すべての体験談

高アンドロゲン、そして間違った世代との紙一重

女性 · 断念194
これらのストーリーはAIを使用して要約されています。

Redditでは、人々はしばしば複数のコメントや投稿にわたって経験を共有します。この情報をよりアクセスしやすくするために、detrans.aiはこれらの散らばった部分を単一の、読みやすい要約とタイムラインにまとめます。すべてのシステムプロンプトはプロンプトページに記載されています。

AIは時々幻覚を見たり、真実でないことを述べたりすることがあります。しかし、一般的に、要約されたストーリーはユーザーの元のコメントの正確な反映です。

要約

私はデトランスィションに近い立場の味方です — トランスィションは一度もしておらず、成人した人間の女性として自認することに心地よさを感じる30歳の女性です。アンドロゲンが高く、顔と体の毛がかなり多く、10代前半に服用した避妊薬に関係しているのではないかと疑っており、剃毛とホルモンバランスについての読書で対処しています。10代の頃、不安、ホルモンの変化、性暴力のなかで毎日死にたいと思う気持ちを抱えていました。もし自分がZ世代だったなら、トランスィションに巻き込まれていたかもしれないと考えています。若者の医療的トランスィションと肯定のみのモデルに強く批判的で、法的規制を提唱し、Gender HQのようなリソースを共有しています。支えてくれる夫と結婚しており、デトランスィション以降、自殺念慮や自傷は報告していません。

全文

I have never transitioned — I'm an ally to detransitioners, and I've posted that openly. I'm a woman who has never taken cross-sex hormones or had any gender-related medical procedures, and I identify comfortably as an adult human female. I just turned 30 as of March 2020. I remember being a tween and a teenager and wishing for death daily for really no discernible reason — general teenage angst, hormone rollercoasters, and sexual abuse all factored in. I've said that if I'd been born in Gen Z, I could very easily have been one of these kids swept up in the transgender tide during that period. I can't imagine what would have happened if I'd been offered what I called a "golden ticket of changing my identity to solve my problems." I've never been diagnosed with a formal mental health condition in these posts, but the daily death wishes in my teens are the most significant mental health detail I've shared. I have frustrating hormonal imbalances — high androgens, heavy facial and body hair, and I've joked I could be a Robin Williams impersonator or grow a ZZ Top-worthy beard if I were so inclined. I suspect the imbalance might stem from birth control taken early in my teen years shortly after puberty, though I say "who the heck knows." I've been reading a book called The Hormone Cure to look at hormone balances, while noting it doesn't really address the unique hormonal imbalances that come with detransitioning. I also reacted strongly to a mention of spironolactone, saying I'd never found so much validation in my life. I shave my arms — I only recently started again after a few years off, during which approximately zero people gave them a second glance — and I make shaving more embarrassing parts of my body part of my daily self-care routine. I'm married to a husband who accepts me for everything I am, including my hormonal imbalances. I've tried to reassure other women dealing with body and facial hair that there are people who will love them for who they really are. On transition and youth medicalization, I'm strongly critical. I shared the Gender Health Query / Gender HQ resource as an evidence-based understanding of the "over-medicalization" of transgender youth, saying its information needs to get into the hands of the medical community, media, schools, and parents, all of whom I believe are allowing kids to be preyed on by the affirmation-only model of care. I've said the science is not settled and I want to shout that from the rooftops. I posted an analogy comparing kids on puberty blockers, hormones, and surgeries to letting 12-year-olds enter a permanent marriage, and asked why we encourage kids to do this. I've also argued that if you wouldn't trust your teenager to take care of a puppy alone, you shouldn't trust them with the cognitive capacity to transition. I've discussed the politics around this, noting many bills being proposed to restrict youth transition and keep MtFs out of girls' school sports, mostly getting 'aye' votes from Republicans while Democrats brand them as "hate." I said I'm seeing lifelong Democrats switch to voting Republican over this issue and that I'd love to see both parties take an honest look at the facts. I consider myself a fiscal and social leftist who nonetheless believes allowing children to medically transition is wrong. I've contacted legislators to urge them to support these bills. I've also said I don't think I check off enough intersectional boxes for my opinion to matter to certain groups, and I'm inclined to think they're an affirmation-only safe space. I'm open to learning about whether hormones affect the mind, and I've floated the idea of treating dysphoric youth with hormones that match their sex rather than cross-sex hormones, while admitting I don't know how much hormones have to do with the mind. I've suggested voice training or seeing a speech-language pathologist for detransitioners disappointed with their new voice. I believe gender and biological sex are inextricably linked, but that gender expression can be as unique as the individual, their preferences, culture, or even their mood that day. I think the affirmation-only approach is damaging and that calling a reasonable approach "transphobic" is just a way to shut down conversation.