの正確な反映です。
要約
私はデトランスションした者で、少なくとも2019年からデトランスション支援コミュニティで活動しており、他者に実践的な医学的助言や脱毛の助言を提供する一方、トランジション前に徹底的で時間をかけた医学的・心理的見極めを主張しています。私は医療のゲートキーピング文化に懐疑的で、トランジションに関連する苦しみの量が私の予想より速く増えていると考え、detransサブレディットは政治ではなくデトランスションした人々の支援に集中すべきだと主張しています。私はトランジションに一律に反対しているわけではありませんが、適切な評価が多くの悲劇を防げただろうと論じています。記録には、私の現在のアイデンティティ、病歴、精神状態を述べるのに十分な情報が含まれていません。
全文
I have been active in detransition support spaces since at least mid-2019, and my comments show both the practical advice I give to others and how I think about the broader situation.
In July 2019, someone asked me about passing after stopping testosterone. I told them honestly that I thought they would do reasonably well — that they might look a bit androgynous at first, but that with time, fat redistribution, and possibly laser on darker hairs, they could do well. I emphasized the medical side: just because someone stops testosterone doesn't mean their natural estrogen production will bounce back, so I urged them to see an endocrinologist or at least a GP and get hormone levels checked regularly over a few months to confirm they were recovering properly. I also recommended clean diet and regular exercise to help redistribute fat and regain shape. I followed up with practical hair-removal suggestions — epilators (noting that once you get serious, the pain isn't so bad), home optical pulse devices, and products I associated with 'effeminate gay dudes,' while advising them to research each option themselves.
I've thought a lot about the medical system's role in this. In July 2019 I pointed out that only a minority of physicians actually take the Hippocratic Oath and it isn't expected of them, citing a Becker's Hospital Review article about millennial physicians opting for alternatives. That reflects a skepticism I hold about medical gatekeeping and the culture around transition medicine.
By July 2019 I was also struck by how quickly things were escalating publicly: I commented that I never expected to see something filmed before 2025 or 2030, saying 'the tide of suffering is rising so much faster than ever I anticipated.' In September 2019 I argued that a particular case should be recorded and that the community should crowdsource funding for it — I care about documenting these outcomes.
In November 2019 I responded to someone who had received an extremely hostile message. I told them plainly that the sender was 'a seriously ill individual,' noting that even my powerlifting friends and the rougher guys from my jiu jitsu gym — mostly blue-collar guys who find transsexuals absurd and tell ugly jokes — would never write anything like that. I said this was not normal or common, that the sender was melting down under life's suffering and turning it outward, and that the recipient had handled it impressively. I also made clear I have no desire to bring politics into the subreddit and that I firmly believe the space exists to support detrans folks only, moving any political discussion to private message or another subreddit.
I've also engaged with the idea of discernment in transition. In November 2019 I commented on someone's phrase 'because I just wasn't ready,' calling it an interesting assumption I wasn't sure what to make of. Later that month I praised something as 'genuinely cool,' saying that if we can get across the idea that discernment is difficult and requires time and a thorough medical and psychological process, most of the problem can go away and many tragedies stopped. That is essentially my position: I'm not against transition categorically, but I believe it requires careful, time-intensive medical and psychological evaluation to avoid harm.
The transcript does not include details about my own ages, dates of dysphoria, coming out, hormones, surgeries, or detransition timing, my mental health history, sexuality, or family situation — those specifics aren't present in these comments, so I won't invent them.