移行しなかったシス男性、傍らから見つめる
男性 · 断念483
これらのストーリーはAIを使用して要約されています。
Redditでは、人々はしばしば複数のコメントや投稿にわたって経験を共有します。この情報をよりアクセスしやすくするために、detrans.aiはこれらの散らばった部分を単一の、読みやすい要約とタイムラインにまとめます。すべてのシステムプロンプトはプロンプトページに記載されています。
AIは時々幻覚を見たり、真実でないことを述べたりすることがあります。しかし、一般的に、要約されたストーリーはユーザーの元のコメントの正確な反映です。
要約
私は移行しない非宗教的な男性で、支援と学びのためにr/detransを訪れており、自分をトランスと名乗ったことのないシス男性だと位置づけています。宗教系の私立学校で育ち、つらい感情を抑えることを学びましたが、今は自分の感情能力を鈍らせていたことが不健全な対処法だったと認識しています。政治的にはほぼすべてで民主党に賛成ですが、ジェンダーと性の問題への最近の執着と私が感じる点は別です。証拠が対立するときは移行を支持する主張にも反対する主張にも懐疑的で、制度と経済の圧力に一部動かされていると見る脆弱な10代への医学的移行には批判的です。デトランスした人や迷う人には率直で思いやりのある助言を心がけ、さらなる医学的介入よりも根底にある不安に対処するよう促しています。
全文
I was born male and I have never identified as trans — I've said plainly, "I was never trans, I'm here to be supportive and learn." I came to r/detrans as an outsider who wanted to understand what people there were going through, and I've tried to offer steady, practical encouragement whenever someone posts in distress.
I grew up in a religious private school setting, and I've described that environment as one where you "just kinda learned not to have the kind of feelings they were not equipped to deal with, then suffered silently while daydreaming about prison camps." My coping strategy back then was to try to intentionally blunt my capacity to feel pain about any of it, which I now look back on and recognize wasn't a healthy cope. I don't think I ever had dysphoria myself, but that upbringing left me with a strong sense of how institutions handle uncomfortable emotions by suppressing rather than addressing them.
Politically I describe myself as nonreligious and an atheist, and I say I still agree with Democrats on just about everything "except the weird sex stuff they have made into their number one priority since the early oughts." I remember when the party was mainly about labor protections, and I've been critical of how gender ideology has, in my view, crowded out other concerns. I've been skeptical of claims made on both sides — for example, when someone cited a Heritage Foundation report I immediately flagged the source's agenda, and when studies about "trans brains" conflict I've noted that the science seems to shift over time "based on what the narrative requires."
On the substance of transition, I've argued that genuine dysphoria is real and that most trans people are genuinely dysphoric, but I also think outsiders who fetishize crossdressing and sissification blur the lines. I've told people that pursuing happiness through crossdressing is fine as long as they make no demands of strangers for participation or affirmation. I'm critical of what I see as premature medical intervention, especially for vulnerable teens — I've called the current social situation one where "militant gender ideology and vulnerable teens being psyoped into irreversible surgeries seems like the plot to a Cronenberg film, except we're living it." I've also commented on the financial and institutional pressures on doctors, suggesting there was "basically a gun to the doctor's head, and a fat sack of cash" to go along with transitions.
When someone who has detransitioned or is questioning has written to me, I've tried to be direct and compassionate. I told one person, "Genetically, you're a woman. You produce, or produced, female gametes," and urged them to address the underlying anxieties rather than pursue further surgery, adding that "there is a brighter tomorrow, from which you may one day look back on the past and present with knowing relief, but only if you make it there." I've also advised someone that HRT would make their wish to "just want to be loved and feel comfortable" harder, not easier, and encouraged gay men to take care of themselves and lean into the roles the gay community already offers rather than reinventing the wheel. I've been encouraging about small baby steps, about fitness and emotional health as lifelong projects, and about not letting a youthful mistake feel like the end of life: "Life isn't over. For you it has barely even begun. Your best years are ahead of you, and the past no longer exists."
I don't have personal regret about transition because I never transitioned, but I take other people's regret seriously and I've tried to be a supportive presence for them. I've also drawn parallels between how detransitioners are quietly scrubbed from affiliated websites and how pastors or theologians who apostatize are treated by their own institutions.