19歳のTumblrファンダム——そしてはっきりと見えるようになるまでの10年
女性 · 断念96
これらのストーリーはAIを使用して要約されています。
Redditでは、人々はしばしば複数のコメントや投稿にわたって経験を共有します。この情報をよりアクセスしやすくするために、detrans.aiはこれらの散らばった部分を単一の、読みやすい要約とタイムラインにまとめます。すべてのシステムプロンプトはプロンプトページに記載されています。
AIは時々幻覚を見たり、真実でないことを述べたりすることがあります。しかし、一般的に、要約されたストーリーはユーザーの元のコメントの正確な反映です。
要約
私は18/19歳頃に社会的移行を行ったものの医療的な移行は一度も受けず、約10年間移行を思いとどまっている、移行を思いとどまった女性です。私は自分の移行をTumblrのファンダム/ファンフィクションのコミュニティに帰しており、そこでトランスの思想と拒食症が、影響を受けやすくおそらく自閉症の同世代の間で広がりました。今は自分がトランスだったことは一度もなかったと考えています。2024年、経口避妊薬をやめたことで月経が戻り、違和感と男性への驚くべき嫉妬が戻りました。それらは重いPMDD様の症状と関連しています。私は他の人の移行について、微妙で、おおむね支持するが批判的な見方を持ち、外部からの影響やエコーチェンバーに対して警告しています。私はデトランジションへの後悔は報告しておらず、その変化を安堵として語っています。
全文
I am a female desister who identified as trans and socially transitioned around age 18/19, but I never medically transitioned. I have been detransitioned/desisted for around a decade as of 2024. I now describe myself as a cis woman and believe I was never truly trans.
My transition happened during a period when I was heavily involved in Tumblr fandoms and fanfic communities (I was into Doctor Who). I believe the same circles on Tumblr were spreading both anorexia and trans ideas, and that many of the people involved, including me, were autistic — which made us more impressionable, less firm in our identities, more uncomfortable in our bodies, and more likely to feel we didn't fit our assigned social roles. During those years it seemed like everyone in those circles was trans, anorexic, and had every mental or emotional disorder listed in their bios. I think social interactions and community played a huge role in my identity formation, which I did not understand at 18/19 but am starting to see now that I'm approaching 30.
I don't think being trans or gay is something people choose in the vast majority of cases, but I do believe that people thinking they're trans when they're not is becoming more common. I think the idea that I was 'never trans' is simply easier to understand and accept, and it shapes how I think about my own journey. I respect that some people are truly and permanently happier post-transition and that there's no way to guess from the outside who is 'actually trans.'
I experienced some of the less extreme negative consequences of trans ideology without medically transitioning. I've noted that the word most associated with this phenomenon is so closely tied to TERF ideology that I avoided using it, but found it accurate. I'm critical of extreme online discourse on both sides — I've said I have opinions that would get the mainstream LGBTQ community to 'send me to the gulags,' and I've also called one website 'a very one sided anti trans website.'
Around 2024 I stopped birth control (which I'd been on for basically the entire decade since detransitioning) due to side effects, and my period returned. The return of my dysphoria surprised me: my periods are horrible, and during the worst symptoms I feel trapped in my body and envious of men for not having to deal with it. I frustratedly note I can't tolerate the natural state of my body. I don't believe in God, but said if I did I'd think He was punishing me for existing as female. I also feel society infantilizes women. I said it's clear why so many young girls feel gender dysphoria — being female sucks sometimes, especially with women's health issues — and that if I could trade places with a man or be born male I probably would, though I don't think I feel that way at all on birth control. I was on an IUD at one point without realizing it had a 'high androgen index,' which caused pattern hair loss on my hairline and new facial hair; I stopped it a few months before that comment and it improved. I later noted I was on an antidepressant that interacts with my new birth control.
I've been supportive of others exploring transition at their own pace ('it's never too late,' 'no sense in rushing it'), while also worrying when I see people being swayed externally rather than arriving at decisions for internal reasons. I encourage others to separate rhetoric from personal experience, focus on how they can live happily rather than whether they'd 'truly' be a given gender, and step away from TikTok and internet echo chambers. I've advised someone distressed about their chest to give it time and try to feel neutral before considering surgery. I've quoted Kung Fu Panda to encourage presence and patience. I don't regret my detransition; I've described the suddenness of these shifts as a relief and expressed appreciation for the detrans community.